Cole Young’s Gold Glove case gets more interesting once you move past the Statcast leaderboard.
At second base, OAA does not flatter him. Young finished 2026 at -5 Outs Above Average, which tied him for 35th among 42 qualifying players at the position.
On that metric alone, there would not be much to celebrate. But Gold Glove voting does not hand out the award based on one defensive model, and that is where Young’s resume starts to look a lot stronger.
The selection process is built with both people and data in mind. Managers and as many as six coaches from each MLB club make up 75 percent of the vote.
They only vote in their own league, and they cannot vote for their own players. The other 25 percent comes from the SABR Defensive Index.
So no, the Mariners cannot simply talk this one into existence. Young’s support has to come from opposing managers and coaches who watched him man second base all year. And he gave them a lot to evaluate.
He played 157 games at the keystone, the most of any AL second baseman, and logged 1,350 1/3 defensive innings, also the most at the position. He led AL second basemen with 223 putouts, 397 assists and a .990 fielding percentage. Defensive Runs Saved gave him 16 runs saved, the best mark among AL second basemen.
That’s where his case gets sticky in a good way. OAA says one thing.
DRS says another. And the Gold Glove process is designed to handle exactly that kind of split.
Massey brings the best OAA number among the finalists at +11, while Chase Meidroth led AL second basemen with +10 Fielding Run Value. Those are real arguments against Young. But the voting system is not a one-stat referendum, and the human element matters here.
The SABR Defensive Index doesn’t boil defense down to a single easy answer. It blends information from Statcast, Sports Info Solutions and STATS Perform, mixing location-based data with play-by-play evaluation.
That means Young’s lower OAA ranking does not get to overrule the entire final quarter of the vote. His DRS total still counts, and it counts in a big way.
The broader picture helps him, too. He was on the field almost every day.
He handled more chances than the other finalists. He made the routine plays over and over again.
That kind of steadiness does not always jump off a spreadsheet, but it absolutely registers with opposing staffs over the course of a season.
Young is not a sure thing. Massey and Meidroth have strong cases, and Young’s Statcast profile gives voters plenty of reason to go another direction.
Still, his path is there. The process gives 75 percent of the decision to baseball people and 25 percent to an index that can better reflect the kind of season he actually had.
That makes his defensive résumé a better fit for Gold Glove voting than for a quick glance at OAA ever would.
In Other News...
Former Mariners Are Suddenly Part Of Tampa Bay's October Story
The Tampa Bay Rays have pushed past the Cleveland Guardians and are now one win from the World Series, which means a couple of familiar names from Seattles recent past are suddenly attached to October baseball in a big way. Casey Legumina and Ben Williamson are both on Tampa Bays roster, giving Mariners fans a small reminder of how many moving parts can be involved in building a contender from year to year.
Legumina arrived in Tampa Bay in a 2026 trade, while Williamson came over in a three-team deal before spring training, and both now sit one game away from helping the Rays finish the job. Game 5 of the ALCS is set for Monday night at Tropicana Field, where Tampa Bay will try to turn a strong postseason run into a trip to the Fall Classic. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Face A Costly Offseason Choice Fans Can Already See
The Mariners are already looking at a 2027 offseason that could force some hard choices, even if the payroll gives them room to maneuver. Left field and third base are set to be open because of impending free agency departures, and those are the kinds of everyday spots Seattle cannot afford to leave unresolved if it wants to keep pace in the division.
At the same time, the bullpen looms as another priority, with the front office expected to chase a high-leverage arm to stabilize the late innings. The market should offer options, but the real challenge is obvious: Seattle may not be able to solve the back end of games and plug two lineup holes at the same time without deciding which need matters most. [Read more 🡒]
Phillies' Carlos Mendoza Hire Looks Bigger After Seattle Interest
When the Mariners moved on from Dan Wilson, the search for their next manager immediately took on a familiar urgency, and one early name on the radar ended up landing elsewhere. Carlos Mendoza, the former Mets manager, has now taken a job with the Phillies as their third base and infield coach after removing himself from Seattles vacancy, a reminder of how quickly these searches can shift when a club is trying to rework its staff.
For Seattle, the pool has already narrowed to a more specific kind of possibility, and the timing makes the next step feel even more important. The Mariners have permission to interview former Astros manager Joe Espada, whose contract in Houston was not renewed recently, leaving Seattle with one known lead as it tries to settle on the person who will guide the franchise into its next phase. [Read more 🡒]