Giants Suddenly Have A New Rotation Decision After Tyler Mahle Trade

Can Anthony Molina, acquired in a previously undervalued trade, become a key figure in the SF Giants' pitching rotation after a string of promising performances?

When the Giants sent Tyler Mahle to Atlanta at the deadline, the return didn’t jump off the page. Anthony Molina was a 24-year-old right-hander with a thin major-league résumé and ugly numbers attached to it, the kind of piece that looked more like a flyer than a difference-maker.

Three and a half months later, that view looks a lot less certain.

Molina arrived in the deal on August 2 after spending most of his season in the minors. Before landing with San Francisco, he had logged 52 big-league games entering 2026, including 35 with the Rockies in 2024, when he posted a 6.79 ERA, and 17 more the next year, when that ERA climbed to 7.27.

The Braves claimed him from Colorado in December 2025 and quickly outrighted him to Triple-A. He did make a few spring training appearances for Atlanta, then pitched a couple of innings for Venezuela in the World Baseball Classic, but most of his year was spent trying to work his way back into view.

Atlanta did bring him up three times, though it barely used him. Molina appeared in just three games for the Braves and finished with a 5.40 ERA across five innings. His Triple-A work was far more encouraging: 18 games, nine starts, a 3.64 ERA and one save.

That version of Molina is the one the Giants have seen more of since the trade.

He opened his Giants stint with three starts for Sacramento, where he posted a 3.00 ERA over nine innings before getting the call on August 24. The way that debut unfolded was unusual even by baseball standards.

Molina, who was reportedly making coffee, was suddenly summoned to replace Adrian Houser after Houser left early with an injury. Molina responded by throwing 52 pitches, blanking the Reds for 4 1/3 innings, allowing one hit and earning the win.

The next start came against his former Braves teammates on August 31, and he picked up another victory after giving up three runs in five innings. In his third Giants start, he allowed only one hit and struck out six Mets hitters. He did surrender two runs, but neither was earned.

The roughest night of his Giants run came against the Padres on September 11, when San Diego piled up nine hits and seven runs against him. That outing accounted for more than half of the 12 earned runs he allowed with San Francisco. Outside of that game, Molina gave up just five earned runs over 26 innings, good for a 1.73 ERA.

For a pitcher who spent much of his major-league career in relief, the Giants also learned he could handle a starter’s workload. Molina had made only two starts combined in 2024 and 2025 before joining San Francisco, but he started five games for the Giants and went at least three innings in all six of his outings.

He reached five innings four times and worked into the sixth once, in his final start of the season against the Twins. That was his only quality start of the year, and he still took the loss.

The trade is still too fresh to hand out a winner. Mahle gave Atlanta valuable postseason innings. The Giants, meanwhile, got a young pitcher who looks capable of helping at the major-league level next season.

He could fit as a bulk innings arm or in long relief. The Giants could also send him back to Sacramento if they want, since Molina still has one option left.

In Other News...

Giants Just Sent A Clear Message About Which Young Arms Matter

The Giants made their priorities clear this week by protecting three young pitchers from the Rule 5 draft, adding Henry Lalane, Marty Gair and Josh Bostick to the 40-man roster. It was a move that spoke as much about the organizations pitching pipeline as it did about the immediate roster picture, with Lalane standing out as the most advanced of the group and expected to begin next season in Double-A.

Gair and Bostick are further behind but still viewed as arms with future major-league possibilities, even if each comes with some developmental questions. To create the room, San Francisco designated Christian Koss and Rowan Wick for assignment, a reminder that the 40-man crunch often forces tough choices when a club decides which young players are worth protecting now and which ones can be exposed to the market. [Read more 🡒]

Giants May Have Created A Bullpen Problem They Did Not Expect

The Giants trade of Erik Miller for infielder Marcelo Mayer was always going to be judged through the lens of the prospect return, but it also quietly changed the shape of the bullpen. Miller had been a useful left-handed option in San Francisco, posting a 2.76 ERA in 38 appearances before the deal, and his departure left the Giants with fewer matchup choices from the left side as the season moved on.

Millers early work with Boston suggested the Red Sox had gotten a steady arm, even if his season later turned uneven down the stretch and into the playoffs. For the Giants, the bigger issue is less about what Mayer might become and more about the roster balance they gave up in the moment, since left-handed relief depth is one of those things a club tends to miss only after it is gone. [Read more 🡒]

Royals Just Got Pulled Into A New Infield Trade Market Twist

The Giants are already being linked to the kind of offseason move that can reshape a roster quickly, with ESPNs Jeff Passan reporting that San Francisco is exploring trade options involving infielder Casey Schmitt as it looks to add pitching help. Nothing has been finalized, but the idea fits the clubs broader winter plan, which is expected to center on finding arms either through trades or free agency.

Kansas Citys recent Maikel Garcia trade has only added another layer to the infield market, raising the possibility that more teams could jump in before the December lockout changes the pace of business. For the Giants, the question is whether Schmitt becomes part of that next wave of talks, and how aggressively the front office is willing to move to address a staff that still needs reinforcements. [Read more 🡒]