The Giants’ outfield picture for 2027 is getting crowded fast, and that makes Grant McCray look more like a trade chip than a long-term answer.
Drew Gilbert has already earned an extended look. Jonah Cox has entered the center-field mix.
Bo Davidson is in the conversation after a strong minor league season. Jung Hoo Lee is still there, and Harrison Bader’s expected return adds yet another name to the pile.
For Buster Posey, the job now is figuring out which players actually bring something unique.
McCray does have a calling card: speed. He stole eight bases and wasn’t caught, and Statcast put his sprint speed in the 95th percentile. That kind of athleticism can help in pinch-running situations and as outfield depth.
But the bat remains the real issue. In 2026, McCray hit .143/.250/.273 with two home runs in 91 MLB plate appearances, and he struck out in 30.8% of them. It’s a tiny sample, but it’s still enough to explain why the Giants should be careful about penciling him in for regular starts.
Gilbert, by comparison, gave San Francisco a much better offensive read, hitting .238/.330/.394 with 11 home runs in 393 plate appearances. He simply has more on-record work for the Giants to sort through next spring.
McCray’s defense doesn’t make the decision easier. Statcast had him at minus-3 Outs Above Average across the outfield in 2026. Those reps were limited, so it’s not a final verdict, but it also doesn’t scream hidden defensive edge strong enough to override what he did at the plate.
Then there’s the roster squeeze itself. McCray turns 26 in December, is still pre-arbitration, and gives the Giants some minor-league flexibility.
Keeping him at Triple-A would not cost much. But the front office also has injured players to fit back onto the 40-man roster, prospects to protect, and outside additions to consider.
Every spot matters more than usual.
McCray’s season at Sacramento at least hinted at something better. He hit .233/.352/.356 there, which showed some ability to get on base, even if it never turned into a forceful case for a promotion. His year was also interrupted by hamate surgery, something the Giants should factor in without turning it into a catch-all explanation for everything.
That leaves the organization with a choice: keep evaluating him, or move him while he still has some appeal. A trade built around a lower-level pitching prospect would make sense, if another club believes it can give McCray a cleaner path to playing time.
If the market doesn’t cooperate, there’s no harm in keeping him around Sacramento as injury insurance for an unsettled outfield. But the direction is clear. McCray should be available this winter, because San Francisco’s next version of the roster seems likely to need a different mix.
In Other News...
Giants Fans Already Have A Krukow Successor Debate Brewing
Mike Krukows impending retirement after the 2026 season has already put Giants fans into speculation mode, because filling that chair will not be a simple handoff. Krukow has been one of the defining voices of the franchise, and now the conversation has turned to who might fit the job when the Giants eventually have to replace him.
J.T. Snow has already said he has interest in the role, and he is far from the only name floating around. Hunter Pence, Javier Lopez, Shawn Estes, Rich Aurilia, George Kontos, Sergio Romo, Jeremy Affeldt and Dusty Baker are all among the possible candidates, and the Giants are expected to look at multiple options before making a decision. For now, it is less about a single frontrunner than a familiar question around this team: who can step into a role that means so much to the fan base? [Read more 🡒]
Buster Posey May Revisit A Giants Path Fans Know Well
Buster Posey spent the 2026 season focused on shaping the Giants future, even as the roster swelled to a record number of players and the club ultimately finished fourth in the NL West. The front office still found a way to add to the next wave, using the MLB Draft to bring in pitching prospects, but the bigger work this offseason could come in the form of familiar names.
Several former Giants are now free agents, and that opens the door to a path fans know well: revisiting players who already have history in San Francisco. Kevin Gausman, Luis Arraez, Robbie Ray and Michael Conforto are among the possible additions the Giants could weigh as Posey looks to keep improving a roster that still needs more certainty, even after an active year of turnover and prospect accumulation. [Read more 🡒]
Christian Koss Is Caught In The Giants' Roster Squeeze
Christian Koss spent much of the season as one of the Giants more visible fill-ins, appearing in 70 games and taking advantage of the injuries that opened a path to regular at-bats. But the chance came with limited offensive impact, and his season line left him as one of the players whose grip on a roster spot never really strengthened.
Now he is part of the squeeze that always arrives when the offseason starts sorting out a crowded roster. The Giants have more players than places, and Koss is among the names waiting to see how the club reshapes the group before next season, with his future still very much tied to what comes next. [Read more 🡒]