The San Jose Sharks took a big swing this summer, and so far it’s landing like a whiff.
In their push to move from rebuilding to contending, the Sharks brought in Darnell Nurse as the kind of veteran defenseman they hoped could steady the blue line and help speed up the timeline. The price was steep: Shakir Mukhamadullin and defensive prospect Zack Sharp went the other way, and San Jose absorbed Nurse’s full $9.25MM cap hit along with the remaining four years on his contract.
That kind of commitment only works if the player delivers. Right now, Nurse hasn’t come close.
Through 20 games, Nurse has one goal and one assist and sits at minus-5 while averaging 21:23 of ice time per night. His most common partner, Michael Kesselring, has not been a fit.
Together, they’ve posted a 20% Goals For Percentage, allowing 12 goals in 249 minutes at five-on-five while being on for just three goals, according to Natural Stat Trick. Nurse’s even-strength possession rate sits at 45.9%, and the broader numbers don’t offer much relief either.
What makes the situation worse is that the Sharks are leaning on him heavily. Nurse is logging the third-most ice time on the roster, trailing only Macklin Celebrini and Jacob Trouba. That’s a lot of responsibility for a player who has not stabilized the group around him.
The issues have shown up in the same places over and over. Nurse still has the skating and the size, but those traits are not turning into impact.
His gap control has been shaky, with too much space given to opposing forwards. In his own zone, he has been caught scrambling and losing coverage, and that has opened the door to dangerous chances against.
None of that should have been a total surprise. Nurse has never been a big point producer, reaching 40 points only twice in his career, and he has not been a driver of play for about five years. The defensive problems have usually been more of a playoff issue in recent seasons, but the early returns in San Jose suggest the concern may be broader than that.
The Sharks were betting that a new environment would help. But a lot of Nurse’s best work in Edmonton came with Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl around him.
Last season, his expected-goals rate at five-on-five without McDavid on the ice was 47.1%, and with McDavid it jumped to 57.5%. He also spent plenty of time skating with McDavid in previous seasons, including 35.6% of his five-on-five shifts in 2022-23.
That dropped to 23.8% last year. Moving to a new team does not automatically explain a collapse, but having the best player in the world beside you more than a third of the time is a luxury that covers a lot of flaws.
The contract may be the biggest problem of all. Nurse is 31, and the odds of him suddenly playing like he did at 26 are slim.
With three years left after this one, San Jose is staring at the possibility of being tied to a deal that other teams would not want to touch. That matters even more with young players like Will Smith due for new contracts in the coming summers.
On paper, the Sharks have $29MM for next year with just five players to sign. But the larger issue is what they’re spending that money on.
If a team wants to take the next step, pouring major cap space into a below-replacement-level defenseman is not the cleanest path. General manager Mike Grier will have to sort that out if he wants to build a roster that properly supports the young core.
There’s still a chance this is just the early stage of a transition, and Nurse is adjusting to a new city, organization, and system. He still has the tools of an NHL player.
Just not the kind the Sharks were paying for. Time will tell.
In Other News...
Sharks Added A Battle-Tested Scorer With A Remarkable NHL Path
Mason Marchments journey to 100 NHL goals is the kind of path that still stands out in a league built on pedigree and draft status. The undrafted forward spent time in the AHL and ECHL before getting his first NHL look with the Toronto Maple Leafs, then carved out a career with stops on several teams before landing in San Jose on a long-term deal.
Now Marchment has reached a milestone that only a select group of NHL players can claim, and it adds another layer to what the Sharks were buying when they brought him in. For a team looking for proven offense and a player who has had to earn everything the hard way, his latest goal is a reminder that his value goes beyond the usual box score. [Read more 🡒]