The Reds have moved on from two familiar names, declining their 2027 mutual options for third baseman Eugenio Suárez and right-hander Pierce Johnson, the club announced. Both players are now free agents, and Cincinnati suddenly has five open spots on its 40-man roster.
The Suárez decision is the bigger one on paper, even if it hardly qualifies as a shock. Mutual options almost never get exercised by both sides, and the Reds’ call leaves the 35-year-old’s future in Cincinnati hanging unless a new deal comes together. His option carried a $16MM price tag and no buyout attached.
Johnson’s situation was different, but the end result was the same. The Reds paid a $1MM buyout rather than commit to the $8MM they would have owed had both sides picked up the option.
For Suárez, this could close the book on his second run with the Reds. He spent the first stretch of his Cincinnati career from 2015-21 and was a real force there, turning in three seasons of at least 4.0 fWAR and two seasons with 30 or more home runs. He also picked up the first of his two All-Star selections during that span.
Cincinnati eventually sent him away in a blockbuster deal three weeks before the 2022 season, packaging him with Jesse Winker for the Mariners. Suárez then bounced from Seattle to Arizona, spent one and a half seasons with the Diamondbacks, and was traded back to Seattle before the 2025 deadline.
Last year, split between Arizona and a pennant-chasing Mariners club, he launched 49 homers for the second time in his career and hit .228/.298/.526. The batting average and on-base numbers were light, but the overall production still came with a 125 wRC+.
The Reds clearly hoped they were buying that version of Suárez when they guaranteed him $15MM last offseason. Instead, the first half was rough.
By the All-Star break in mid-July, he was sitting on a .208/.285/.388 line, and Cincinnati was 43-52. He caught fire after that, posting an .852 OPS in August and a .935 mark in September, but the club still finished 75-87 and missed a second straight playoff berth by a wide margin.
In late August, with a month left in the season, the Reds placed Suárez on revocable waivers. A claim would have saved them about $2.5MM, but no other team stepped in.
Even with that late surge, Suárez’s final line came in at .212/.307/.433 over 498 plate appearances. He hit 26 homers, but his overall production was only 2% better than league average, and a career-worst 33.9% strikeout rate dragged things down.
His defense at third base didn’t help either. Over 50 games and 401 innings there, he was graded negatively across the board, with minus-7 Outs Above Average, minus-6 Fielding Run Value and minus-4 Defensive Runs Saved.
For the first time in his career, most of his work came as a designated hitter.
That matters for Cincinnati’s offseason plans, because Ke’Bryan Hayes was the team’s primary third baseman and he’s still under contract. The Reds also claimed Oswaldo Cabrera off waivers last month, but if Suárez doesn’t return, they could still be shopping for a better answer either in free agency or through a trade.
Johnson’s year in Cincinnati never matched the one that got him paid. He reached free agency after giving the Braves 59 innings of 3.05 ERA ball, then landed a $6.5MM guarantee from the Reds.
This time, the payoff wasn’t there. He averaged 95.8 mph on his fastball, but he struck out only 19.9% of hitters, walked about 9%, and finished with a 4.62 ERA over 48 2/3 innings, with the underlying numbers tracking in the same neighborhood.
The 35-year-old now appears headed to the open market alongside 2026 bullpen mate Emilio Pagan, who declined his player option on Saturday.
In Other News...
Mariners Bullpen Question Suddenly Has An Unlikely Name To Watch
Seattles bullpen took a noticeable step back in 2026, and that has pushed the Mariners toward every possible source of relief help as they look ahead. One of the more interesting names in that mix is Adam Smith, a 26-year-old right-hander acquired in May who has moved through High-A, Double-A and now the Arizona Fall League while trying to carve out a place in the organizations future.
Smith has had his share of bumps, but his arm has started to draw real attention from people who follow prospects closely. The Mariners are still sorting out what he can become, yet he has put himself in the conversation as a possible bullpen piece for 2027, which is not the kind of timeline anyone had in mind when he arrived. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Outfield Question Just Got More Complicated After Latest Claim
The Mariners added another name to their outfield mix this offseason when they claimed Grant McCray off waivers from the Giants, a move that fits the clubs habit of looking for low-cost athleticism and roster flexibility. McCray brings speed and defensive ability, two traits that can play in a hurry if a team needs help in the grass, and he gives Seattle another option to sort through as it pieces together its outfield picture for the coming season.
McCrays track record, though, suggests a different kind of role than a direct path to regular playing time. He has spent most of his career in the minors and has not yet shown enough with the bat to force his way into an everyday job, which is why the Mariners seem more likely to treat him as depth than as a real Opening Day answer. Even so, his presence adds another layer to an outfield situation that already had enough moving parts. [Read more 🡒]
Jerry Dipoto Just Created A Bigger Mariners Concern Than Victor Robles
Victor Robles time in Seattle has already become a cautionary tale about how quickly a low-cost gamble can turn into a sunk cost. The Mariners took a flier on him in 2024 after his release from Washington, then doubled down with a two-year deal when he flashed enough to earn more runway, but the results never matched the optimism. Injuries kept him off the field far too often, and when he was available, his production fell well short of what the club needed.
Now the bigger concern is what his exit says about the roster-building work still ahead. Seattle has already moved on from the option year it held for 2027, and while the buyout is manageable, the larger issue is that the Mariners are again looking for answers in a spot that was supposed to be settled. For a team trying to tighten up the margins, losing that kind of outfield stability is the kind of problem that lingers well beyond one contract decision. [Read more 🡒]