The San Francisco Giants are reportedly willing to hear trade offers for Casey Schmitt as they hunt for controllable starting pitching, but moving him would be a dangerous play. Schmitt’s value is sky-high after the best offensive season of his career, and the Giants would be giving up a player they control for three more years who can help them in a few different places.
That versatility matters. Schmitt is projected to open the season as the Giants’ second baseman, but he can also handle third base and shortstop at a high level, and he can hold his own in left field. At the plate, he hit .271 with 21 home runs, and that total might have climbed past 30 if his season hadn’t been cut short by injury.
Those numbers would absolutely draw interest from other clubs and could bring San Francisco the kind of pitcher it wants. Still, the Giants would be taking a real risk if Schmitt isn’t on the roster in 2027.
If the goal is to move a position player, the better name to shop is Jung Hoo Lee.
Lee remains popular with fans in San Francisco, but the fit is getting harder to ignore. He hit .276, which is respectable, yet his value is limited by shaky outfield defense and an offense that leans too heavily on batting average. Since arriving from Korea, he has a -11 DRS for the Giants while playing two different outfield spots, and he also strikes out too much and doesn’t walk enough for someone with his profile.
The Giants already moved on from one defensive liability in Heliot Ramos. Lee should be the next one out the door. When he’s rolling, he can be a useful bat around the stars in the lineup, but he’s cold too often for a team that needs steadier production.
Trading Lee would also clear the way for the organization’s younger outfield options to get more regular run. Victor Bericoto, Scott Bandura, and Bo Davidson all showed flashes in limited big-league chances, and with Lee gone, that group could compete for roles and potentially stabilize the outfield for years.
The problem is making a deal happen. Lee still has three years and about $64 million left on the contract he signed out of Korea in 2023, so San Francisco would likely have to cover a big chunk of the money or include cash to move him. Even then, there may not be many teams willing to take it on.
There’s also the issue of value. Reports say Lee doesn’t have much trade value, if any, which means the Giants might not get a meaningful return beyond relief from the contract itself. Buster Posey wants to keep building the farm, but that could make a Lee trade harder if the return doesn’t help enough.
Schmitt may bring back more in a deal, but he also gives the Giants more on the field. If San Francisco is going to swing a trade, the push should be for Jung Hoo Lee.
In Other News...
Former Dodgers Infielder Is Suddenly On The Giants Radar In A New Role
Erick Mejias path back into the majors has taken a sharp turn, and it has put him on the Giants radar in a way few would have expected. The former Dodgers and Royals infielder converted to pitching full-time after the 2024 season, then landed a minor league deal with San Francisco without a spring training invitation. Since then, he has made enough of an impression in Triple-A and at other minor league stops to at least make the transition look more than like a novelty.
Mejia is now pitching in the Dominican Winter League, where the Giants can keep evaluating whether this late-career switch has real staying power. For a club that is always looking for useful arms and creative roster value, the appeal is obvious, even if the next step remains unwritten. If the conversion keeps trending the right way, there is at least a path back to MLB, this time on the mound instead of in the infield. [Read more 🡒]
Former Giants Prospects Are A Harsh Reminder Of How Fast Depth Fades
Luis Matos move to Milwaukee was the latest reminder of how quickly a once-promising Giants depth chart can thin out. After being cut loose by San Francisco, Matos was claimed off waivers by the Brewers and later elected free agency, a path that has become familiar for players trying to keep their careers moving while searching for a clearer opportunity.
Ismael Munguia has also landed elsewhere, signing a minor league deal with the Diamondbacks after bouncing through multiple organizations, while Ryan Murphy is now in the Athletics system on a minor league contract and has been assigned to Triple-A. For the Giants, it is the sort of turnover that underscores how fragile organizational depth can be, especially when former prospects keep resurfacing in other uniforms instead of in the mix back in San Francisco. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Spring Surprise Quickly Became A Roster Reality Check
Jared Olivas spring with the Giants looked like the kind of under-the-radar success story every club hopes to uncover in March. He played his way onto the Opening Day roster after an impressive camp, giving San Francisco a speed option and a fresh outfield look, but the regular season quickly turned into a tougher test. In seven games, he never found much traction before landing on the injured list.
What followed was a fast-moving tour around the league that underscored how fragile a roster spot can be for a player in his position. After a rehab assignment in Triple-A, Oliva was designated for assignment by the Giants, claimed by the Mets, then released and signed to a minor league deal by the Rays. He is now a free agent, and his ability to steal bases could still make him appealing to clubs looking for a low-cost speed piece. [Read more 🡒]
