Mariners Fans May Hate How The Brendan Donovan Trade Looks Now

Former Mariners prospect Tai Peete shines brightly in the AFL, leaving Seattle with regrets as he fuels the Peoria Javelinas' unexpected title success.

The Arizona Fall League closed with the Peoria Javelinas taking the title, but the Mariners didn’t exactly leave with much to celebrate. Peoria beat the Surprise Saguaros 8-3 on Saturday, and the Seattle prospects on that roster didn’t do much to change the mood around the organization.

If anything, the loudest Mariners-related development came from someone who isn’t even in the system anymore.

Tai Peete, now with the St. Louis Cardinals after the Brendan Donovan trade, kept building on a breakout year and looked like the best player in the league while doing it.

In 66 minor league games, he posted a .908 OPS. Then he went to the AFL and raised the bar even higher, putting up a 1.103 OPS with 13 extra-base hits and 20 stolen bases in 19 games.

That performance earned him AFL Offensive Player of the Year honors.

For the Mariners’ current group in the league, the results were far less inspiring. Boston Smith and Brandon Eike both finished with OPS marks in the .600s.

Adam Smith, who got a positive mention in The Athletic, still finished with a 5.40 ERA in seven AFL outings, the lowest mark among Seattle’s five pitching prospects. Matthew Ellis had a more productive run overall, appearing in 14 games, hitting three homers and driving in 14 runs, but he also struck out 22 times, which ranked third on the Javelinas, and he didn’t play in the championship game.

Peete’s climb has been the bigger story, though. His stock had dropped so sharply after Seattle took him No. 30 in the 2023 draft that he was basically a throw-in in the Donovan deal.

That looks very different now. He’s still listed as the Cardinals’ No. 17 prospect by MLB Pipeline, but his production this season has made that ranking feel light.

The tools were never the question. Peete has always had speed, power and arm strength.

The issue was the bat, which had looked like a major problem through his first three pro seasons. This year, that changed.

His strikeout rate improved as the season went on, and in the AFL he struck out 17 times in 93 plate appearances, an 18.3 K%.

He also showed off the kind of pop that turns heads in a hurry. On November 8, 2026, MLB Pipeline noted that Peete homered four times on four swings to advance to the second round of the AFL Home Run Derby.

With Double-A already behind him before the AFL even started, Peete is now positioned to possibly reach the majors in 2027. It wouldn’t be a shock if he got there before Jurrangelo Cijntje, who was supposed to be the Cardinals’ headline return in the Donovan trade.

That’s where the Mariners’ side of the deal gets uncomfortable. Donovan’s 2026 season was wrecked by injuries, and while his bat still matters, his defensive home is unsettled. Seattle also probably couldn’t move him even if it wanted to, since his trade value took such a hit this year and he fits the same difficult-to-trade profile as other players headed toward free agency after 2027.

No one is ready to call the Donovan trade a loss for Seattle yet. But with Peete surging the way he is, it’s getting harder to ignore where this could be headed.

In Other News...

Mariners Fans Have A New Reason To Worry About That Donovan Trade

The Mariners got a useful look at Brendan Donovan after bringing him over from St. Louis in a three-team deal that sent Tai Peete to the Cardinals and Ben Williamson to the Rays. In 39 games with Seattle this past season, Donovan hit .277 with three home runs, but injuries kept him from giving the club the kind of extended run it hoped for when the trade was made.

Tai Peete has only added to the sense that this deal could become a talking point for years. The young infielder has been productive in the Cardinals minor league system and carried that momentum into the Arizona Fall League, where he won Offensive Player of the Year honors and helped his team to a championship, giving Seattle fans a fresh reason to wonder how this one might age. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners Just Got One More Reason To Spend Like Contenders

The Mariners may have a little more room to operate than previously thought as they look ahead to 2027. Ryan Divish of The Seattle Times reported that Seattle could be working with a payroll in the $175 million to $180 million range, a step up from earlier projections that had the club closer to $165 million to $170 million. For a front office that has spent years trying to thread the needle between contention and caution, that kind of shift matters.

A bigger budget would not guarantee a splash, but it would widen the list of possibilities if Seattle decides to act like a team ready to push deeper into October. Names such as Seiya Suzuki and Adrian Morejon would fit the kind of upgrade the Mariners could chase, and the club also has trade assets that could create even more flexibility. Jerry Dipoto has usually leaned on trades more than major free-agent bets, so the real question is whether this added spending power changes the way Seattle approaches its next big roster move. [Read more 🡒]

Mariners Prospects Just Gave Fans A Telling Offseason Snapshot

The Arizona Fall League wrapped up with a championship for the Peoria Javelinas, who beat the Surprise Saguaros 8-3 at Peoria Stadium, and it offered a useful offseason snapshot for the Mariners. Seattle had a strong presence on the title team, with Brandon Eike, Ty Cummings, Reid Easterly, Calvin Schapira, Matthew Ellis, Boston Smith and Adam Smith all part of the roster that finished on top.

For a club that has spent the fall sorting through young talent from the 2024 and 2025 MLB Drafts, the result matters beyond the trophy itself. The AFL is often where organizations get a cleaner read on how prospects handle advanced competition, and this group gave Seattle plenty to evaluate as the winter begins, even if the bigger question is how much of that momentum can carry into next season. [Read more 🡒]