The Mariners’ search for a new manager keeps shrinking, and not because the field is getting more attractive. With Stephen Vogt now off the board, Seattle’s next skipper appears likely to be either Joe Espada or Jason Kanzler - a shortlist that tells you just as much about who passed on the job as it does about who might take it.
Vogt had at least one thing going for him that made him a natural fit on paper. He got his coaching start with the Mariners in 2023, and he and his family live in Olympia.
That made the possibility of a return to the Pacific Northwest feel real in a way it didn’t for Carlos Mendoza or Rocco Baldelli, both of whom also declined the Mariners’ opening. Mendoza chose a coaching job with the Philadelphia Phillies, while Baldelli also said no earlier this week.
According to Daniel Kramer of MLB.com, the Guardians “were open to allowing Vogt to explore the opportunity with the Mariners.” That possibility never got far. The Mariners reportedly never contacted him, and Vogt publicly committed to Cleveland last week.
From Cleveland’s side, the setup made sense. Vogt signed an extension before the 2025 season, and the Guardians had reason to expect that Seattle might come calling.
He had a direct connection to the organization, and a return home would have carried obvious appeal. But for that to happen, Seattle would have needed to navigate a rare trade situation, and none of it advanced.
The bigger question is why Vogt would have left a good thing in Cleveland. He’s in a stable place with a front office led by Chris Antonetti, and even with the Dolans not known for big payroll splashes, he’s had plenty to work with. The results are hard to ignore: three straight AL Central titles.
Seattle offers a very different picture right now. The Mariners are coming off a 76-86 season, and the changes go well beyond the dugout.
Whoever takes over will be walking into a reset that includes culture, roster construction and a front office trying to patch a lot of holes at once. Randy Arozarena and J.P.
Crawford could be leaving, and the bullpen needs help too. All of it has to be handled, as usual, with limited resources.
Kramer also reported that Dipoto and Justin Hollander will have “the final say” on the Mariners’ next manager. Even that comes with uncertainty, since there’s still a question about how long either man will be running the baseball operation.
Dipoto was already hinting at job-security concerns in late September. If his status changes next year, the person he hires now may not be long for the job either.
That’s the bigger issue hanging over Seattle’s search. Vogt looked at Cleveland and saw comfort, continuity and a winning infrastructure.
The Mariners, by contrast, look like a team in the middle of a messy transition. It’s not hard to see why he stayed put.
In Other News...
Cal Raleighs Slide Created A Mariners Question Fans Cant Ignore
Cal Raleigh entered 2025 with the kind of reputation that makes him one of the most valuable catchers in the game, backed by the Platinum Glove he won the year before and the steady two-way value Seattle has leaned on. But the season has brought a different conversation around him, one centered less on his power and presence in the middle of the lineup and more on how much his all-around game has slipped from that elite standard.
The offensive dip is only part of the concern for the Mariners, because Raleighs defense has also taken a noticeable step back and theres no easy explanation attached to it. Injuries may have played a role, but the bigger question for Seattle is whether this is a temporary downturn or the start of a longer decline from a catcher who had looked like one of the safest anchors on the roster. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Just Sent An Early Offseason Signal With Three Roster Calls
The first offseason moves from Seattle were more revealing than dramatic, and they offered a quick glimpse at how the front office is sorting out its next roster. Andrs Muoz will remain a late-inning fixture after the club exercised his option for 2027, while the Mariners moved on from options tied to Bryce Miller and Victor Robles as they began trimming down the roster picture.
Muozs return keeps one of the teams most important arms in place, but the decisions around Miller and Robles underline how much remains unsettled as Seattle heads deeper into the winter. Miller still stays under club control, while Robles now enters free agency, and the Mariners 40-man roster has already been cut to 34 players as the organization keeps reshaping the group around its core. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Manager Search Is Down To A Debate Fans Know Well
The Mariners managerial search has reached the familiar stage where the names start carrying their own arguments. Joe Espada and Jason Kanzler are being discussed as the leading options to replace Dan Wilson, and the conversation around the fit is already doing what these debates always do in Seattle: turning into a referendum on experience, upside and what kind of clubhouse voice the organization wants next.
Nothing has been made official yet, which keeps the door open on how this all finishes. The front office could still widen the field after the World Series, and that leaves the decision in a holding pattern for now, with the club balancing what it wants immediately against whatever else might surface once the postseason noise dies down. [Read more 🡒]