The Mariners may have already decided J.P. Crawford won’t be part of their 2027 plans, but that doesn’t erase the case for what he meant to the franchise.
Last week, Seattle reportedly told the longtime infielder he won’t be back in 2027, even though Crawford said at the end of 2026 that he wanted to return. That move wasn’t a shock to everyone. Buster Olney of ESPN said he wasn’t surprised, and he explained why when speaking about the situation.
What did spark debate was the idea that Crawford could eventually wind up in the Mariners Hall of Fame. That drew plenty of pushback, and it’s easy to see why.
Crawford never put up eye-popping numbers, never made an All-Star team, and never really looked like a classic Hall of Fame type. His value came from steadiness, dependability and loyalty.
There are other Mariners names that feel more obvious in that conversation. Alex Rodriguez feels like a Hall of Famer more.
Kyle Seager feels like a Hall of Famer more. There’s even a case for Mitch Haniger, and maybe Harold Reynolds too.
Still, Crawford’s candidacy isn’t built on flash. It’s built on a body of work that stacks up better than it might first appear.
He ranks No. 9 on the franchise’s all-time WAR list for position players, sitting ahead of Alvin Davis and Dan Wilson, both of whom are already in the team’s Hall of Fame. He’s 10th in offensive WAR and 10th in defensive WAR as well, despite the questions that have followed his defense in recent years. He also won a Gold Glove Award in 2020.
The longevity piece matters too. Crawford is 10th in franchise history in games played, has played the most games in team history at shortstop, and sits 10th in at-bats. He’s also 10th in runs scored and seventh in walks drawn.
Then there’s the loyalty angle. Crawford spent eight years in Seattle, signed a contract extension, and stayed with a franchise that has often struggled to keep players around. That kind of commitment carries weight in the same way it does for Seager and Felix Hernandez.
And there’s one more part of the story: the drought. After the 2018 season, when the Mariners began reshaping the roster, Crawford was the first player the organization targeted.
In a lot of ways, he became the face of the rebuild and the face of hope. He also helped deliver on that hope when Seattle broke the drought and reached the playoffs in 2022.
In Other News...
Jerry Dipoto Just Put Two Mariners Positions In The Spotlight
Jerry Dipoto used the General Managers Meetings to sketch out the Mariners offseason priorities, and the picture he drew was pretty clear: defense and depth are at the top of the list. With the collective bargaining agreement set to expire on Dec. 1, Seattles president of baseball operations said the club wants to get better in the field while also making sure it has enough reliable options across the roster, especially with left field and third base now in focus after the departures of Randy Arozarena and J.P. Crawford.
The bullpen is part of the conversation too, with Dipoto saying the Mariners would like to add one or two leverage relievers before spring training gets closer. Just as important, he stressed that any new pieces need to fit the way Seattle wants to play, which suggests this winter may be less about splash and more about fit, versatility and keeping the roster aligned with the clubs identity. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Fans May Hate How The Brendan Donovan Trade Looks Now
The Arizona Fall League offered a frustrating contrast for Mariners followers watching the organizations young talent, because the clubs prospects did not make much noise there while a former Seattle prospect was turning heads in a Cardinals uniform. Tai Peete, who is now in St. Louis system, put together a strong showing that earned him AFL Offensive Player of the Year honors, a sign that his bat has taken a meaningful step forward and that his stock is climbing fast.
For Seattle, that only adds another layer to the lingering questions around the Brendan Donovan trade and how it has aged. Donovans time with the Mariners was complicated by injuries and a lack of positional clarity, and the broader picture now includes a player the organization once had in hand looking more and more like a future big leaguer, with a debut projected for 2027. It is the kind of development that can make a deal feel very different in hindsight, especially when the return has yet to establish itself. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Face A Tough Rule 5 Call On One Prospect
Carlos Jimenez is suddenly part of one of those front-office decisions that can shape a farm system for years. The 23-year-old outfielder, one of Seattles top prospects, is now eligible for the Rule 5 Draft, which means the Mariners have to decide whether to put him on the 40-man roster before the deadline and shield him from being taken away.
Jimenez is still early in his climb, having just reached Single-A after signing internationally, and his major league timeline is still viewed as a few years away. The wrinkle is the ongoing lockout, which could prevent the Rule 5 Draft from even happening and complicate the Mariners calculus as they weigh whether to use a roster spot now or risk leaving him exposed. [Read more 🡒]
