Sonny Gray’s new deal with the Minnesota Twins may have done the Giants a favor, even if the reunion is happening somewhere else.
Gray signed a two-year, $55 million contract with a player option after the first season, a move that fits a familiar pattern for him. He had long looked like a possible Giants target because of his time with the A’s, but in free agency he has kept landing in the Midwest or on the East Coast. This latest agreement sends him back to Minnesota, where he pitched in 2022 and 2023 and earned an All-Star nod in his second season there.
For San Francisco, the more interesting part is what Gray’s contract might mean for Kevin Gausman. The comparison is easy to draw.
Gausman spent two seasons with the Giants, 2020 and 2021, and was an All-Star in his second year before the club let him walk in free agency. He then turned in several strong seasons with the Toronto Blue Jays.
Now the Giants have a chance to revisit that decision. Gausman is coming off a season in which he posted a 4.51 ERA in 32 starts split between Toronto and the Chicago Cubs.
He is almost 36, which might make some teams think discount. But Gray’s payday, along with Dustin May’s recent three-year, $52.5 million contract, suggests the market for veteran starters is still plenty strong.
That means Gausman may not come cheap if the Giants want him back.
A two-year contract in the $45-50 million range would not be a surprise. Teams are looking beyond ERA when they evaluate pitchers, and May’s deal was driven in part by his FIP and advanced metrics such as Stuff+. Gausman’s own FIP was 3.74, a sign that he may have been a little unlucky.
There is also the pitch-shape element. Clubs have shown more interest in pitchers with a strong changeup or splitter, and Gausman’s splitter was one of the defining weapons of his Giants tenure. Anyone who watched him in San Francisco remembers how effective it was.
From the Giants’ perspective, a two-year arrangement makes sense. It would give them rotation stability for the next couple of seasons and serve as a bridge until younger arms in the farm system, such as Jackson Flora, are ready for the majors.
The price, though, is the issue. Starting pitching is expensive, and San Francisco may need to go to around $22 million per year to get Gausman back to the Bay Area. Earlier this offseason, the expectation was a two-year, $50 million deal, especially if other teams, including the Blue Jays, entered the bidding.
Gray’s contract doesn’t settle the question, but it does set the range. The Giants now have a clearer idea of what a reunion with Gausman might cost. The only thing left is whether they want to pay it.
In Other News...
Giants Just Sent A Clear Message About Which Young Arms Matter
The Giants made their priorities clear this week by protecting three young pitchers from the Rule 5 draft, adding Henry Lalane, Marty Gair and Josh Bostick to the 40-man roster. It was a move that spoke as much about the organizations pitching pipeline as it did about the immediate roster picture, with Lalane standing out as the most advanced of the group and expected to begin next season in Double-A.
Gair and Bostick are further behind but still viewed as arms with future major-league possibilities, even if each comes with some developmental questions. To create the room, San Francisco designated Christian Koss and Rowan Wick for assignment, a reminder that the 40-man crunch often forces tough choices when a club decides which young players are worth protecting now and which ones can be exposed to the market. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Have Created A Bullpen Problem They Did Not Expect
The Giants trade of Erik Miller for infielder Marcelo Mayer was always going to be judged through the lens of the prospect return, but it also quietly changed the shape of the bullpen. Miller had been a useful left-handed option in San Francisco, posting a 2.76 ERA in 38 appearances before the deal, and his departure left the Giants with fewer matchup choices from the left side as the season moved on.
Millers early work with Boston suggested the Red Sox had gotten a steady arm, even if his season later turned uneven down the stretch and into the playoffs. For the Giants, the bigger issue is less about what Mayer might become and more about the roster balance they gave up in the moment, since left-handed relief depth is one of those things a club tends to miss only after it is gone. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Just Got Pulled Into A New Infield Trade Market Twist
The Giants are already being linked to the kind of offseason move that can reshape a roster quickly, with ESPNs Jeff Passan reporting that San Francisco is exploring trade options involving infielder Casey Schmitt as it looks to add pitching help. Nothing has been finalized, but the idea fits the clubs broader winter plan, which is expected to center on finding arms either through trades or free agency.
Kansas Citys recent Maikel Garcia trade has only added another layer to the infield market, raising the possibility that more teams could jump in before the December lockout changes the pace of business. For the Giants, the question is whether Schmitt becomes part of that next wave of talks, and how aggressively the front office is willing to move to address a staff that still needs reinforcements. [Read more 🡒]
