For a long time, Connor Hellebuyck-to-San Jose would have sounded like pure fantasy. He was Winnipeg’s franchise backbone, a three-time Vezina Trophy winner, the 2025 Hart Trophy winner, and a goalie who signed long term and said he wanted to be a Jet for life.
Now the idea is actually on the board.
Hellebuyck requested a trade this summer, refused to report to training camp, and was suspended. Elliotte Friedman reported that the Sharks have kicked the tires on a possible deal, which is enough to make this more than a loose rumor.
For San Jose, the appeal is obvious: goaltending has been the club’s clearest weak spot, and Hellebuyck would instantly change that conversation. But the fit is not nearly as simple as the need.
The upside is easy to see. Last season, goaltending was arguably the biggest thing holding the Sharks back from a playoff push, with Yaroslav Askarov putting up numbers well below league average behind a young defense.
Even if Hellebuyck is no longer at his absolute peak, he would still be a major upgrade. At his best, he’s the top goalie of his generation, with three Vezinas, a Hart, and a .916 save percentage over 625 games, all in Winnipeg.
There’s also the timing. San Jose finished four points out of a playoff spot and spent the offseason adding veterans to speed up its climb.
A goalie like Hellebuyck could be the difference between being on the outside looking in and becoming a real postseason team. And because he has five years left on his deal after this season, he wouldn’t be a short-term patch.
He could hold the crease while the young core matures.
His control matters too. Hellebuyck has a full no-move clause and has reportedly turned down multiple options, including refusing to waive for any Canadian team.
If the Sharks are truly in the mix, that suggests he would approve San Jose as a destination. That alone narrows the field in a way that could work in the Sharks’ favor.
But the warning signs are just as loud.
The biggest issue is the contract. Hellebuyck’s cap hit is $8.5 million through 2030-31, and that is a serious commitment for a team that still has to pay its young core. To make a deal work, either salary would need to go back to Winnipeg or the Jets would have to hold money back, and analysts have already pointed to the cap fit as the main obstacle.
There’s also the age and timeline problem. Locking in that kind of money for a goalie entering his mid-thirties, right as Askarov and prospect Joshua Ravensbergen are supposed to be developing, could complicate the whole organizational plan.
And then there’s the form. Hellebuyck is coming off the worst season of his career, finishing 23-23-11 with a 2.86 goals-against average and an .895 save percentage.
It was his first sub-.900 save percentage in a decade, and it came as Winnipeg fell from first in the Central Division to seventh.
Yes, some of that was the team collapsing around him. Still, it’s fair to ask whether he’s the kind of goalie worth paying such a steep price for now. His well-known postseason road struggles only deepen that concern.
The price in assets could be just as painful. Winnipeg will want a strong return for a franchise goalie, likely including premium young pieces or picks, and those are exactly the kinds of assets San Jose has been gathering to build for the future. Using that stockpile on a 33-year-old in hopes of chasing a wild-card spot would be a very different kind of move from the patient approach that has shaped the Sharks’ rebuild.
So the answer sits somewhere in the middle.
If the cost stays reasonable and Winnipeg eats meaningful salary, Hellebuyck is a swing worth exploring. Elite goaltending is hard to find, and San Jose badly needs it. But if the deal requires sending out real roster pieces and taking on the full $8.5 million cap hit, it starts to look like a bet that doesn’t match where the Sharks are in their timeline.
The interest is real. The question is whether the price makes sense for a team whose window is only starting to open.
In Other News...
Sharks Young Defenseman Suddenly Facing Real Lineup Pressure
Nolan Allans first camp with the Sharks has already done more than give the coaching staff a look at a player acquired from the Blackhawks. The young defenseman has stood out enough to work his way into a top-four practice role alongside veteran Jacob Trouba, a sign that San Jose sees real opening-night potential in him if he stays healthy.
But the picture on the back end is still very much in flux, which is why these preseason games matter so much. The Sharks are using the schedule to sort through several young defenders, and Allan is not the only one pushing for a place, with Luca Cagnoni also in the mix and Sam Dickinsons standing suddenly looking far less secure. [Read more 🡒]
Ivar Stenberg Is Already Giving Sharks Fans A Big Draft Debate
The early buzz around the 2026 NHL Draft is already turning into a familiar kind of debate for Sharks fans, because San Joses selection, Ivar Stenberg, and Torontos No. 1 pick, Gavin McKenna, are taking different paths into the spotlight. McKenna has looked creative and driven play well in preseason, even if the scoring column has not followed yet, while Stenberg has shown the kind of offensive pop that immediately gets a fan base talking about what might have been on the board.
For San Jose, the comparison is less about a scoreboard snapshot than about the pressure that comes with being the second player taken in a draft class that is expected to be watched closely for years. Both prospects carry elite scouting resumes, but they are also entering very different developmental situations, which only adds to the intrigue around how their careers will unfold. Stenbergs recent surge has given Sharks fans something to latch onto right away, and it has also made the long view of this draft a little more interesting than usual. [Read more 🡒]