Credit where it’s due: the Brewers found something in Jake Bauers that the Mariners never managed to unlock.
Five years ago, Seattle took a low-risk swing on Bauers in June of 2021, bringing in a 25-year-old former top prospect who already had lost plenty of shine. He had been through the Padres, Rays and Guardians organizations before landing with the Mariners, and while the appeal was obvious enough for a club in the middle of a rebuild, the results never came. In 202. plate appearances with Seattle, Bauers finished with a .572 OPS, two home runs and 13 RBI.
At the time, then-manager Scott Servais believed there was still something to tap into.
"It takes some players longer to figure it out the big-league level. Sometimes it’s a (different) coach or it’s just being in a different uniform that can help somehow flip the switch and allows that player to take off and relax.
It happens to multiple players every year in our game. It happened to me in my career.
You get an opportunity to play a little bit people look at you a little bit differently. They see it through a different lens and maybe they can unlock something and hopefully that’s what we can do with Jake."
Servais had the right idea. Seattle just never got the payoff.
Bauers left after that season, then kept moving: Reds, Yankees, Brewers. By the end of the 2024 season, he had even thought about walking away from baseball. He kept going because he and his wife got pregnant and needed health insurance, and he re-signed with Milwaukee for 2025.
That decision looks awfully different now.
Bauers was named NLCS MVP on Thursday after powering Milwaukee’s four-game sweep of the two-time defending World Series champion Los Angeles Dodgers. He put up a .983 OPS in the series, came through with tough at-bats against Yoshinobu Yamamoto in Game 2 and Blake Snell in Game 3, and drove in a run in each of the final three games. In the clincher, he delivered three RBI with a bases-loaded walk and a two-run double.
Every pitch from that UNREAL Jake Bauers at-bat 😤
11 pitches. One unforgettable moment. pic.twitter.com/QpDMUMMPFP
- MLB (@MLB) October 15, 2026
The breakout didn’t begin in October. Bauers was already trending up last year with a 111 OPS+ in 85 games, then took another leap this season with a 140 OPS+ and a team-high 26 home runs. At 31, he’s gone from afterthought to centerpiece.
And that makes Servais’ old comment hit differently. He was right about Bauers, just too early.
The tools were there. The eye was there.
What Milwaukee gave him was the space, clarity and simplicity to make it all work.
There’s not much use in blaming Seattle for missing the full version of Bauers. Plenty of clubs have been there with him. The Padres, Rays, Guardians, Reds and Yankees all passed through the same frustration.
Now he’s the one having the last word.
Former Mariner. Current hero. Proud journeyman.
In Other News...
Mariners Fans Just Got An Uncomfortable October Reminder
The Cleveland Guardians run through October has offered a familiar kind of reminder for Seattle followers: once the regular season ends, the door stays open for teams that know how to play deep into the calendar. Cleveland won Game 3 of the ALCS and is now within striking distance of the World Series, a stunning position for a club that only needed 85 wins to claim the AL Central and still found a way to turn a modest regular-season profile into October momentum.
For the Mariners, it is an uncomfortable comparison because it comes back to how they have talked about building a winner and what that has looked like in practice. Jerry Dipoto has long framed Seattles path around a certain standard for sustained success, but the Guardians current postseason surge is the sort of example that forces a fresh look at whether that approach is enough when the games matter most. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Still Have One Lineup Problem They Cant Ignore
With the postseason churning around them, the Mariners are still staring at a familiar roster question that is hard to put off any longer. Around the league, the Brewers have moved on to a World Series berth, the Guardians have gotten a lift from rookie Petey Halpin and other clubs are already dealing with retirements, surgeries and coaching changes, but Seattles attention remains on how it will line up its own offense for next season.
The issue is less about adding another headline name than figuring out where the production goes from here and how the lineup holds together if the club wants to keep pace in the American League. Randy Arozarenas role in that mix has become central to the conversation, and it is the kind of problem that can linger into the winter if the Mariners do not find a clean answer soon. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners May Have A Surprise Left Field Option Emerging
Randy Arozarenas strong season has made left field one of the more interesting questions on the Mariners offseason checklist, especially with free agency looming. Seattle has already started looking at possible ways to cover that production, and the list includes big-league names such as Michael Arroyo and Brendan Donovan, plus a more unexpected internal candidate who could give the club another path if it wants to keep the job in-house.
Boston Smith is the one worth watching there. The catching prospect has impressed offensively in the minors, and the Mariners gave him a look in left field in the Arizona Fall League, a sign they may be open to broadening his role. After arriving in an earlier trade, Smith is starting to emerge as a player Seattle could evaluate not just as a bat, but as a potential answer to a pretty important roster hole. [Read more 🡒]