The Seattle Mariners’ 2026 season ended with a number that says plenty all by itself: 76 wins. Look closer, though, and the picture gets even rougher. They were shaky at the plate, unreliable on the mound, sloppy in the field and, as it turns out, not especially sharp when it came to using MLB’s Automated Ball-Strike System.
That last part matters more than it might seem. In the league’s first year with ABS, the Mariners finished with a 59 percent success rate on defensive challenges, which was respectable enough. But in terms of net overturns compared with what an average team would have been expected to get on the same pitches, they landed fifth from the bottom in MLB at -33.9.
The split tells the story cleanly. Mariners catchers and pitchers were at -3.9. Mariners hitters were at -30.0.
That’s the real problem. Seattle’s hitters tied for the worst challenge success rate in the league at 42 percent, even while managing to flip 23 strikeouts and 12 walks. The numbers make one thing obvious: the Mariners weren’t getting nearly enough out of the system on offense.
There’s also no easy way to shrug this off as a minor detail. Good ABS use doesn’t map neatly onto wins.
Using Statcast’s total vs. expected metric, only three of the 10 best challenging teams made the playoffs. Among the best offensive challenging teams, it was four of 10.
Among the best defensive challenging teams, three of 10. The correlation just isn’t strong.
But that doesn’t mean it’s meaningless. Leaving value on the table is still leaving value on the table, and for a team like Seattle, every little edge matters.
The Mariners may even get some help simply from subtraction. Randy Arozarena’s likely departure could help their offensive ABS work, even though he was only one piece of the problem. Among the five Mariners who challenged most often on offense, the numbers looked like this:
Cal Raleigh: 14 won, 8 lost, +6.7 overturns vs. expected
Cole Young: 7 won, 6 lost, +0.8
Dominic Canzone: 5 won, 8 lost, -1.1
Randy Arozarena: 11 won, 17 lost, -5.9
Josh Naylor: 7 won, 19 lost, -11.0
Cole Young and Dominic Canzone need to get better. Josh Naylor, based on those results, might be a candidate to have his ABS privileges revoked altogether. Julio Rodríguez, meanwhile, was almost the opposite case: he challenged only seven times all year, and won just two of them.
That leaves spring training as the obvious place for Seattle to clean this up. The Mariners can do next spring what they didn’t really do this year: use camp to experiment.
Under Dan Wilson, Mariners hitters challenged only 24 calls last spring. That put them in the bottom 10 across MLB, and well behind teams that were much more aggressive, including the New York Yankees at 49, the Cleveland Guardians at 48 and the Tampa Bay Rays at 43.
If Seattle had made ABS a more visible part of spring training, maybe Wilson wouldn’t have had to say on Opening Day: “It is new obviously for everybody, and I think maybe it doesn’t jump to the forefront of the mind all the time when you’re in the box. But again, it’s part of the game now and something definitely we will use.”
The Mariners did get more active early in the season, with 33 challenges in March and April. After that, the usage tailed off. Two of their three quietest months came in August and September, and at times they seemed to forget the system was even there.
In Other News...
Emerson Hancock Gave Mariners Hope But One Concern Still Lingers
Emerson Hancock gave the Mariners a real reason to feel better about the back of their rotation in 2026. The right-hander put together a career-best 3.57 ERA and 2.7 bWAR while looking more like the pitcher Seattle hoped it was drafting, with a tick up in velocity and mechanical changes that helped his strikeout rate and made his fastball play better.
Still, the picture around Hancock is not fully settled, and that is where the caution comes in for Seattle. Some of the deeper indicators behind his breakthrough suggest the improvement may not be as sturdy as the surface results, and with George Kirby and Bryce Miller also in the mix, Hancocks long-term place in the rotation remains a question the Mariners have not quite answered. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Fans Can Dream On Elly De La Cruz But The Price Changes Everything
Elly De La Cruz is the kind of name that naturally gets Mariners fans talking, because a player with that blend of speed, power and star power would change the shape of a lineup in a hurry. The idea of Seattle making a run at the Cincinnati infielder also fits a familiar front-office question: when is it time to turn a deep prospect system into proven impact talent?
The hurdle, of course, is that De La Cruz is not the kind of player a club simply shops around and replaces. Any serious attempt would come with a steep price, and the Mariners would have to decide how much of their prospect depth they are willing to sacrifice for a centerpiece who could help now and for years to come. That is where the conversation shifts from fantasy fit to real roster-building risk, and it is why this one is more dream than easy solution. [Read more 🡒]
Julio Rodrguez Just Made A Future Mariners Call Much Tougher
Julio Rodrguez has already given the Mariners plenty to believe in, from the early-career stardom that made him the face of the franchise to the steady sense that Seattle still views him as central to its long-term plans. Even with the uneven stretches that have crept into his game, the organization is still headed toward a major decision after the 2028 season, one that could shape the direction of the roster for years.
The complication is that Rodrguezs recent trends have made that call harder to project than it once looked. His defense has slipped, his plate discipline has not been as sharp, and his inconsistency has created at least some pause even as the Mariners seem inclined to keep him in place. Add in the way his clubhouse standing and overall importance continue to matter, and this figures to be one of the biggest decisions Seattle faces when that contract choice arrives. [Read more 🡒]