Logan Webb’s latest rough night in Pittsburgh didn’t just sting because the Giants lost 13-12. It also added another ugly data point to a stretch that has started to look far too familiar.
Tuesday was supposed to be a marquee pitching matchup between Webb and Paul Skenes, but neither starter got through five innings. Webb’s outing was the more alarming one: nine earned runs, no out recorded in the third inning, and an early exit that stood out as arguably the worst start of his big league career.
The problem for the Giants is that this wasn’t a one-off. Just over a week earlier, Webb was shelled by the Boston Red Sox at Fenway Park.
On August 21, he lasted only 2 and 2/3 innings and allowed five earned runs. The common thread in both starts was a lack of command that doesn’t usually show up in Webb’s game.
In Boston, he walked three and hit two batters. Against the Pirates, he walked two and hit two more.
That’s what makes this stretch so unsettling. This is not the version of Webb the Giants have built around for years.
He’s been the steady force, the pitcher who gives them innings and rarely lets them down. Now, with a 4.21 ERA in 2026 - his worst mark since 2020 - and a career-low 7.2 K/9 rate, the question is no longer whether he’s had a bad week.
It’s whether the Giants are seeing the first signs of something bigger.
That question gets louder because Webb turns 30 next season, and the Giants have seen this story before with their own homegrown aces. Tim Lincecum’s decline had already started by the time he hit 30.
Matt Cain never posted an ERA under 5.00 again after reaching that age. Madison Bumgarner left in free agency at 30 and later had a dreadful run with the Arizona Diamondbacks.
None of them pitched beyond their age-33 season.
Buster Posey and the Giants made it clear at the trade deadline that Webb wasn’t going anywhere. Teams reportedly asked, but the club didn’t entertain it.
That made perfect sense then. Webb is the ace, the clubhouse leader, the guy you don’t casually move.
The offseason could be different.
That doesn’t mean the Giants should suddenly start shopping him. But if another team comes with a serious offer, Posey may need to listen. At the very least, these two starts in Boston and Pittsburgh force a real conversation about whether Webb’s 2026 season is a temporary stumble or the start of a decline the Giants can’t afford to ignore.
For now, the Giants still don’t want to tear anything down. But they may have to confront a hard truth: even the most reliable arm in the building doesn’t stay that way forever. And if these outings were warning signs, they were loud ones.
In Other News...
Giants Just Sent Another Clear Message About Drew Gilbert
Drew Gilbert is getting another opportunity to set the tone for the Giants, and this time the club is also giving him a different defensive look. San Francisco kept him in the leadoff spot for its game against the Pirates while shifting him from center field to right field, part of a lineup shuffle that also sends Jonah Cox to the cleanup spot and puts Andrew Knizner behind the plate.
The changes fit a team that is trying to ride its previous win over Pittsburgh into a series victory. For Gilbert, the combination of top-of-the-order responsibility and a new outfield assignment suggests the Giants are still sorting out where he fits best, while also trusting him to stay in a prominent role as the lineup continues to evolve. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Are Betting Their Outfield Future On One Risky Choice
With Heliot Ramos traded and Harrison Bader battling an injury, the Giants have opened the door for a different kind of outfield plan. Turner Hill, Drew Gilbert and Jonah Cox are among the younger players now in position to show what they can handle, and that sort of internal audition matters for a club trying to map out its next few seasons without leaning too heavily on the open market.
The organization also has more outfield talent coming through the minors, which helps explain why it may be more willing to wait on its own players than chase an expensive corner bat. It is a sensible long-view approach, but it also puts real pressure on the next wave to turn opportunity into production, because the Giants seem intent on letting their future sort itself out from within. [Read more 🡒]
Yunior Marte's Giants Audition Suddenly Means More Than Just Innings
Yunior Martes path to the Giants has moved faster than anyone could have expected when he was still in Double-A, but injuries and roster needs forced the organization to bring him up and give him a look in the majors. His first big league start arrived quickly, and it came with a little extra attention too, as broadcasters pointed to similarities in body type and pitching style between Marte and former Giant Guillermo Mota, a comparison that at least gives San Francisco a familiar reference point for the kind of arm it may have in its system.
For the Giants, though, this is about more than covering innings in the moment. Martes stint is now part of a broader evaluation of where he fits going forward, including whether he needs to be protected from the Rule 5 Draft and whether he can work his way into future plans beyond this emergency opportunity. A call-up that began as a roster fix has suddenly turned into a meaningful test of just how much the club believes in what it has seen so far. [Read more 🡒]