Josh Naylor’s first season under a five-year, $92.5 million deal has left the Mariners staring at a problem they didn’t expect when they brought him in to stabilize first base and strengthen the middle of the order.
On the surface, the numbers look useful enough. Through Sept.
11, Naylor had 142 hits, which led the team. But the shape of those hits tells a far less flattering story: 112 of them were singles.
He also ranked fifth on the club with 192 total bases. That spread says more about his season than his .265 batting average does.
Seattle wanted a long-term answer at first base, and for a brief stretch, it looked like they had found one. Naylor’s first 54 games with the Mariners in 2025 made the contract feel easy to justify.
He hit .299, slugged .490, drove in 33 runs and added nine home runs. He also played with the kind of edge that made him an immediate fit.
Then came the drop-off.
In 137 games this year, Naylor has hit 10 home runs. He finished 2024 with 31.
He produced nine homers in 54 games after arriving in Seattle last season, then managed just one more in 83 additional games this year. His slugging percentage has fallen to .359, and his run production has flattened out with it.
The Mariners needed more from the largest position-player free-agent commitment of the Jerry Dipoto era, especially with the club sitting at 581 runs through Sept. 11, the lowest total in the AL. Naylor has still done some things well.
He has put the ball in play. He has battled through at-bats.
And he has continued to run far better than anyone built like a refrigerator has any right to run, with 26 stolen bases after 30 last season. But those skills don’t solve the core issue: a first baseman slugging .359 is not anchoring an offense.
Seattle has also seen enough to know this isn’t just about the ballpark. T-Mobile Park is the easy scapegoat whenever a Mariners hitter loses power, but Naylor’s split doesn’t point that way.
He has hit five home runs at home and five on the road. Statcast put him at 10.8 expected homers.
His average exit velo has dropped to 87 mph, and his barrel rate sits at 4.3 percent. The hard contact simply hasn’t been there.
There is at least one reason the Mariners can point to if they want a more hopeful read. Naylor’s right wrist has been part of the picture.
He missed two straight starts in June because of wrist soreness, and the issue surfaced again in August when he was held out after visibly grimacing during swings. He had only five home runs through May, before the problem became public, so the power dip was already underway.
Still, the discomfort may have made it harder for him to correct course.
That leaves Seattle in an awkward spot. Naylor has four more years on the contract, and he also has a full no-trade clause, which makes any quick exit unrealistic. First base is already spoken for financially, so the Mariners need to look elsewhere for the power they’re missing - whether that comes at DH, in a corner outfield spot or through another move entirely.
The club can’t simply wait around for Naylor to “get back to normal” and call that a plan. But it also doesn’t have to write him off yet.
One poor season doesn’t automatically turn the contract into a dead end. An offseason of rest and treatment could help restore some force to his swing, and if he gets back to the hitter who slugged .490 in those first 54 games, that version of Naylor becomes a bonus rather than the answer Seattle is forced to build around.
The first season of the deal has already made one thing clear: the Mariners can’t count on that version to solve the problem for them.
In Other News...
Mariners May Need A New Manager For One Frustrating Reason
Dan Wilsons first full season in the dugout has given the Mariners a familiar kind of frustration, the sort that invites a bigger conversation about direction rather than just one bad night. His hands-off style has been part of the discussion from the start, along with the way he has managed the bullpen and handled player accountability, and those choices have left some wondering whether the club is getting enough in-game edge when the margins get tight.
Nothing has been decided, and there is no official change on the horizon, but the possibility of a reset is hard to ignore when a season starts feeling like a referendum. If Seattle does move on, the next manager will likely need to bring a firmer strategic presence and a clearer command of the game, because the Mariners seem to be weighing not just results, but whether the current approach is the right fit for what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Trade With Rays Just Got Tougher To Defend
The deal that sent Randy Arozarena to Seattle looked cleaner for the Mariners when it was built around long-term upside, but Tampa Bay keeps finding ways to make its side of the trade look smart, too. Brody Hopkins is now being called up and added to the Rays 40-man roster after a role change from starter to reliever turned his season around, a reminder of how often Tampa squeezes value out of pitchers other clubs might have given up on.
Hopkins has flashed a fastball that has touched 102 mph, and the results in relief have been much better than what he showed as a starter, with his ERA and WHIP both moving in the right direction. For Seattle, Arozarena has been a productive bat since arriving, but the bigger picture still tilts toward Tampa Bay, which has already locked up a playoff berth while the Mariners have spent the year fighting for ground in the standings. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Suddenly Have A Tough Bullpen Decision With Eduard Bazardo
A rough extra-inning finish on Friday night put Eduard Bazardo back in the spotlight, and not in the way the Mariners wanted. The right-hander has been part of a bullpen that has had to absorb plenty of scrutiny this season, but his second-half struggles have made his place on the staff look less secure as Seattle keeps sorting out its late-game options.
Bazardo is still in the mix with Michael Rucker for what could be one of the more interesting bullpen jobs heading toward 2027, but the Mariners are also operating with several relievers already under control. That gives the front office some flexibility, and it also means Bazardo may not just be competing with one arm for his next role if Seattle decides the group needs a broader upgrade. [Read more 🡒]