Mariners Facing a J.P. Crawford Dilemma as Opening Day Looms
The Seattle Mariners have long relied on J.P. Crawford as their everyday shortstop, but this spring, his limited action raises concerns just days before the season opener.
Crawford, now 31, has only appeared in seven Cactus League games due to a sore right shoulder. The Mariners are taking precautions, consulting renowned orthopedic surgeon Dr.
Keith Meister. Although initial imaging showed no significant damage, the team is keen to ensure the right treatment plan is in place.
Despite the looming season start, Mariners GM Justin Hollander isn't overly worried, stating that surgery isn't a likely option for Crawford. However, with Opening Day just eight days away, the situation remains precarious.
The Impact of Crawford's Absence
Crawford entered spring training as a steady, if unspectacular, component of the Mariners' lineup-a lineup with high expectations at the top. His role was to provide stability, batting lower in the order, and supporting a lineup with some uncertainties. With a .345 OBP and 108 OPS+ over the past five seasons, Crawford isn't a lineup centerpiece but is crucial for maintaining momentum.
Yet, his current spring performance is lackluster, going just 2-for-16 at the plate. Defensively, Crawford's performance has also waned since his Gold Glove year in 2020, with noticeable issues in throwing strength and accuracy late last season.
Who Steps Up If Crawford Can't Go?
If Crawford begins the season on the injured list, the Mariners face a conundrum at shortstop. Colt Emerson was a strong candidate a month ago, but his limited Triple-A experience and spring stats-batting .250 with one homer and nine strikeouts in 15 games-make him a less viable option right now.
Brendan Donovan could fill in temporarily, but he's not a long-term solution at short. Cole Young, primarily a shortstop in the minors, is pegged as the future second baseman, leaving him out of the immediate picture.
Leo Rivas emerges as a logical, though temporary, choice. His presence would also allow the Mariners to keep Miles Mastrobuoni, who is out of minor league options, on the roster. However, relying on Rivas long-term could be risky if Crawford's injury proves more severe.
Mariners' Forward Planning
The Mariners need to consider the long-term implications of Crawford's injury. If he requires time on the IL, it signals not just a setback but also a potential oversight in roster planning. The team must be ready to adapt quickly to ensure stability as the season kicks off.