Giants Suddenly Face A Franchise Reset Question Fans Dread

With another postseason out of reach, the Giants may shake things up by trading their star pitcher Logan Webb, potentially reconfiguring their future roster dynamics.

The San Francisco Giants are staring at a winter that could reshape the whole roster, and one of the biggest questions involves a familiar name at the top of the rotation.

After missing the postseason for a fifth straight season, the Giants have real decisions ahead for president of baseball operations Buster Posey. The first one is whether Tony Vitello stays on as manager. After that, the front office may need to take a hard look at the roster and consider moving some of the team’s most recognizable players.

That’s where Logan Webb comes in.

FanSided’s Christopher Kline floated the right-hander as a possible trade candidate, arguing that San Francisco may need to make a more dramatic change than simply tinkering around the edges. Webb has been the ace of the Giants’ staff for years, and even with a down season, he remains one of the most valuable arms in the game.

“While Webb is still incredibly valuable, even in a down year with his inflated 4.21 ERA, the Giants need to induce radical change. [Rafael] Devers, [Willy] Adames and [Matt] Chapman - their other big-ticket stars - are all sunk costs who will be hard, if not impossible, to move off of,” Kline wrote.

He also pointed to Webb’s contract situation as a reason contenders would come calling.

“Webb is approaching the penultimate year of his contract, and contenders would line up around the block to acquire such a stabilizing force,” he added. “A Webb trade would infuse the Giants' needy farm system with several high-end prospects.”

Webb’s deal is far more manageable than the contracts of Devers and Adames. He’s set to make $18 million per season over the next two years before reaching free agency in 2029.

At 29, Webb would almost certainly draw interest if San Francisco seriously explored a deal. He’s the kind of starter teams covet: a pitcher who regularly logs 30 or more starts and delivers All-Star-caliber production year after year.

In Other News...

Giants Fans Have One More Reason To Celebrate Mike Krukow

As Giants fans process Mike Krukows announcement that 2026 will be his final season in the booth, there is a new tribute arriving in his honor. Fieldwork Brewing Company is rolling out a West Coast IPA called Grab Some Pine, Meat, a nod that fits the longtime broadcasters unmistakable style and the place he has held in San Francisco baseball for more than three decades.

The beer is tied to a good cause, too, with proceeds going to the Northern Nevada Childrens Cancer Foundation. Fieldworks co-founder also made a substantial donation to the foundation, and it was matched to double the impact, giving the tribute a charitable edge as Krukows farewell year begins to take shape. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Keep Sending A Frustrating Message With Homegrown Rookie Catcher

The Giants catching picture has taken on a strange shape this season, and it has kept circling back to the same question of opportunity. After moving on from Patrick Bailey, San Francisco has leaned on a mix of rookie options behind the plate, including Stockton native Zach Morgan, who has been called up twice and spent time on the roster during September call-ups.

Andrew Knizner has continued to get playing time even with a low batting average, while Morgan has yet to appear in a game. For a club trying to sort out its catching depth, the message has been hard to miss: the looks are not coming evenly, and the homegrown rookie is still waiting for his turn. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Are Finally Getting Clarity On Which Young Pieces Matter

Since the trade deadline, the Giants have been using the stretch run to sort out what their 2027 roster might actually look like, and a small group of young players has started to separate itself from the rest. Christian Koss, Dylan Smith, Turner Hill, Jonah Cox and Drew Gilbert have all flashed enough to make the club think twice about where they fit, with possible lanes ranging from utility work in the infield to bullpen innings and platoon help in the outfield.

None of that means the picture is settled, of course, but it does give San Francisco something it has needed: a little clarity on which younger pieces are worth carrying forward. The next few weeks will still matter for each of them, and the Giants decisions could shift as they keep evaluating, but the organization is no longer guessing quite as much about who belongs in the long-term conversation. [Read more 🡒]