Jon Morosi of MLB Network kicked off a wave of speculation on Thursday when he floated the idea of the Mariners trading Brendan Donovan, and that was enough to light up Seattle’s corner of the baseball internet.
The reaction moved fast, but the logic behind the chatter is pretty thin. The basic argument being tossed around is simple enough: Donovan began last season at third base, Garcia is set to start there next season, and that supposedly leaves Donovan without a spot. But that view ignores how the Mariners seem to see him.
After Seattle acquired Garcia on Wednesday, Jerry Dipoto was asked directly what the move means for Donovan’s future. Dipoto did not sound like someone preparing to move on from the versatile infielder. He pointed to the way the trade could push Donovan into more of an outfield role, while also leaving him available to bounce around wherever needed.
That flexibility is the whole point. If Cole Young needs a break at second base, Donovan can handle it.
If Colt Emerson needs time off at shortstop, Garcia can move over there and Donovan can take third. For this roster, that kind of plug-and-play value matters.
Right now, the Mariners appear set to use Donovan in left field, Julio Rodriguez in center and Dominic Canzone in right, with the DH spot going to either Michael Arroyo or Lazaro Montes. If Seattle adds another bat such as Seiya Suzuki, then both of the young players would get squeezed.
But that still does not mean Donovan has to go. He is under team control through 2027, and the Mariners could simply keep at least one of those young players in the minors and wait until 2028. There is no rule saying they have to trade Donovan just to create space.
In fact, there are a lot of reasons a Donovan trade would be hard to justify. He fills a real need because of his versatility.
He will only be 30 next season. Seattle would be selling low after he played in just 39 games last season.
The Mariners paid a hefty price to get him, including prospect Tai Peete, who just won Offensive Player of the Year in the Arizona Fall League. He also is not expensive, with just over $6 million likely headed his way in arbitration.
And with a lockout looming, there is real uncertainty about how much of 2027 anyone might actually get from a player with only one year of control left.
The one scenario where it starts to make more sense is if Seattle is bringing back a player at another position of need who is also on an expiring deal. Steven Kwan of the Cleveland Guardians would fit that kind of idea as a traditional left fielder, and Jhoan Duran of the Philadelphia Phillies could fit the bullpen need too.
Even then, the cleanest version of this idea is a one-for-one swap involving another expiring contract. Outside of that, trading Donovan just does not add up.
In Other News...
Luis Castillos Latest Trade Says Plenty About His Value Now
Luis Castillos latest move says as much about how clubs view his contract as it does about his recent work on the mound. The right-hander and Davis Martin were dealt from the White Sox to the Rockies, with Colorado taking on the full remaining salary attached to Castillo, including a guaranteed amount for 2027 and a possible option for 2028.
For Chicago, the trade brings back two prospects and clears a struggling arm from its rotation, a sign the White Sox were ready to reset after Castillos performance issues. For Colorado, the bet is straightforward enough: absorb the money now and hope the upside still outweighs the risk, even with the long tail of the deal still hanging over the next few seasons. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Trade Puts Brendan Donovans Role Back In The Spotlight
The Mariners trade for Maikel Garcia has already nudged the conversation around Brendan Donovan back into focus, and for good reason. Jerry Dipoto said Donovan is likely to spend more time in the outfield this season, a reminder of how valuable his versatility can be as Seattle continues shaping the roster after dealing three pitchers to land Garcia.
Donovans flexibility gives the Mariners options, which is exactly what teams want this time of year, but it also leaves his exact role open-ended for now. No definitive roster decisions have been announced, so the next step will be seeing how Seattle balances its new infield addition with Donovans ability to move around the diamond. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Just Made A Bold Infield Move With Huge Pitching Implications
The Mariners made a significant infield splash by landing Gold Glove third baseman Maikel Garca from the Royals in a six-player trade, a move that immediately changes the look of their roster and sends a clear signal about how they want to build around the diamond. Seattle gave up Bryce Miller, Logan Evans and Jos Ferrer in the deal, a steep price that underscores how much value the club placed on stabilizing third base with a proven defender.
It also comes at a time when the rest of the market is moving fast, with the Twins adding Sonny Gray, the Angels bringing in Jace Jung and the Red Sox dealing for Nick Fortes. For the Mariners, though, the bigger question is how this reshuffling affects the pitching side of the equation, especially after parting with two arms and a reliever in a trade that suggests the front office is willing to sacrifice depth now for a cleaner fit later. [Read more 🡒]
