The Seattle Mariners may have a Tai Peete problem on their hands.
Peete, who went to the St. Louis Cardinals in last offseason’s Brendan Donovan deal, is suddenly looking like the kind of prospect that can make a front office wince a little longer than expected. The Mariners were the team that moved him in the three-team trade that brought Donovan to Seattle in February, with infielder Ben Williamson also sent to the Tampa Bay Rays.
At the time, the idea was simple enough: Donovan was supposed to be the missing piece. Instead, injuries kept him on the field for only 39 games.
When he did play, he produced, batting .277 with a .377 on-base percentage, along with three homers and 15 RBIs. But availability was the issue, and Seattle finished 76-86, missing the playoffs a year after reaching the American League Championship Series.
Williamson’s path only added to the sting for Mariners fans. He didn’t have a great year in Tampa Bay, but he did appear in the World Series and delivered a walk-off hit in Game 4 against the Milwaukee Brewers - the lone game Tampa Bay won.
Meanwhile, Peete kept building momentum in the Cardinals’ system. The 21-year-old Georgia native, who was Seattle’s first-round pick in 2023, hit .300 at High-A with 10 home runs and 39 RBIs. He followed that with a .319 stretch in 21 games at Double-A Springfield, adding three more homers.
Then came the Arizona Fall League, where he really took off. In 19 games, Peete hit .351 with three homers, 17 RBIs and 20 stolen bases.
That run earned him the league’s Offensive Player of the Year award, and he also finished second in the All-Star Game Home Run Derby. He capped it by helping the Peoria Javelinas win the AFL title on Saturday night with seven other Mariners prospects.
From Seattle’s side, there are really two ways this can play out. If Donovan turns in a big 2027, the regret attached to the trade can be softened. And the Mariners have spent the last five or six years under Jerry Dipoto dealing away prospects, usually without getting burned too badly by the players they sent out.
But if Peete keeps moving like this, he could be the one who finally makes that trade look different for Seattle.
In Other News...
Mariners Are Already Showing How Serious They Are About Julio Rodriguez
The Mariners are wasting no time trying to make sure Julio Rodriguez stays at the center of their plans. Manager Jason Kanzler is set to fly to Florida to meet with the centerfielder and strengthen their relationship before the offseason really gets rolling, a clear sign the club wants to stay connected to one of its most important players after a rough 2026 campaign.
Rodriguez, a five-year veteran and three-time All-Star, saw both his offense and defense slip last season, a downturn that made his next step a major point of focus for Seattle. Kanzlers trip is meant to help steer him back toward the level that made him a franchise cornerstone, and it fits with the Mariners larger push to keep their core moving in the right direction. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Hire Raises A Big Question About Cal Raleighs Development
Buster Olneys note about the Mariners bringing in Tanner Swanson as bench coach adds an interesting wrinkle to Seattles offseason, especially for a club that has long leaned on Cal Raleigh as a central piece of its future. Swanson built a strong reputation in the Yankees organization for working with catchers, so his arrival naturally invites curiosity about how much of that background will carry over in Seattle and what it could mean for Raleighs continued growth.
The bigger question is how the Mariners will divide Swansons attention once he settles into the bench coach role, since that job comes with plenty of day-to-day responsibilities beyond player development. Seattle is also trying to navigate a busy winter with reported interest in outfielder Seiya Suzuki, all while the clock is ticking toward a looming MLB lockout, which could make every coaching and roster decision feel a little more urgent. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Trade Search Just Got More Complicated For One Big Reason
The Mariners winter trade search has a little more texture now, and not necessarily in a way that makes the job easier. A fresh look at the 2026 Silver Slugger finalists has put several intriguing names on the board, including infielders Otto Lopez, Zach Neto and Elly De La Cruz, each bringing a different blend of offense and defense that would appeal to a club trying to upgrade without giving up too much versatility.
Hunter Goodman also belongs in that conversation, though the fit is not as clean because of where he plays. For Seattle, that is the bigger issue lurking beneath the list of targets: the best bats are not always the easiest to line up with roster need, and the market may force the Mariners to decide whether they want the most realistic trade path or the most impactful one. [Read more 🡒]
