Giants Suddenly Face A Familiar Joey Bart Decision Again

The SF Giants face a crucial decision as they weigh the potential drawbacks of reuniting with Joey Bart following his release by the White Sox amidst their search for more catcher depth.

The Giants have a catcher problem to sort through, but Joey Bart probably shouldn’t be the answer.

Bart was designated for assignment by the Chicago White Sox on Tuesday, according to Robert Murray of FanSided, as clubs across MLB continue trimming rosters ahead of the deadline to tender contracts to arbitration-eligible players. Teams are also making room for Rule 5 protection decisions and upcoming free-agent moves, and Bart suddenly landed back on the market.

On paper, he fits a need. The Giants’ current catcher group is young, with Daniel Susac, Drew Cavanaugh and Jesus Rodriguez in the mix, and adding a veteran to that room makes sense.

But Bart comes with a price tag that makes the fit a lot less clean. He’s in his final season of arbitration eligibility, and MLB Trade Rumors projects him to make about $2.9 million.

For a catcher who still hasn’t locked down a starting job, that’s a steep number.

Bart’s 2026 season was split between three teams - the Pittsburgh Pirates, Atlanta Braves and Chicago White Sox - and the production was modest: .214/.305/.357 with four home runs and 13 runs batted in. His 2024 and 2025 seasons with the Pirates were better, but the larger story has stayed the same. He has not been able to carve out a regular role anywhere.

That’s what makes the Giants’ possible interest so complicated. Bart was once viewed as the heir apparent to Buster Posey behind the plate, which would make a reunion feel pretty ironic now that Posey is in a position to decide whether to bring him back after the organization moved on from him. The Giants were confident Patrick Bailey was the future at catcher when they gave up on Bart, and that belief eventually changed as Posey moved to trade Bailey.

The bigger point is that San Francisco does need help at catcher, but it doesn’t have to come from Bart. The Giants should be open to bringing in veteran catchers, just not necessarily one who would cost close to $3 million and require a 40-man roster spot. There are cheaper options available, including minor league deals, and the source material suggests those choices could be just as good, if not better.

Claiming Bart would also create another decision for a front office already facing one. Posey recently claimed Camilo Doval at the end of the season, and now the Giants are weighing whether to non-tender him. Adding Bart would only pile on another tough call.

It would be a notable move, sure. But with less expensive alternatives out there, the Giants have little reason to take another swing on Bart.

In Other News...

Giants Face One Risky Rotation Decision They Cannot Get Wrong

The Giants are already looking ahead to how their rotation might take shape in 2027, and the early outline suggests there will be at least one new arm joining Logan Webb and Landen Roupp. Adrian Houser is expected to be part of that mix, which gives San Francisco a starting point as it weighs how to build the rest of the staff around a pair of pitchers it can count on.

The more delicate part of the equation is how aggressively the Giants want to chase another veteran starter. Nick Pivetta is on the radar, but his injury-shortened season last year raises questions about workload, while Nick Martinez is also under consideration as the club tries to balance contract length and financial commitment. For a front office trying to avoid a costly misstep, the next move in this rotation plan may matter as much as the first. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Just Closed The Book On A Bullpen Story Fans Knew Well

Ryan Walkers Giants run is over, and it ends with a move that says plenty about where his stock had gone. After debuting in 2023 and working his way into the closer role, he spent the last couple of seasons fighting to recapture that form, including multiple trips to Triple-A as the Giants tried to sort out the back end of their bullpen.

Now he heads to Milwaukee in a trade that brings San Francisco two minor league pitchers, Blake Holub and Gavin Perry, while giving Walker a fresh start with a new club. For the Brewers, it is a low-cost bet on a pitcher who has already shown he can handle late-inning work, and for the Giants it closes the book on a familiar bullpen storyline that had become harder to ignore. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Face A Tough Rule 5 Call On One Young Arm

The Giants are staring at one of those front-office decisions that can quietly shape a farm system for years. With the deadline approaching to protect eligible prospects from the Rule 5 draft, San Francisco has to sort through a group that includes Blake Holub, Marty Gair and Henry LaLane, weighing who needs a spot and who might be exposed to another club. The timing makes the call even trickier, because the Rule 5 draft itself is not guaranteed to happen this offseason while Collective Bargaining Agreement talks continue.

If no new agreement is reached by December 1, a lockout could follow and leave the draft format in limbo, though the minor league phase is still expected to move ahead as scheduled. For the Giants, the uncertainty only adds another layer to an already delicate evaluation of young arms, especially when recent performance and outside interest can make a prospect more or less vulnerable than the raw talent alone suggests. [Read more 🡒]