Mariners Outfield Search Could Ride On One Unfinished Former Top Pick

As the Seattle Mariners weigh the pros and cons of acquiring Dylan Crews, questions arise about whether the underperforming outfielder can finally find his footing in the big leagues and deliver on his once-promising potential.

The Mariners are being linked to another outfield name, and this one comes with a familiar Seattle twist: a player with tools, pedigree, and just enough uncertainty to make the fit interesting.

Dylan Crews has surfaced as a “popular name in trade talks” in multiple reports, including from Washington Nationals beat writer Spencer Nusbaum of The Athletic. For Seattle, that kind of buzz matters because Crews checks a lot of boxes the club tends to value - right-handed bat, above-average range, and enough versatility to make him useful in more than one spot.

Crews is not some anonymous trade chip, either. The 24-year-old was the No. 2 overall pick in 2023, starred alongside Paul Skenes on Louisiana State University’s College World Series team, and arrived in pro ball with the kind of reputation that usually points toward a long runway. Raised in the suburbs of Orlando, FL, he came into the game as a polished prospect with a mature approach, strong contact skills, athleticism, and the kind of offensive profile that made him look like a safe bet.

That’s also what makes his current situation so notable. Through 225 big league games, Crews has hit .217/.285/.363 with a 79 wRC+. Those numbers don’t match the hype that followed him from LSU to the draft, and they help explain why Washington might be willing to listen.

The concern has been there for a while. Before the 2024 season, Baseball Prospectus described him as one of the best collegiate position prospects since Adley Rutschman, praising his bat-to-ball ability, strike zone judgment, and all-around athleticism. The warning sign was buried in the scouting report: a tendency to hit the ball on the ground, which could keep the power from fully playing.

That issue has followed him into the majors. Hard grounders can still be useful, but they don’t give a hitter the same margin for error as balls lifted into the air. For a player expected to bring more than just contact, that’s the difference between a useful regular and something more.

Washington tried to address it this year by sending Crews to Triple-A Rochester at the end of spring training after disappointing 2024-25 campaigns. The assignment was aimed at mechanical work and getting the ball in the air more often.

Crews worked with Rochester hitting coach Shawn O’Malley, with guidance from Nats minor league director of hitting C.J. Gillman, who is now the Mariners hitting coach.

The result was the best minor league stretch of his career by expected outcomes, and it earned him a May return to the majors.

Even so, the jump never fully arrived. In 109 games and 443 plate appearances, Crews posted a .223/.289/.374 line with an 82 wRC+. That’s better than his earlier major league work, and it came without the oblique injury that slowed him in 2025, but it still leaves plenty of room for debate about what he really is at this point.

And that debate is exactly why he’s in the rumor mill.

There are reasons to believe in the upside. Crews cut his groundball rate by more than 10% from the year before, struck out 24.2% of the time, and posted strong barrel and hard-hit rates.

His xwOBA also came in more than 20 points higher than his actual production. If you want to see a player still adjusting to swing changes and not yet getting the results to match the underlying quality, Crews gives you that case.

There are reasons to hesitate, too. His walk rates have been modest since turning pro, and the profile that once made him look like such a complete threat may not be translating cleanly against big league pitching.

The concern isn’t just contact. It’s whether enough of the damage is coming against the right kinds of pitches to hold up over time.

For Seattle, the cost would be real. A deal would likely require moving one of its starting pitchers, almost certainly Bryce Miller or Emerson Hancock, based in part on value frameworks put together by Federal Baseball. That’s a steep price for a player who won’t reach arbitration until at least 2028, even if the appeal is obvious: a will-be-25-year-old with a strong defensive floor, the ability to cover every outfield spot, and enough pedigree to make him a legitimate long-term piece.

Baseball Prospectus is more optimistic, projecting Crews as a league-average hitter by its Deserved Runs Created+ metric, which accounts for the shape of his contact rather than just the results. If that version of Crews is the real one, then Seattle would be getting a regular with upside still left to unlock.

That’s the decision point for the Mariners. Crews fits the roster logic.

He fits the developmental track. He even fits the coaching connection, with C.J.

Gillman now on Seattle’s staff. But the bat still has to carry enough weight, and if this is the kind of move that ends up defining the season, the risk is obvious.

Seattle may like the idea of Dylan Crews. The harder question is whether it wants to pay for the version of him that still has to prove it.

In Other News...

Mariners Fans Have A New Reason To Worry About That Donovan Trade

The Mariners got a useful look at Brendan Donovan after bringing him over from St. Louis in a three-team deal that sent Tai Peete to the Cardinals and Ben Williamson to the Rays. In 39 games with Seattle this past season, Donovan hit .277 with three home runs, but injuries kept him from giving the club the kind of extended run it hoped for when the trade was made.

Tai Peete has only added to the sense that this deal could become a talking point for years. The young infielder has been productive in the Cardinals minor league system and carried that momentum into the Arizona Fall League, where he won Offensive Player of the Year honors and helped his team to a championship, giving Seattle fans a fresh reason to wonder how this one might age. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners Just Got One More Reason To Spend Like Contenders

The Mariners may have a little more room to operate than previously thought as they look ahead to 2027. Ryan Divish of The Seattle Times reported that Seattle could be working with a payroll in the $175 million to $180 million range, a step up from earlier projections that had the club closer to $165 million to $170 million. For a front office that has spent years trying to thread the needle between contention and caution, that kind of shift matters.

A bigger budget would not guarantee a splash, but it would widen the list of possibilities if Seattle decides to act like a team ready to push deeper into October. Names such as Seiya Suzuki and Adrian Morejon would fit the kind of upgrade the Mariners could chase, and the club also has trade assets that could create even more flexibility. Jerry Dipoto has usually leaned on trades more than major free-agent bets, so the real question is whether this added spending power changes the way Seattle approaches its next big roster move. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners Prospects Just Gave Fans A Telling Offseason Snapshot

The Arizona Fall League wrapped up with a championship for the Peoria Javelinas, who beat the Surprise Saguaros 8-3 at Peoria Stadium, and it offered a useful offseason snapshot for the Mariners. Seattle had a strong presence on the title team, with Brandon Eike, Ty Cummings, Reid Easterly, Calvin Schapira, Matthew Ellis, Boston Smith and Adam Smith all part of the roster that finished on top.

For a club that has spent the fall sorting through young talent from the 2024 and 2025 MLB Drafts, the result matters beyond the trophy itself. The AFL is often where organizations get a cleaner read on how prospects handle advanced competition, and this group gave Seattle plenty to evaluate as the winter begins, even if the bigger question is how much of that momentum can carry into next season. [Read more 🡒]