The Giants’ rotation picture has been rattled hard by a wave of elbow injuries, but Anthony Molina has given them something to work with.
Trevor McDonald, Carson Whisenhunt and Blade Tidwell have all gone down in recent months with elbow injuries that required reconstructive surgery. Tidwell is the latest to be recommended for surgery. Earlier in the season, Hayden Birdsong also had Tommy John surgery, and there is a good chance he can return at some point next year.
The outlook is murkier for the other three. Whisenhunt and Tidwell were injured late in the year, and with recovery times ranging from 12 to 18 months, the best-case scenario is that they could begin rehab assignments at the end of next season.
More likely, McDonald, Whisenhunt and Tidwell won’t be ready until the spring of 2028. Before those injuries hit, they accounted for a big chunk of the Giants’ rotation depth.
The club probably didn’t want any of them making more than 20 starts, but it was counting on them to help cover innings.
Now the Giants have to rebuild that depth, and Molina has emerged as a possible part of the answer.
Molina came to San Francisco in the deal that sent Tyler Mahle to the Atlanta Braves. At the time, it looked like the Giants were mainly trying to move the rest of Mahle’s contract. That trade has played out in a surprising way, though, because Mahle has been excellent since the move.
Molina, meanwhile, spent most of the season in Triple-A with the Braves before getting his chance. His fastball has shown better shape, and the gains are real on the radar gun too.
In 2025, his four-seamer averaged 94.9 MPH and just under 15 inches of induced vertical break. This year, it has jumped to 96.5 MPH and over 17 inches of induced vertical break.
That extra velocity matters, but the movement is what really changes the look of the pitch. If Molina can keep it at the top of the strike zone, it should be a difficult fastball to square up.
The early results have backed that up. In 29 innings with San Francisco, Molina has a 3.72 ERA with 29 strikeouts and six walks, enough to earn a real look when spring arrives.
In Other News...
Giants Just Lost A Promising Rotation Option At The Worst Time
Blade Tidwells progress as a starting pitcher had given the Giants a possible rotation answer to keep in mind for the next couple of seasons, which is why the latest update lands so hard. The team has recommended surgery after he was diagnosed with a moderate to severe right UCL sprain, a development that points toward Tommy John surgery and a long rehab ahead.
The timeline alone changes the conversation around his place in the organization, since the recovery window runs 12 to 18 months and wipes out any realistic shot at being part of San Franciscos rotation plans in 2027. For a pitcher who was building momentum in that role, the setback is more than just a medical note, it is another reminder of how quickly rotation depth can disappear. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Are Headed For Painful Offseason Roster Decisions
The Giants have spent most of this season juggling injuries, but the broader problem is coming into focus now: they have 16 players on the 60-day injured list, a historically high total that will follow them into the offseason roster math. Once the 2026 season ends, those players will count against the 40-man limit, turning what has already been a messy year into a far tighter winter.
San Francisco also has 55 players under control for just 40 roster spots, which means the front office is headed for some uncomfortable choices. Some injured players will need to be kept, others may not fit, and the same goes for players already hanging on the edge of the roster. The result is the kind of offseason squeeze that can force a team to part with talent before it is ready to do so. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Rotation Problem Is Bigger Than One Cheap Offseason Fix
The Giants pitching picture has gotten a lot murkier than they probably expected when the season started, and it is no longer just a matter of patching one hole. Four young starters have gone down with Tommy John surgery, leaving the club staring at two open spots in next years rotation and a deeper organizational question about how much of the workload it can reasonably expect from its own arms.
That is why the offseason conversation already feels pointed toward affordable help, even if the names are familiar. Michael Lorenzen, Chris Bassitt, Zac Gallen, David Peterson and Tyler Mahle all fit as potential veteran additions on the right kind of deal, while the Giants could also look inward and give younger pitchers a chance to compete. However it plays out, the sense is that San Francisco will need at least one inexpensive starter, and probably more than that, before the rotation can feel stable again. [Read more 🡒]