The Sharks’ early-season story has been defined by more than one hot topic, but the one that keeps bubbling to the top is the guy in goal.
Alex Nedeljkovic has been the steadier of San Jose’s two options, and Thursday night in Nashville was the latest reminder. He turned aside 28 shots in regulation, added four more stops in overtime and then made two saves in the shootout to help the Sharks escape with a wild 3-2 win at Bridgestone Arena.
A week after a 24-save overtime win over the St. Louis Blues, he came through again.
“He was unbelievable,” Sharks forward Will Smith said of Nedeljkovic after Thursday’s game. “He won that game for us. He was unbelievable all night, and we always feel comfortable with him back there.”
That kind of performance has a way of forcing a bigger conversation, especially with Yaroslav Askarov coming off a stretch of uneven outings. Askarov has a .848 save percentage in five starts, and Tuesday against the Boston Bruins was another tough night.
Late in the second period at SAP Center, Pavel Zacha was left wide open and buried a shot past Askarov to make it a two-goal game heading into the third. The Sharks eventually fell 6-3, and Askarov stopped just 20 of 25 shots while making his fifth start in six games to help him adjust to a No. 1 workload.
Still, this isn’t as simple as handing the net to the hottest goalie and calling it a day. Natural Stat Trick has the Sharks among the NHL’s worst teams at giving up high-danger chances, so the defensive environment matters here too. But there’s also no ignoring the times when Askarov has needed one of those game-saving stops and couldn’t quite produce it.
Nedeljkovic, meanwhile, has been exactly what the Sharks hoped for when they acquired him from the Pittsburgh Penguins last summer for a 2028 third-round pick and then extended him in March. He’s been a dependable NHL pro for a long time.
At the same time, the numbers show a wrinkle the Sharks have to manage carefully: on one day’s rest, he has a .873 save percentage in nine games since the start of the 2022-23 season. In March, when Askarov was sidelined by a lower-body injury, Nedeljkovic posted a .867 save percentage over six games in 13 days, and San Jose went 2-4-0.
That makes the next few decisions less about emotion and more about sequencing. It’s unclear whether the Sharks will turn back to Askarov at Little Caesars Arena on Saturday, though after Thursday’s effort it would be a tough call to sit Nedeljkovic against one of his former teams. One of the two goalies will get the Toronto Maple Leafs on Monday, and the other is set for the Montreal Canadiens the next night.
For the long run, the Sharks seem to need something more deliberate than simply riding a “hot hand.” Nedeljkovic appears better suited to a lighter rhythm, while Askarov - outside of his standout play last November - still looks like a goalie who needs the right workload rather than too much too soon. The smartest path may be to map out starts ahead of time and keep both in a range that works.
There was plenty else to like in Nashville, too, starting with Sam Dickinson. He was on the ice when Steven Stamkos tied the game 2-2 with less than a second left in regulation, but that one moment shouldn’t overshadow what was one of Dickinson’s best NHL performances.
With Darnell Nurse out because of an upper-body injury, Dickinson skated a career-high 24:39 alongside Jacob Trouba, killed penalties, blocked a team-best five shots and logged 1:35 in overtime. He also got 10:06 of third-period ice time in a tight game, a clear sign of the trust he’s earning from coach Ryan Warsofsky.
There’s still more growth ahead, especially on the offensive side, but this was the kind of step forward San Jose has been waiting to see from Dickinson in his second NHL season.
Michael Kesselring had his best game as a Shark as well. He picked up his first point with the team by assisting on Smith’s third-period goal, and he looked effective while paired with Dmitry Orlov.
And then there’s the line that’s been getting attention for all the right reasons. Alexander Wennberg, Tyler Toffoli and Mason Marchment - the so-called ‘UNC’ line, as some on social media have labeled them because of their age - has been solid through two games. They’ve outchanced opponents 8-5 over that span, and they’ve also been asked to handle several defensive-zone starts.
On Thursday, that group delivered San Jose’s first goal five minutes and 30 seconds into the game. After a forecheck, Toffoli took a pass from Wennberg behind the net and found Marchment driving to the crease for a 1-0 lead.
For now, it’s a trio worth keeping an eye on, and maybe the Sharks have stumbled into a line that can give them something useful for however long it sticks together.
In Other News...
Sam Dickinson Is Giving The Sharks A Blue Line Decision To Make
Sam Dickinsons latest turn in the lineup gave the Sharks another reason to think hard about their blue line. In the 3-2 shootout win over Nashville, the young defenseman handled a heavier workload and looked more settled doing it, continuing the kind of steady rise that has made his spot in the conversation feel more real after he was scratched earlier in the season. Coach Ryan Warsofsky has noticed the difference, praising Dickinsons improved play and consistency as the Sharks sort through how they want to shape their defense.
Darnell Nurses status only adds another layer to the decision. He was a full participant in practice, but the upper-body issue that has him listed as day-to-day still leaves his availability unresolved for the upcoming game against Detroit. For a team trying to build on a win and get the back end organized, the timing matters, because Dickinson has suddenly made it harder to treat those minutes as a temporary fill-in. [Read more 🡒]