The Mariners are staring at the kind of offseason that usually brings movement, even if the team still scrapes its way into the postseason. Change tends to follow a rough year, and in Seattle it would not be surprising to see some of that happen as the organization looks ahead. But there is one move that feels far less likely: Jerry Dipoto is probably staying put.
That’s where the conversation starts to get uncomfortable. Dipoto has been running baseball operations in Seattle for 10 years, and the longer he stays, the more he begins to resemble a different familiar face - Brian Cashman in New York, a longtime power broker who has outlasted bad seasons, organizational shakeups, and sky-high expectations.
Cashman has been the Yankees’ general manager for nearly three decades, and while he’s kept the job through plenty of turbulence, he has produced just one World Series winner since 2000. That kind of record has fueled plenty of frustration in a market that expects more. Seattle isn’t there yet, but the comfort around Dipoto is starting to feel awfully familiar.
To be clear, Dipoto has earned real credit. He has one of the strongest resumes of any front office leader in Mariners history. Seattle has had 19 winning seasons in its 50 years, and seven of them have come during his tenure.
A big reason is the pitching pipeline. The Mariners have become one of the best teams in baseball at drafting and developing arms, turning young pitchers into major-league pieces. Logan Gilbert was the 14th pick in the 2018 draft, George Kirby went 20th in 2019, Bryan Woo was a sixth-round pick in 2021, and Bryce Miller was taken in the fourth round that same year.
Dipoto has also become more willing to reward the players the organization believes in. Extensions for Cal Raleigh, Julio Rodríguez, and Colt Emerson stand out as important wins for a club that is always trying to build something durable.
That’s the good part of the story. Dipoto knows how to construct a team, he has a real eye for pitching, and he has kept the farm system relevant. He’s also made sure the Mariners stay in the race.
But staying in the race and winning the whole thing are not the same thing.
That’s where the criticism starts. Seattle’s pitching development has been excellent, but the offense has not kept pace.
Dipoto’s preference for platoon players and low-cost bounce-back bets can be smart in theory, but eventually someone has to carry the lineup. A roster built too heavily on small edges runs into a ceiling sooner or later.
The Mariners have stars in Rodríguez and Raleigh, but this season wasn’t their time to carry the load. Their production slipped, and Dipoto’s reluctance to chase a legitimate middle-of-the-order bat left the lineup short on sustainability.
That tension ties back to a comment Dipoto made in 2023, when he said the goal was to win about 54 percent of games over a 10-year span. On paper, it makes sense. A team winning 87 or 88 games every year will almost always be part of the postseason picture.
“We're actually doing the fanbase a favor in asking for their patience to win the World Series while we continue to build a sustainably good roster.”
But those remarks sparked a bigger debate about what, exactly, he was building toward. Dipoto later apologized for how the comments were received and stressed that mediocrity was not the objective. Still, the question lingers: does his approach give the Mariners a high floor without a high enough ceiling?
That’s the heart of it. A good team can stumble into a championship.
But a serious contender does more than wait for variance to break its way. It puts itself in position to force the issue.
Seattle has often protected the future at the expense of the present, and Dipoto has become the face of those choices.
His managerial decisions have drawn scrutiny too. When he arrived in 2016, he hired Scott Servais, who had never managed a professional game and was also a longtime friend.
After Servais’ run ended, Dipoto turned to Dan Wilson, another manager whose path to the job was not a conventional one. Wilson is highly respected inside the organization, but his limited coaching background raised a fair question about what Dipoto wants in the dugout.
That matters because Dipoto’s history includes a difficult relationship with Mike Scioscia during his time with the Angels, a dynamic that eventually helped push him out of Los Angeles. It’s easy to wonder whether Dipoto is more comfortable with managers who won’t push back too hard on his vision. Front offices need someone willing to challenge ideas, and that kind of tension does not appear to be a major feature in Seattle right now.
None of this is to say Dipoto has been a failure. Far from it.
His winning percentage across his time leading baseball operations with both the Angels and the Mariners is around .520. He has delivered winning seasons, playoff appearances, talented players, and a ton of quality pitching.
He has also given the Mariners stability.
And that’s exactly why the warning matters. Stability can be a strength, just as it has been for Cashman in New York. But if Seattle keeps Dipoto around simply because the arrangement has become familiar, the Mariners could end up valuing his floor so much that they stop asking whether the ceiling is high enough.
At some point, good enough stops being good enough.
In Other News...
Mariners May Be Headed For A Josh Naylor Decision Fans Dread
The Mariners are staring at an offseason that could force some uncomfortable choices, and Josh Naylor is now part of that conversation. Seattles playoff push has been bumpy, and if the front office decides a broader roster shakeup is coming, the first base mix is one of the spots that could get examined closely after Naylors uneven 2026 season.
Naylor arrived with real expectations after what he did previously, but his production has not matched the same level and that has opened the door to speculation about his future in Seattle. A trade would not be a simple call, especially with the kind of lineup support the Mariners still need, but the possibility has already led to some outside ideas, including a potential swap with Toronto involving Anthony Santander. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Just Ran Into Taylor Wards Most Frustrating Pattern
Taylor Ward arrived in Seattle with the kind of track record that suggested the Mariners were getting a bat they could count on, but the early return has looked very different. His performance has dropped off sharply since the trade, and the Mariners are dealing with the same basic issue that has followed him around for years: the production comes in waves, then disappears just as quickly.
Ward has long been one of the streakier hitters in the league since 2021, and the current slump is exposing the downside of that profile. His walk rate has fallen, his power is down from what he showed in earlier seasons with Anaheim and Baltimore, and Seattle is still waiting for the version of Ward that can settle into a steady middle-of-the-order presence. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Closing Stretch Comes Down To Randy And Julio
With 13 games left and the Mariners five games out of a playoff spot, the final stretch has started to look less like a chase and more like an audition for what comes next. Two of the biggest names attached to that future are Randy Arozarena and Julio Rodrguez, one in the middle of a strong season that has raised the stakes on his next contract, the other trying to steady himself after a second-half slide.
Arozarena is shaping up to be one of the clubs most important offseason decisions, with a qualifying offer for 2027 expected and the bigger question being whether Seattle can work out something longer term. Julios situation is different but no less central to the Mariners outlook, because his recent uptick has offered at least a hint of the player this lineup needs him to be. For a team already looking past this year, how those two finish may say a lot about what the next one is supposed to look like. [Read more 🡒]