Gavin McKenna and Ivar Stenberg didn’t need long to end up in the same conversation.
When the San Jose Sharks came to Toronto on Monday, the attention naturally drifted to the first and second picks in the 2026 NHL Entry Draft. It’s the kind of setup that can get overplayed in a hurry, but this time there was at least enough substance behind it to make the storyline worth following.
McKenna and Stenberg were facing each other in a real NHL game for the first time, with their clubs meeting in an actually competitive setting after only a pre-tournament game before the 2026 World Juniors had linked them previously. In that one, McKenna had a rough night and Stenberg delivered the winner.
By the nine-game mark, both teenagers had already reached another important checkpoint: their entry-level contracts can no longer slide. That technical detail may not have changed much about how either player is viewed, but it does put an official stamp on what their play has already shown. Both are NHLers, and both have already started to look the part.
The wrinkle is that their situations couldn’t be more different. McKenna has been dropped into a Toronto lineup built around established names such as Auston Matthews, William Nylander, John Tavares and fellow newcomer Kirill Marchenko. Stenberg, meanwhile, is playing alongside a younger group that includes Macklin Celebrini, Will Smith, Michael Misa and Sam Dickinson.
McKenna’s early season has had some uneven patches, but the flashes have been obvious. He went quiet in his first three games before breaking through with a goal and an assist against the Nashville Predators in his fourth.
That opened the door to a four-game point streak, and the fit has already been easy to see. His vision and creativity have given Toronto another layer in the attack, and his work on the power play has helped either breathe life into an inconsistent first unit or turn the second unit into a real threat of its own.
“The talent is obvious, but his personality, just the way he carries himself, his quiet confidence [has impressed me],” Leafs head coach Jim Hiller said ahead of the game. “He’s unflappable, maybe that’s a word I would use with him. Just a really great kid who’s got on a trajectory and is going to have a phenomenal career.”
There has been a rough patch, too. In the eighth game, McKenna spent most of Toronto’s 5-4 overtime loss to the Buffalo Sabres on the bench.
Whether that was simply a matter of bench management, as Hiller suggested, or tied to defensive issues, it stood out. His +0.79 5v5 expected goals against per 60 minutes relative to his teammates ranks 17th-worst among forwards with 100 minutes this season.
Even so, it hasn’t lingered. McKenna logged a new career high in ice time in the next game against the New York Islanders, then followed it with a power-play goal and the game-winner against the Sharks.
Stenberg has been steadier. He was held off the scoresheet in his debut, picked up his first assist in game two, and then alternated between point-less outings and games where he chipped in, including his first NHL goal in his sixth appearance. Quietly, he’s moved into a tie with McKenna for second in rookie scoring, along with three others.
“He’s been really good,” Sharks head coach Ryan Warsofsky said. “The game’s slowed down for him.
He’s confident. He’s picking up things really quickly.”
His defensive game has also looked more settled than McKenna’s. Stenberg sits at 0.12 in 5v5 XGA/60 Rel among forwards with 100 minutes of ice time, which places him 120th out of 200.
That’s not elite territory, but it’s a solid early foundation, especially for a rookie. And while expectations were high for his two-way game, plenty of strong defensive players have needed time to sort things out in their first NHL season.
That’s really the broader story here: both players are tracking close to what was expected of them at the draft, if not ahead of schedule in McKenna’s case. He was supposed to need time to adjust while still flashing the skill and hockey sense that made him the first pick.
Stenberg was supposed to look more NHL-ready from day one. So far, that’s more or less how it’s gone.
The two teenagers also handled the spotlight the right way, with both offering respectful praise for the other. McKenna described Stenberg as calm and difficult to rattle.
“He’s a confident player and he’s not afraid to make plays,” McKenna said. “Just a super calm player and [doesn’t] really seem to make too many mistakes.”
Stenberg’s answer was shorter, but no less complimentary.
“I haven’t watched anything, so I don’t know,” Stenberg said. “But [at] World Juniors, [he was] super good. Only good stuff about him.”
The game itself didn’t deliver a grand verdict on anything beyond the box score. McKenna finished with the deciding goal, while Stenberg was stuck with a night that showed up poorly in the numbers, including a team-worst 22.74% 5v5 xGF%. But the real action was elsewhere: both teams trading chances, both goalies making the kind of saves that kept the game tight, and Sergei Bobrovsky and Yaroslav Askarov turning it into a one-goal game for 59 minutes.
“I don’t really go out there thinking it’s McKenna versus Stenberg, it’s Leafs versus the Sharks,” McKenna said.
So no, one night doesn’t settle any debate about who’s better. But McKenna did show he can handle the moment, and that matters when you’re the first-overall pick and expected to carry that weight.
“I’m trying to be known as the guy who’s able to perform in those situations,” McKenna said.
And if you were wondering how much time the two actually spent sharing the ice, the answer is barely any at all: just one second.
In Other News...
Macklin Celebrini Gave The Sharks A Boost They Desperately Needed
The Sharks had little margin for error in Montreal, especially after falling behind by two goals, but they found enough push to claw back and leave town with a 4-3 overtime win over the Canadiens. The result nudged San Jose to 5-4-1 and gave the club another useful checkpoint on a six-game road trip that has already produced a few reminders that this group can hang around even when the night starts badly.
Macklin Celebrini was at the center of it again, giving San Jose the finish it needed when the game reached overtime. The Sharks were also operating without Alexander Wennberg, who exited Mondays game with an upper-body injury and was unavailable against Montreal, leaving his status day-to-day as the team waits to see how its lineup settles in for the next stretch. [Read more 🡒]
Stars Lose A Key Defensive Piece At The Worst Time
The Sharks are dealing with another lineup question after Alexander Wennberg was forced out of Mondays loss at Toronto in the third period with an upper-body injury. His availability matters because he has been part of San Joses forward mix, and any absence changes the way the club lines up down the middle and in support roles as it heads into the next stretch.
San Jose was already left to make an adjustment against Montreal, where Ty Dellandrea stepped into the lineup in Wennbergs place. With Wennberg now considered day-to-day, the Sharks will be watching closely to see whether this is a short-term absence or something that keeps them reshuffling the forward group again in the immediate future. [Read more 🡒]
Celebrini Gives Sharks Fans Another Reason To Believe
The Sharks left Montreal with a 4-3 overtime win that fit the kind of night their fans have been waiting to see more often. San Jose got goals from Michael Misa and Tyler Toffoli along with a two-goal performance from Macklin Celebrini, and the result at the Bell Center offered another reminder that this group can skate with some resilience when the game gets tight and the stakes start to rise.
Celebrini has been at the center of that optimism, giving San Jose a young cornerstone who can tilt a game in a hurry. The win also showed the value of having more than one source of offense, with Toffoli and Misa each finding the net as the Sharks kept pushing through a back-and-forth night that ended with two points on the road and another reason for their supporters to lean in. [Read more 🡒]