The Dodgers are staring at the same ugly lesson the Mariners already lived through: a star can be so banged up that putting him out there only makes the problem worse.
That’s where Shohei Ohtani is right now. Los Angeles is even weighing a bench move for Game 3 on Wednesday, with Ken Rosenthal and Katie Woo of The Athletic reporting that rookie Josue De Paula could get the nod instead.
Dave Roberts already pushed Ohtani down in the batting order, so this would simply be the next step. Alden Gonzalez of ESPN reported a slightly different angle, saying the Dodgers will keep playing Ohtani “ if he deems himself healthy.”
But the team has every reason to be wary.
The numbers have been brutal. Ohtani last went deep on August 18 and is 14-for-90 over his last 24 games.
That stretch includes the first six games of the playoffs, and the last two have helped leave the Dodgers in an 0-2 hole against the Milwaukee Brewers in the NLCS. Ohtani himself said earlier this month that his left knee and right biceps were still bothering him, and the two weeks he spent on the injured list in September now look like they were overdue and not nearly enough.
Right now, Ohtani doesn’t look like a four-time MVP carrying a contender. He looks like a hitter trapped in his own body, too hurt to pitch and struggling badly at the plate. It’s been hard to watch.
The Mariners saw this movie with Cal Raleigh, just on a lesser stage. His 2026 season turned when an oblique strain on his right side, suffered sometime in late April, wasn’t enough to send him to the injured list until mid-May.
In that gap, the damage piled up. Raleigh went 0-for-38 at one point, and in the 11 games before the IL stint he hit 2-for-44 with 19 strikeouts.
That’s the same kind of warning sign the Dodgers are seeing now with Ohtani: the kind that jumps off the page and still somehow doesn’t need the page to be convincing. Raleigh was clearly not right, and every trip to the plate while he tried to play through it only reinforced the point.
Once Seattle finally put Raleigh on the IL, the situation improved. The Mariners went 16-13 while he was out, not because Mitch Garver and Jhonny Pereda became lineup anchors, but because they weren’t a black hole the way Raleigh had been while hurt.
That’s why the Dodgers deserve credit for at least considering the bench. Ohtani isn’t helping them right now; he’s hurting them.
And if De Paula gets the call, there’s at least some reason for optimism there. His 11 games with the Dodgers at the end of the year produced a 1.081 OPS, with more walks (11) and extra-base hits (6) than strikeouts (5).
The Mariners’ mistake was being too slow to act with Raleigh, even if that was only one of several issues in their season. They may also have rushed him back too soon, because his first 49 games after returning from the IL brought only a .551 OPS.
In Other News...
Mariners Fans Finally Have One Real Reason For Offseason Hope
The Mariners offseason outlook got a little more interesting after a 76-86 finish left them with the eighth-best odds in the 2027 MLB draft lottery. It is not the kind of immediate consolation prize fans were hoping for, but it does at least give Seattle a tangible path to adding another high-end amateur talent after the clubs earlier success landing Kade Anderson in 2025.
Seattles attention now turns to the shape of that draft board, with the front office eyeing a pool that could include Mississippi State left-hander Tomas Valincius or outfielder Landon Hairston depending on how the lottery breaks. The complication, of course, is that the whole picture could shift if the expiring Collective Bargaining Agreement leads to a lockout, leaving even this one real reason for optimism hanging in the balance. [Read more 🡒]
Mariners Face A Randy Arozarena Decision That Could Shape Their Offseason
Randy Arozarenas first season in Seattle gave the Mariners exactly the kind of middle-of-the-order production they were hoping for when they brought him in, and now the front office has to decide how much that matters in the bigger picture. Extending a qualifying offer would be a bet on keeping one of the lineups more reliable bats in place, while also signaling that Seattle is willing to make a real financial commitment as it sorts through an offseason that needs both offense and roster clarity.
The wrinkle is that the decision carries consequences even if Arozarena does not stay. If he declines, the Mariners would not just move on from a productive hitter, they would also have to weigh how any compensation fits into the rest of their winter plans and the way they build around the current core. For a club trying to thread the needle between contention and flexibility, this is the kind of call that can shape the tone of the entire offseason before the meetings even get going. [Read more 🡒]
Red Sox Offseason Could Get Messy If This Outfield Pursuit Is Real
Randy Arozarenas next move is already being kicked around before the offseason even gets rolling, and the speculation has a Seattle angle to it. Bleacher Reports Zachary D. Rymer floated the idea of the Red Sox signing the Mariners outfielder in free agency, a prediction that would send one of Seattles more recognizable bats into a different league contender and immediately reshape the market around him.
What makes the idea stand out is the fit, or lack of it, on Bostons side. The Red Sox are already carrying a crowded outfield, which is why any pursuit of Arozarena would come with some awkward roster math even before the contract discussion begins. For the Mariners, it is the kind of rumor that reminds you how quickly a players value can turn into someone elses offseason problem. [Read more 🡒]