Mariners Left Key Prospects Exposed After A Telling Deadline Choice

With the Rule 5 Draft deadline passing, the Mariners strategically bolster their bullpen depth by signing two former Mets pitchers, betting on their potential for future success.

The Mariners spent the Rule 5 protection deadline doing something a little different: instead of clearing room on the 40-man roster, they used the day to stock up on non-roster arms.

On Monday, Seattle agreed to a minor league contract with a spring training invite for right-hander Stephen Nogosek, according to Ari Alexander of 7News. Then on Tuesday, Will Sammon of The Athletic reported that right-hander Bryce Conley got the same deal.

Both pitchers come with Mets connections. Nogosek, 31, made 33 appearances for New York across parts of four seasons from 2019 through 2023.

Conley, 32, was called up by the Mets in August, but he never got into a game before being designated for assignment two days later. He’s still waiting on his MLB debut.

Neither pitcher arrives with much prospect buzz attached. Of the two, only Nogosek ever earned a Baseball America mention, and that came nearly a decade ago when he was ranked as the Boston Red Sox’s No. 27 prospect entering 2017. Between them, Nogosek and Conley have logged 471 minor league appearances, and both carry career ERAs in the 4.00s.

Nogosek did show something this year in the Mexican League, even though he didn’t pitch in affiliated ball. He posted a 3.69 ERA and a 7.0 K/BB ratio in 46 appearances.

Seattle also appears to like the shape of his fastball. Like fellow non-roster addition Isaac Mattson, Nogosek’s heater has strong induced vertical break that helps it stand out.

For the Mariners, these are low-risk bets on two bullpen arms with a little bit of history and not much to lose. If one of them turns into another useful Jerry Dipoto relief project, great. If not, the cost is minimal.

What Seattle did not do on Tuesday was protect anyone from the Rule 5 Draft.

The club entered the day with 39 players on its 40-man roster, leaving space to add at least one player. One option was outfielder Carlos Jimenez, whom MLB Pipeline has ranked as the organization’s No. 25 prospect. Instead, he remains exposed to the draft, along with other names who could draw interest, including former top prospect Michael Morales and Hunter Fitz-Gerald, who was the most overlooked extra-base hit machine in the minors this season.

That could mean the Mariners simply didn’t view any of those players as worthy of protection. It could also mean they’re betting on the Rule 5 Draft not happening at all.

It’s set for December 9, but that comes after the league is likely to lock out the players. The last time that happened, in 2021, the Rule 5 Draft was delayed and eventually canceled after the lockout ended in March 2022.

In Other News...

Mariners Trade Buzz Around Logan Gilbert Just Got More Serious

Logan Gilberts name is starting to come up more often in trade conversations, and that alone says plenty about where the Mariners stand as they weigh their pitching depth against their long-term plans. Even with Gilbert under contract through 2027, other teams are reportedly poking around, which is no surprise for a durable front-line starter in a market that always values controllable pitching. For Seattle, the question is less about whether there would be interest and more about how willing the club would be to even listen.

The Mariners, though, do not appear eager to move him, and that reluctance is part of what makes this situation worth watching. There is already speculation that Gilberts future could still be tied to Seattle through an extension, while other arms such as Bryce Miller, Emerson Hancock and George Kirby are viewed as more realistic trade candidates if the front office decides to make a bigger move. For now, Gilbert remains the pitcher other clubs want most, and the Mariners are the ones deciding how far they want to go in protecting him. [Read more 🡒]

Royals Trade Return Could Reshape More Than Fans Expected

A possible Bryce Miller-for-Maikel Garcia deal would give the Mariners a very different kind of return than the one most fans might have expected. Garcia brings the sort of defensive versatility Seattle has long valued, with the ability to handle multiple infield spots and potentially give the club more flexibility as it pieces together its roster for the next step.

For a team that has spent plenty of time trying to balance run prevention with enough offense, Garcias fit is the interesting part here. The trade would not just be about replacing one arm with another piece, but about how Seattle chooses to shape the rest of its infield and lineup around a player whose value comes from doing a little bit of everything well. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners Blockbuster Just Complicated A Cubs Rotation Fix

The Cubs already knew their 2027 rotation picture could get tricky, with several current arms on track for free agency and the front office expected to keep scanning both the trade and free-agent markets. Trevor Rogers has been mentioned as a possible fit, and so have trade candidates like Reid Detmers, but the list of realistic pitching targets can shift quickly once other clubs start moving pieces of their own.

A recent Mariners-Royals deal is one of those moves that can ripple beyond the teams directly involved, because Seattle had been one of the clubs on Chicagos radar for possible pitching help. The timing matters even more with Jason Kanzler now in place as Cubs manager, since a new voice in the dugout can influence how aggressively the organization wants to reshape the roster and how it prioritizes a rotation fix over the next couple of years. [Read more 🡒]