Fox Sports made its choice, and for SF Giants fans, the Madison Bumgarner-Yoshinobu Yamamoto comparison landed the way you’d expect: Bumgarner got the starting nod.
The network rolled out a list of the best World Series performers of the 21st century, and the Giants had a few familiar names on it. Bumgarner was the starting pitcher over Yamamoto, Barry Bonds made the cut as a starter, and Pablo Sandoval and Tim Lincecum also earned spots on the roster.
Bonds’ place on the list came with a reminder of just how scorching his 2002 World Series was against the Los Angeles Angels. He put up a 1.994 OPS with four home runs and six RBI in 30 plate appearances. The only catch was that the season ended before that series could reach a conclusion.
At third base, Fox Sports went with David Freese over Sandoval, though the source of the debate is clear enough: there’s an argument for Sandoval there too.
The bigger call, though, was on the mound. Fox Sports didn’t just pick Bumgarner - it backed him with a blunt explanation of why he belongs at the top of the World Series pitching list.
"Madison Bumgarner isn’t just the best starting pitcher of the 21st-century World Series - he might be the best the league has ever seen in that setting... His 0.25 ERA across 36 innings is the lowest for a career, and he never lost a World Series game in five chances."
Fox Sports on Madison Bumgarner
That selection feeds directly into the long-running Giants-Dodgers argument over Bumgarner and Yamamoto, a debate that has been going for the past 12 months. Yamamoto did make the list, but only as a reserve.
The numbers in the source point clearly toward Bumgarner. He won World Series MVP honors in 2014 after giving up just one earned run in 21 innings against the Kansas City Royals and finishing the job in Game 7.
Yamamoto’s 2025 World Series was excellent in its own right. He allowed two earned runs in 17 innings against the Toronto Blue Jays and worked on back-to-back days as the Dodgers wrapped up the championship over Toronto.
Still, the comparison has a built-in hurdle for Yamamoto. Dodgers fans have argued that he faced a stronger lineup than the one Bumgarner dealt with in 2014, but that kind of qualification only underscores the gap in the actual results.
And there’s one more note from the source that strengthens Bumgarner’s case: the Royals were no accident. They got back to the World Series in 2015 and beat the New York Mets.
In Other News...
Wilmer Flores Heartbreak Is Fueling A Baseball Debate Giants Fans Know Too Well
The check-swing call that ended Game 2 of the World Series has reopened an argument Giants fans know all too well, because it instantly brought back memories of the disputed Wilmer Flores call from the 2021 NLDS. In both cases, a game turned on an umpire's ruling about whether the bat had gone far enough to count as a swing, and once again the debate has shifted from the moment itself to the rulebook behind it.
What has kept the discussion alive is the minor league check-swing review standard, which says the bat has to cross the foul line to be ruled a swing. That definition does not match the more traditional way fans and many in the game think about a check swing, and it has left room for confusion in high-pressure moments. The latest controversy only adds to the case for clearer definitions and review protocols, especially when a single call can decide October games and stir up old wounds in San Francisco. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Just Lost One Fix To Their Pitching Problem
The Giants pitching staff has been one of the biggest talking points around the club, and Buster Posey has already hinted that changes could come once the regular season ends. There is some movement behind the scenes already, with reports saying Frank Anderson is set to become an assistant pitching coach, Justin Meccage will stay on as pitching coach, Christian Wonder is headed into a role centered on the farm system and Jesse Chavez is expected back as bullpen coach.
One potential outside fix is now off the board. The Yankees locked up pitching coach Matt Blake with a three-year extension, removing a name the Giants could have explored if they decide to reshape the staff or take a different approach to the pitching problems that have dogged them. For a team still sorting through what the next version of its pitching infrastructure should look like, losing a candidate like that only narrows the options. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Infield Churn Could Suddenly Make Nate Furman Matter In 2027
A midseason wave of injuries and the trade involving Luis Arraez pushed Nate Furman into the Giants picture in August 2026, and the rookie infielder got a quick taste of the majors as the club searched for answers around the diamond. Furman arrived with a solid minor league hitting rsum, but his brief big league sample was modest, with four singles in 32 at-bats.
Even so, the Giants saw enough in his defense and speed to keep him in the conversation, and that matters with the infield still looking unsettled heading toward 2027. Furman may not have seized a regular role yet, but he has a path to sticking on the 40-man roster as useful depth, which is often how a player goes from emergency call-up to a legitimate part of the long-term plan. [Read more 🡒]