The Mariners spent the trade deadline circling bullpen help, but the reliever who might sting most now is the one they never got close to landing.
Instead of Mason Miller, whose asking price from the Padres started with ace prospect Kade Anderson, the more realistic target may have been Erik Miller. The left-hander ended up with the Red Sox after coming over from the Giants, and he’s turned into exactly the kind of arm Boston wanted in the late innings.
Jim Bowden of The Athletic floated a deal ahead of the Aug. 3 deadline that would have sent Miller and Casey Schmitt to Seattle in exchange for George Kirby. At the time, the idea didn’t exactly inspire confidence, especially because the focus was more on Schmitt than Miller. And to be fair, the Mariners would have been justified in asking for more than that return for Kirby anyway.
There were also legitimate concerns about Miller himself. His command in San Francisco was shaky enough to make him look like too volatile a bet to be the shutdown reliever Seattle really needed, and his 15.5 BB% this season reflected that.
But since arriving in Boston, Miller has been a different pitcher. He’s logged 10 scoreless appearances with 18 strikeouts and three walks across 10.1 innings, and he’s now riding a run of no earned runs in 24 straight outings, a streak that began before the trade with the Giants.
For a pitcher whose control was a question mark, the results have been loud and clear. His 2.09 ERA is the kind of production Seattle could have used in a hurry.
That need has only grown more obvious as the Mariners bullpen has fallen apart. The unit was strong through the end of May, ranking third in the majors with a 3.11 ERA.
Since then, though, injuries, a thin pool of trustworthy arms, inconsistency, and the piggyback system leaving them short at times have dragged it into the ditch. Since the start of June, Seattle’s bullpen has posted the second-worst ERA in baseball at 5.36.
The frustration here isn’t just hindsight talking. Even at the deadline, there was a sense the Mariners hadn’t treated the bullpen situation with enough urgency. Seranthony Domínguez was the lone notable addition, coming over as part of the Luis Castillo trade, and that never looked like enough on its own.
Carlos Vargas is back now, but the situation still feels shaky. Gabe Speier has not been missing bats the way he once did, and while Cooper Criswell and Matt Brash are currently lined up to return in early September, Brash’s timeline has already been pushed back repeatedly.
With all of that hanging over the club, Miller’s name is the one that really lingers. He may not have looked like the obvious answer in July, but right now he sure looks like the kind of reliever the Mariners could have used.
In Other News...
Mariners May Have Found One Pitcher Who Solves Two Problems
The Mariners have been doing their homework in Japan, and Kaima Taira is the kind of name that fits the clubs needs on more than one level. The Saitama Seibu Lions right-hander has put together a strong season in Nippon Professional Baseball, leading the league with a 1.46 ERA, while also showing the kind of role flexibility front offices love to find in an international arm.
What makes Taira especially intriguing from Seattles perspective is the way he can straddle both sides of the pitching conversation. He has worked as both a starter and a reliever, giving the Mariners a possible bullpen option now and a longer-term rotation possibility down the line, which is exactly the sort of depth piece that can matter over the grind of a season. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Suddenly Have A Shot At Familiar Help They Desperately Need
The Mariners suddenly find themselves with a familiar option as they try to patch one of their thinnest spots. Cincinnati placed Eugenio Surez on waivers, and Seattle is reportedly in a strong position to claim him if it decides to pursue the move. Surez has not had the kind of season that once made him a difference-maker, but the need in Seattle is real, with injuries leaving the club looking for help at third base.
What makes this possibility worth watching is the chance to address a problem without waiting for a perfect market to develop. The Mariners standing gives them a favorable path to win the claim, which means the decision may come down less to logistics than to whether they believe Surez can still provide enough stability to matter. For a club trying to stay afloat while covering for injuries, even an imperfect reunion could carry some appeal. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Suddenly Have A Reunion Decision They Can't Wait On
Eugenio Surez landing on waivers has quickly turned into the kind of roster wrinkle contenders have to weigh carefully, and the Mariners are very much in that group. With a playoff push in full swing, Seattle is reportedly considering a claim on the former Mariner, a move that would bring back a familiar power bat at a time when every upgrade matters.
Surezs season has been uneven, but there are signs he has started to find something again, especially in August, when his production picked up and he recently uncorked a grand slam. For a Mariners team looking to squeeze every bit of offense out of the final stretch, the question is whether this reunion is worth acting on now, before another club gets there first. [Read more 🡒]