If the Mariners are looking for a jolt of power and a steadying voice in the room, Carlos Santana checks both boxes on paper. The problem is that the paper version and the real-life version are drifting farther apart.
Santana, who spent the second half of the 2022 season in Seattle, helped fuel the Mariners’ push to their first playoff appearance in 21 years. J.P.
Crawford said at the time that the 2019 All-Star had brought the group together and made the team closer. Santana also delivered at the plate, hitting 15 homers in 79 games, and Mariners fans still remember the three-run blast he launched in the comeback win over the Blue Jays in the Wild Card round.
That history is exactly why his name comes up now. Seattle could use more leadership, and it could use more home runs after watching its total fall from third-best in 2025 to tied-16th this past season. Santana also has a connection to Julio Rodríguez, who still thinks highly of him and could use the kind of lift that comes with a familiar veteran presence after the worst season of his five-year major league career.
But the fit gets shaky fast.
Santana is 40, and he has every reason to think seriously about retirement after a 17-year MLB career that includes 335 home runs and 1,136 RBI. According to Will Sammon, Ken Rosenthal and Katie Woo of The Athletic, though, he wants to keep playing. The issue for Seattle is whether that desire lines up with what he can still offer.
The recent track record is not encouraging. Santana played only eight major league games for the Diamondbacks this past season before being released in late June.
He later signed a minor league deal with the Braves, but never appeared in the majors for them and was let go in mid-August. He will turn 41 on April 8 next year, which makes it fair to wonder how much is left in the tank.
There is at least a financial angle to consider, since Santana would likely come cheaply after signing a $2 million deal with Arizona a year ago. Still, his best work is behind him, and outside of his home run power, he did not do much else offensively in a Mariners uniform. There is also the uncomfortable detail that T-Mobile Park has not been kind to him over the course of his career, where he has hit .206 with a .652 OPS in 82 games.
Nobody is saying Santana should walk away if he wants to keep going. If he still wants to play, that is his call. But even with the clubhouse goodwill and the old Seattle connection, this does not look like a clean match for the Mariners.
In Other News...
Jerry Dipoto Just Put Two Mariners Positions In The Spotlight
Jerry Dipoto used the General Managers Meetings to sketch out the Mariners offseason priorities, and the picture he drew was pretty clear: defense and depth are at the top of the list. With the collective bargaining agreement set to expire on Dec. 1, Seattles president of baseball operations said the club wants to get better in the field while also making sure it has enough reliable options across the roster, especially with left field and third base now in focus after the departures of Randy Arozarena and J.P. Crawford.
The bullpen is part of the conversation too, with Dipoto saying the Mariners would like to add one or two leverage relievers before spring training gets closer. Just as important, he stressed that any new pieces need to fit the way Seattle wants to play, which suggests this winter may be less about splash and more about fit, versatility and keeping the roster aligned with the clubs identity. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Fans May Hate How The Brendan Donovan Trade Looks Now
The Arizona Fall League offered a frustrating contrast for Mariners followers watching the organizations young talent, because the clubs prospects did not make much noise there while a former Seattle prospect was turning heads in a Cardinals uniform. Tai Peete, who is now in St. Louis system, put together a strong showing that earned him AFL Offensive Player of the Year honors, a sign that his bat has taken a meaningful step forward and that his stock is climbing fast.
For Seattle, that only adds another layer to the lingering questions around the Brendan Donovan trade and how it has aged. Donovans time with the Mariners was complicated by injuries and a lack of positional clarity, and the broader picture now includes a player the organization once had in hand looking more and more like a future big leaguer, with a debut projected for 2027. It is the kind of development that can make a deal feel very different in hindsight, especially when the return has yet to establish itself. [Read more 🡒]
J.P. Crawfords Mariners Legacy Just Became A Real Fan Debate
J.P. Crawford has spent enough time in Seattle to become one of the defining players of the Mariners rebuild, and now his place in team history is being measured against something bigger than a box score. He has been a steady presence through the clubs rise, earned a Gold Glove, and stacked up enough value to sit prominently in franchise discussions about the modern era. Even before the debate turns to Cooperstown, his case as one of the most important Mariners of his generation is already hard to dismiss.
The tougher question is what all of that means as the conversation shifts from appreciation to legacy. The Mariners reportedly told Crawford he will not be back in 2027, despite his desire to keep going, and that has only sharpened the argument over how he should be remembered. For some, his blend of defense, durability and role in a playoff team makes him a franchise pillar; for others, the Hall of Fame talk feels like a bridge too far. Either way, his standing with Mariners fans is no longer just about what he did on the field, but how much of the teams identity he helped shape. [Read more 🡒]
