The Phillies’ Wild Card exit on Thursday night only sharpened the conversation around Luis Arraez, because Philadelphia could have used the former SF Giants second baseman in a series that went the full three games. Instead, the Braves moved on, and Arraez was left watching after an ankle injury kept him out of the matchup.
Arraez spent enough time with the Giants to make an impression almost immediately. He won over fans with his plate approach, his knack for turning almost any pitch into a single, and the fact that he turned out to be a surprisingly strong defender at second base. It’s easy to see why he felt like the kind of player who could have settled in for a few years, even if the Giants’ circumstances never really lined up that way.
San Francisco instead sent Arraez and reliever Caleb Kilian to Philadelphia in a deal that brought back pitchers Ramon Marquez and Marty Gair. The move didn’t produce the same kind of offensive output for Arraez in Philadelphia, though he did get off to a strong start. He finished the season at .310/.345/.419 with six home runs and 64 runs batted in over 151 games.
The ankle issue at the end of the regular season may have cost him a shot at a fourth batting title. Arizona Diamondbacks catcher Gabriel Moreno finished just ahead of him at .311.
For the Phillies, though, the bigger pain point was his absence in October. In a series decided over three games, a couple of timely hits could have changed the story.
Arraez is now headed back to free agency, and he’ll be looking to top the one-year, $13 million contract he signed with San Francisco last offseason. The Giants’ appeal was clear: they were willing to let him play second base, and he showed he can be one of the best there when given the chance.
As for a return to San Francisco, it doesn’t look likely. Going into 2027, Casey Schmitt would be the projected starter at second, though the Giants could choose to move Schmitt if they want to add pitching this offseason. Even then, the payroll picture points toward a cheaper internal answer, with Marcelo Mayer named as one possible option.
Arraez has earned a multi-year deal and a chance to keep playing second base. The hope, from a Giants perspective, is that he gets paid accordingly. Just not by the Dodgers.
In Other News...
Giants Can't Stay Silent On This Pride Night Controversy
Pride Night has long been one of the Giants more visible themed events, part of a wider run of celebrations the club has used to recognize different communities around the ballpark. Earlier this season, though, that showcase turned awkward when three players wrote Bible verses on their Pride hats and another declined to wear the hat at all, steps the team said were not authorized.
Commissioner Rob Manfred later described the episode as a communication breakdown, but the larger question around San Franciscos Pride Night presentation still hangs over the franchise. The Giants have declined to say whether the rainbow-colored hats will remain part of the annual observance going forward, leaving an already sensitive issue unresolved as the club weighs how it wants to handle the event next time around. [Read more 🡒]
Another Former Giants Arm Is Raising Tough Questions About This Staff
Tyler Mahles latest stretch has only sharpened the questions around what happened in San Francisco. After being dealt from the Giants to the Braves, the right-hander has pitched better, and his playoff start only added to the sense that Atlanta found something the Giants had not. The biggest difference, according to the story, was simple enough: the Braves urged him to lean harder on his splitter, a pitch that helped unlock the version of Mahle they were hoping to see.
For the Giants, the sting is not just losing another arm who looks revitalized elsewhere, but seeing the same pattern repeat. A pitcher leaves, a new staff makes a tweak, and the change pays off in a way that raises awkward questions about what San Francisco was missing. It is the kind of development that does not settle quickly, especially when it points back to coaching decisions and whether the Giants are getting enough from the group charged with maximizing their pitchers. [Read more 🡒]
Sonny Gray's Boston Frustration Could Open Door For Giants
The Red Soxs quick exit in the Wild Card round left Sonny Gray with more than a disappointing finish to sort through. Pulled early in the loss to the Yankees, the veteran right-hander made clear he was frustrated with how the game unfolded, and his comments afterward only added to the sense that his situation in Boston is far from settled as the offseason begins.
Gray also has a mutual option in his contract, which puts his future in a familiar kind of limbo and could push him toward free agency if he keeps pitching. For the Giants, that keeps a familiar name in the conversation as they look at possible rotation help, especially with Grays uncertainty in Boston leaving the door open for teams that need proven starting pitching. [Read more 🡒]