On Oct. 9, 1987, Candlestick Park was already buzzing with tension when Bob Forsch stepped in and hit Jeffrey Leonard in the fifth inning of Game 3 of the National League Championship Series.
The Giants were up 4-0, and Leonard had spent the first three games tormenting St. Louis.
The left fielder had homered in each of the series’ first three contests, and his “one flap down” home run trot had become a flash point between the clubs. Leonard, known as “HacMan,” would let his left arm hang at his side as he rounded the bases, a celebration Giants fans loved and Cardinals players loathed.
According to Graham Womack of The Sporting News, the act had become a major source of friction. St.
Louis believed Leonard was mocking its pitchers. Leonard saw it as part of who he was and how he competed.
With starter Joe Magrane already out of the game, Forsch came on in relief and, on a 1-1 pitch, drilled Leonard with a fastball. Leonard thought it was deliberate. Magrane later described the dugout reaction in Womack’s retrospective: “There was a lot of, 'Take that and your One Flap Down stuff' coming from our dugout,” Magrane said.
The hit-by-pitch didn’t immediately alter the score, but the inning still had a chance to swing hard in the Giants’ favor. St. Louis loaded the bases with one out, then Forsch escaped by getting Chili Davis on a pop-up and Will Clark on a fly ball.
That escape turned into the opening the Cardinals needed. They scored twice in the sixth on Jim Lindeman’s two-run homer, then broke the game open with four more runs, including Vince Coleman’s two-run single, to flip a 4-0 deficit into a 6-4 lead.
The Giants added a run in the ninth, but St. Louis held on for a 6-5 win.
The Cardinals left Candlestick with a 2-1 series lead, and Magrane said the moment changed the mood inside the clubhouse. “We as a team thought that that really, really woke us up,” Magrane said. “Because the Giants had us on the run, Candlestick was going crazy and we knew we had two more games there.”
Leonard didn’t back off. The next afternoon, he homered again, this time off Danny Cox in Game 4, helping the Giants even the series. It was his fourth home run in four straight NLCS games, a postseason record at the time.
The Giants then won Game 5 to take a 3-2 lead back to St. Louis, but the Cardinals answered with the final two punches.
Lefty John Tudor shut out San Francisco 1-0 in Game 6 in a tight duel with Dave Dravecky, who threw six strong innings, allowed one run and struck out eight. Then St.
Louis rolled in Game 7, with Jose Oquendo hitting a three-run homer in a 6-0 win.
Even with the Cardinals’ comeback, Leonard was named NLCS Most Valuable Player after hitting .417 with four home runs and five RBIs. He remains the last player to win the award while playing for the losing team.
Years later, the episode still lingered. When Will Clark was traded to the Cardinals from the Baltimore Orioles at the 2000 trade deadline, he ran into a retired Forsch before a Cardinals home game.
Clark later recalled the exchange in a 2019 interview with Cardinals broadcasters Dan McLaughlin and Ricky Horton: “I came up to him and said, Bob I want to thank you and I shook his hand,” Clark said. “He said for what Will?
I said, thank goodness you didn't drill me in the ribs.”
In Other News...
Giants Face Tough Calls On Who Still Fits Their 2025 Roster
With the 60-day injured list cleared out, the Giants have shifted from health updates to roster math, and the next wave of decisions is all about who still fits into their 2025 plans. San Francisco has already declined Rowan Wicks club option, even though he remains under team control, while Andrew Knizner, Jason Foley and Jos Butt were moved off the 40-man roster, with Butt quickly landing with the Texas Rangers.
Now the front office is sorting through six arbitration-eligible players and weighing which arms and infield pieces are worth carrying forward. Wick, Randy Rodrguez, Sam Hentges, Camilo Doval, Ryan Walker and Casey Schmitt are all in the mix, and the club is navigating projected salaries and possible contract outcomes as it tries to balance cost, depth and fit for next season. [Read more 🡒]
Rafael Devers Just Made The Giants Offseason Decision Much Harder
Rafael Devers first season in San Francisco already gave the Giants plenty to think about, and now it has added another layer. The first baseman was named a finalist for the 2026 National League Silver Slugger Award, putting him in a group with Jake Bauers, Alec Burleson and Matt Olson after a strong second half that helped stabilize the middle of the lineup.
Devers finished with a .258/.340/.525 batting line, 37 home runs and 98 RBIs before a core muscle injury shut him down in September. For a Giants club weighing its offseason priorities, his production only sharpens the conversation around how much value he brought and how important it is to keep that bat in the lineup going forward. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Have Another Key Staff Opening This Offseason
The Giants are facing another offseason staff change, with Hunter Mense leaving his role as the clubs hitting coach to join the Kansas City Royals as an assistant hitting coach. San Francisco has not officially announced the move, but Mense is the first member of last years coaching staff to depart, adding another decision point for a team already in the middle of its winter planning.
Oscar Bernard is still in place as assistant hitting coach, but the Giants now need to find a new lead voice for the group. For a club trying to sharpen its offense heading into next season, the opening matters because it goes beyond filling a title - it shapes how the lineup will be taught, adjusted and evaluated once spring work begins. [Read more 🡒]