Mariners First Offseason Move Comes With One Big Question

Can Michael Toglia, the Mariners' latest acquisition, overcome his high strikeout rates and comparisons to Jake Bauers to make a meaningful impact this season?

The Mariners’ first move of the offseason didn’t exactly scream headline-grabber when they claimed Michael Toglia off waivers from the Cincinnati Reds in October. But there’s at least a reason to take a second look.

Toglia, a Gig Harbor native who hit 25 home runs for the Colorado Rockies in 2024, arrived with a profile that caught the eye of Mike Petriello of MLB.com. Petriello drew a line between Toglia and Jake Bauers, the reigning NLCS MVP who just signed a four-year, $58 million contract with the Boston Red Sox. Not because Toglia is already there, but because some of the ingredients are similar to the version of Bauers before he broke out: plate discipline, bat speed and a knack for barreling the ball.

That doesn’t mean the Mariners should be planning around a breakout. Far from it.

The expectations need to stay modest, because Toglia’s path to meaningful playing time looks crowded from the start. He’s on the 40-man roster, but he’ll be on the outside looking in at the 26-man roster when spring training opens next year.

First base is already occupied by Josh Naylor, and while Toglia can play the outfield, that’s where he suffered the right shoulder dislocation that led to season-ending surgery in August.

The strikeout issue is the biggest red flag, and it’s a loud one. In 1,094 major league plate appearances, Toglia has struck out 385 times. That’s a 35.2 K%, and the names around him on the 2022-26 strikeout leaderboard don’t exactly inspire confidence: Patrick Wisdom and Gabriel Arias.

Still, there are a few reasons the Mariners may have seen something worth betting on. Petriello pointed to Wisdom as a useful comparison in another way, noting that he was the only Triple-A hitter with a higher expected slugging percentage than Toglia’s .527 among players with at least 250 plate appearances.

Mariners fans know that Triple-A production doesn’t automatically carry over, and Wisdom’s own big numbers in the minors didn’t translate in the majors this year. Seattle outrighted him earlier this month.

Toglia’s 2026 Triple-A line was at least strong enough to keep the conversation going. He posted a .920 OPS in 97 games with Louisville, and while that’s close to his career .930 OPS at the Triple-A level, the context matters.

A lot of his previous damage came in Albuquerque, where the altitude is doing some heavy lifting. Louisville sits at under 500 feet above sea level.

The more interesting part is how the numbers looked from both sides of the plate. Toglia is a switch-hitter, and his Triple-A expected slugging percentages tell a more encouraging story than the overall major league track record:

Year

LH xSLG

RH xSLG

2022

.591

.476

2023

.458

.329

2024

.376

.395

2025

.439

.491

2026

.525

.535

For the first time in five Triple-A seasons, Toglia finished above .500 from both sides. That lines up with another notable shift: his barrel rate also climbed above 15.0 percent from each side of the plate, well above the 6.1 percent league average at Triple-A this year.

Petriello also noted mechanical changes in Toglia’s stance, which was deeper in the box and more open than before. Even his chase rate showed progress, dropping to 24.8 percent in Triple-A this year.

There’s more. Toglia may have finally figured out the four-seam fastball.

From 2022 through 2025, his expected slugging against four-seamers sat in the .400s in both the minors and the majors. In Triple-A this year, it jumped all the way to .732.

That improvement helped get him a shot with the Reds, but the opportunity barely got started. He lasted only 10 games before the shoulder injury ended his season, and in that brief look he went 3-for-26 with 12 strikeouts.

So yes, the Bauers comparison is intriguing. But it’s still just that - intriguing. Toglia has too much swing-and-miss in his game to be treated like a sure thing, and even if he does clean some of that up, the road to a roster spot in Seattle isn’t exactly clear.

For now, the best way to view the claim is as a low-cost flier with a few interesting clues attached. If nothing else, Toglia gives the Mariners something worth watching when they get back on the field next year.

In Other News...

Mariners 2027 Lineup Is Taking Shape But One Concern Still Lingers

By the time the Mariners start mapping out a 2027 Opening Day lineup, the picture is beginning to look familiar in a few spots and a little less settled in others. Maikel Garcia has emerged as the kind of third-base option who can help stabilize the infield, while Brendan Donovans time in left field gives Seattle another way to balance the lineup against a right-handed starter. Between those moving parts and the roster changes already in the background, there is at least a workable blueprint taking shape.

Still, the lineup conversation is not just about where everyone fits on paper. Health remains part of the equation, and that can change both the order and the defensive alignment in a hurry. Seattle may like the direction this group is heading, but until those concerns clear, the Mariners are left with a roster that looks promising and just uncertain enough to keep the discussion going. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners Trade Just Created A Bullpen Problem Fans Cant Ignore

The Mariners latest trade reshaped the roster in a big way, bringing in third baseman Maikel Garcia while sending Bryce Miller, Logan Evans and Jose A. Ferrer to Kansas City. It was the kind of deal that can change both the lineup and the pitching staff at once, and for Seattle the immediate conversation has shifted to what it means for a bullpen that already had to be managed carefully.

Ferrer, in particular, looks like the piece fans will miss most because of his pitching potential and the workload he was able to handle. Seattle can still look to free agency for help, but the trade leaves the bullpen picture less settled than it was before, and the front office will have to sort out how to replace that depth while making the rest of the roster work around the new additions. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners Just Made A Luke Raley Decision Fans Will Debate

The Mariners have moved on from Luke Raley, non-tendering the veteran outfielder and sending him into free agency. It is the kind of roster decision that makes sense on paper, especially with Seattles recent changes and acquisitions trimming the need for his particular mix of versatility and left-handed power.

Raley had value because he could fill multiple roles and bring some pop, but the fit in Seattle has shifted enough that the club may now look for a right-handed bat instead. For Raley, the market is likely to be about opportunity as much as fit, with playing time a bigger selling point than a return to a crowded roster. [Read more 🡒]