The Giants head toward 2027 with no settled answer behind the plate, and right now the picture points to Daniel Susac and Drew Cavanaugh as the most likely catchers if the season opened today. Even so, this is not a position with a firm grip on it. The competition is still wide open, and the club appears likely to keep adding names to the mix.
Jesús Rodríguez is part of that conversation too, though his defense remains a work in progress. He has bounced around a few defensive spots without finding a permanent home, but the Giants are so thin at catcher that he stays in the picture.
What helps Rodríguez is the bat. The organization likes his contact ability, and that gives him a real path to a role as a utility hitter who can move around the diamond, catcher included.
Andrew Knizner also enters the offseason as an arbitration-eligible option, but his hold on a roster spot is far from secure with the crunch coming. A non-tender would not necessarily close the door completely; the Giants could cut him loose and still try to bring him back on a non-guaranteed deal.
Susac and Cavanaugh stand as the current front-runners, though San Francisco almost certainly will look for more depth, even if it comes in the form of a veteran on a minor league contract. The job is not locked down, and the club may wind up sorting through this well into next season.
Susac’s 2026 campaign opened with a bang. His debut could hardly have gone much better: three hits in three at-bats in a 7-2 win over the New York Mets.
For a few weeks after that, the hits kept coming. Then came the injured list, and he was never quite the same after that.
For the year, Susac hit .243/.289/.375 with three home runs, 22 RBI, and 11 runs in 161 plate appearances. The offense faded as the season wore on, but he still brought the stronger glove of the two. Behind the plate, he posted 6 Defensive Runs Saved and 8 Fielding Run Value.
Cavanaugh was one of the year’s more unexpected developments. As the big-league catching depth struggled, he earned a promotion by tearing through the upper minors.
Once he got to San Francisco, the production was more modest. The left-handed hitter finished at .229/.315/.292 with one home run, 12 RBI, and nine runs in 166 plate appearances.
He showed some power in the minors, but that didn’t fully carry over in his rookie season. Cavanaugh ended up with just six extra-base hits in a Giants uniform.
What he did bring was plate discipline, giving the lineup one of its better eyes in a season when that skill was in short supply. That came with a 30.1 percent strikeout rate.
Defensively, Cavanaugh did not match Susac. His numbers sat at -3 DRS and -1 FRV, which points to a slightly below-average defender.
So for now, Susac looks like the favorite, but there still isn’t a clean answer about whether either catcher truly solves the position in 2027. Susac has the edge with the glove.
Cavanaugh offered the better at-bat quality. Spring training will sort out the first round of that battle, though it may not end there.
The Giants’ catching situation still looks like one that could keep unfolding once the season begins.
In Other News...
Giants May Finally Close The Book On A Bullpen Move That Flopped
JT Brubakers time in San Francisco looks set to end the way a lot of bullpen experiments do, quietly and without much celebration. The Giants took a shot by tendering him a $1.8 million contract after he had made only limited appearances in 2025, then used him mostly as a bulk innings reliever in low-leverage spots in 2026, where he logged 60 and 1/3 innings over 41 games with a 3.58 ERA.
Now the veteran right-hander is headed into the offseason as an unrestricted free agent, and the expectation is that the Giants will not bring him back. For a club that has spent plenty of time searching for reliable relief depth, moving on would close the book on a move that never quite became more than an innings-eating stopgap. [Read more 🡒]
Blake Snell Just Gave Giants Fans Another Reason To Laugh
The Brewers 3-0 surge over the Dodgers on Wednesday night offered Giants fans a familiar kind of satisfaction, especially with Blake Snell in the middle of it. Snell, whose comments about adversity were already part of the pregame backdrop, saw the game turn on him in the seventh inning when he gave up two home runs and helped send Los Angeles deeper into trouble.
For a pitcher who has had a rougher run in recent postseason appearances, the outing only added to the noise around him. His postseason ERA now sits at 4.66, a number that fits the larger story of October frustration and gives Giants fans another reason to enjoy the Dodgers latest stumble. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Rotation Gamble With Robbie Ray Looks Worse Than Expected
San Diegos attempt to patch its rotation at the trade deadline never really settled things down, and Robbie Ray became part of that story almost immediately. The Padres brought in Ray and Casey Mize on Aug. 3 hoping to stabilize the starting staff for the stretch run, but Mize never made the postseason roster and Rays results never matched the kind of impact they were after.
For Giants fans, the familiar part is the contrast. Ray is now a free agent after putting up a 5.02 ERA in nine starts for San Diego, a sharp step back from what he gave San Francisco before the deal. Given how uneven the fit was after the trade, the Padres appear unlikely to bring him back, leaving the move looking more like a deadline gamble that didnt pay off. [Read more 🡒]