Giants Rotation Picture Just Got Tougher With Trevor McDonald Off Track

As the San Francisco Giants face a challenging season ahead without key prospect Trevor McDonald, they assess the impact of his stalled rise following a critical elbow surgery.

The Giants’ search for starting pitching got a lot harder with Trevor McDonald headed for a long recovery. The 25-year-old right-hander had Tommy John surgery on August 5, and the expectation is that he won’t be back until late 2027 or 2028. He was one of four young Giants starters to go under the knife, joining Blade Tidwell, Hayden Birdsong and Carson Whisenhunt.

McDonald’s season never settled into one clean arc. It opened with enough promise to keep him in the conversation for a rotation spot next year, especially considering he had entered the season with just 18 major-league innings on his ledger - three in 2024 and 15 in September 2025. But the path from spring training to surgery was uneven almost from the start.

He put together a strong first impression in Cactus League play, posting a 1.80 ERA over his first four appearances and covering 10 innings. Then the wheels came off late in camp, when he allowed seven earned runs in 1 2/3 innings over his final two outings. That led to an option to Sacramento on March 23.

The first real jolt of the season came on May 4, when McDonald was summoned for a spot start and delivered one of his best outings of the year. Against the Padres, he worked seven innings of one-run ball, struck out eight, didn’t issue a walk and needed only 81 pitches to do it. He got the win, then was sent back down the next day to clear room for reliever Joel Peguero.

Less than a week later, he was back in the rotation because Logan Webb was out with right knee bursitis. McDonald handled the Dodgers and A’s well enough in his first two starts back that his ERA sat at 2.37.

But the trouble arrived quickly after that. The White Sox lit him up for seven earned runs on May 22, and that outing kicked off a rough stretch.

June was particularly bumpy. McDonald went 0-4 with a 5.73 ERA in five starts, and two problems kept showing up: he couldn’t consistently work deep into games, and the strike zone kept slipping away from him.

He failed to get through the third inning twice that month and never reached the fifth. In four of his five June outings, he walked three batters.

July brought the full range of what he could be. He opened the month with one of his sharpest performances, a six-inning one-hitter against the Diamondbacks in which he struck out five and walked none.

Then came a brutal second start of the month against the Blue Jays, when Toronto pounded out 11 hits and eight runs and knocked him out before he could finish the second inning. Five days later, he steadied himself again, allowing three hits and one run over seven innings against the Rockies.

His final start came against the Royals, and it turned out to be his last of the year. McDonald threw four innings and gave up three runs.

While warming up for the fifth, he felt discomfort in his elbow. The Giants put him on the injured list the next day, and after further evaluation and a second opinion, he had Tommy John surgery on August 5.

On paper, his year finished at 3-7 with a 5.12 ERA in 14 starts. But the numbers tell a more layered story.

If you remove the May 22 disaster against the White Sox and the July 7 blowup against the Blue Jays, his ERA drops to 3.50 across his other 12 starts. His 4.30 FIP also points to a better season than the ERA suggests, though not one that made him look like a finished product.

The splits were lopsided, too. Left-handed hitters gave him the most trouble, batting .288 with an .846 OPS and accounting for six of the seven home runs he allowed. Right-handers were far quieter, hitting .212 with a .558 OPS.

McDonald was reinstated from the 60-day injured list to the 40-man roster on November 2 as part of roster housekeeping. The timeline still points to a 2028 return, though a late-2027 comeback remains possible.

In Other News...

Buster Posey May Have Just Narrowed The Giants Pitching Market

Buster Poseys latest comments offered a pretty clear hint about how the Giants want to shop this winter. San Francisco appears reluctant to chase players attached to qualifying offers because of the draft-pick cost, a stance that lines up with the organizations emphasis on protecting its amateur pipeline and continuing to build the farm system. It also suggests the front office is trying to be disciplined about where it spends, especially as it looks to reinforce a bullpen that needs help.

For a market that already figures to be competitive, that kind of restraint matters. It narrows the pool of realistic targets and pushes the Giants toward relievers and pitchers who are not tied to those penalties, which could shape the clubs conversations in the coming weeks. Names such as Trevor Rogers, David Bednar and Adrin Morejn are part of the broader discussion, but Poseys comments make it clear the Giants may be drawing a line before the bidding even really starts. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Face A Casey Schmitt Decision That Could Reshape Second Base

Casey Schmitt enters spring training as the projected answer at second base, a notable shift for a Giants club that moved on from Luis Arraez and is still sorting out the infield picture. Schmitts final two months were wiped out by surgery, but before the injury he showed encouraging progress in both power and strikeout rate, enough to keep him in the mix as the organization weighs how best to use him.

The decision is not as simple as handing him the job and moving on. San Francisco is still exploring veteran alternatives such as Gleyber Torres or Arraez, and there is also the possibility of shifting Schmitt to left field if the roster takes shape that way. Meanwhile, prospect Marcelo Mayer could be in line for regular at-bats in Triple-A, another layer to a situation that could end up reshaping how the Giants line up on a daily basis. [Read more 🡒]

Red Sox Are Still Reminding Giants Fans What Rafael Devers Meant

Even after Rafael Devers settled into a strong first season in San Francisco, the ripple effect of his departure still lingers in Boston. The Red Sox have now moved on by adding first baseman Jake Bauers on a four-year, $58 million deal after his breakout 2026 with Milwaukee, a season that helped fuel the Brewers World Series run and made him one of the more sought-after bats on the market.

For Giants fans, the reminder is less about what Boston is doing now and more about what Devers meant before the trade. He delivered a big 2026 of his own in orange and black, finishing with 37 home runs and 98 RBIs while drawing National League Silver Slugger Award consideration, which only reinforces how much impact the Giants gained when they landed him and how much the Red Sox had to replace once he was gone. [Read more 🡒]