As spring training unfolds, it's tempting to ride the waves of excitement or disappointment. Yet, amidst the buzz from Peoria, the Seattle Mariners have a standout storyline: Brennen Davis.
Davis, who joined the Mariners on a minor league deal with a spring training invite, is turning heads in the Cactus League. He's gone 5-for-8 with two walks in four games, showcasing power with all five hits going for extra bases, including two homers and three doubles.
Originally a second-round pick in the 2018 draft, Davis was the Chicago Cubs' top prospect as recently as 2022. His current performance might make Mariners fans hopeful that they've struck gold.
But let's temper that excitement with a dose of reality.
Davis' Journey: A Familiar Tale
While Davis' potential is undeniable, he's 26 and yet to make a major league appearance. His career has been a rollercoaster of promise and setbacks. Notably, he's dazzled in spring training before, posting a 1.455 OPS in 2022 and 1.583 in 2024 with the Cubs, albeit in limited at-bats.
His power is his calling card. Back in 2022, Baseball America highlighted his swing's leverage and potential for plus power.
His minor league stats are decent, with a .242 average and .792 OPS over seven seasons. However, his .211 average and .731 OPS in Triple-A suggest caution.
Balancing Hope and Caution
Davis shone last year with the Yankees' organization, hitting .271 with a .975 OPS in the minors, including .248 and .900 in Triple-A. Yet, durability remains a concern.
Injuries have plagued him, including a fractured ankle and back issues requiring surgery. He's played no more than 71 games in a season since 2022.
Despite being named MVP in the 2021 All-Star Futures Game, Davis' career has been a mix of brilliance and fragility. As impressive as his current form is, it's wise to hold judgment.
While Davis' hot streak with the Mariners is encouraging, a cautious approach is warranted. His talent is undeniable, but consistency and health will determine if he can finally make his mark in the majors.