Kevin Gausman’s season ended the same way his run with the Cubs began to feel: with some real value, but not enough to change the bigger picture. After the San Diego Padres handled Chicago in the Wild Card round and Gausman took the loss in Wednesday night’s deciding game, the former SF Giants right-hander is headed for free agency. And for San Francisco, a reunion suddenly looks like one of the cleanest fits on the board.
The Cubs got Gausman from Toronto at the deadline, but his time in Chicago was more steady than special. He went 4-2 with a 4.83 ERA across nine starts, while striking out 57 and walking only 11 in 50 innings. That strike-throwing stood out, especially for a Giants staff that had major trouble in that area in 2026.
There was a window where this could have been a different story. If the Giants had been in position to chase in 2026, Gausman would have made plenty of sense as a rotation upgrade for a team trying to push into October. Instead, San Francisco was clearly selling, so the reunion never had much of a chance.
Still, the fit hasn’t gone away.
Gausman spent time with the Giants, liked it enough to want back after the 2021 season, and then watched San Francisco let him leave in free agency without much of a battle. He landed in Toronto on a five-year, $110 million deal, and that contract worked out well.
From 2022 to 2025, he posted a 3.48 ERA with the Blue Jays. Even in 2026, when his ERA climbed to 4.51, he remained a dependable starter over the life of that deal.
Now he’s back on the market, though the timing is murky. It’s unclear whether he’ll sign before a likely lockout that is expected to begin on December 1 if MLB and the MLBPA do not reach a new collective bargaining agreement by then.
If and when he does sign, the Giants look like a natural destination. They need multiple rotation spots filled, and Gausman is the kind of arm that could land on a two- or three-year contract.
At 35 and coming off a down year, he shouldn’t cost top-of-the-market money, but he won’t be cheap either. A deal in the neighborhood of $15-20 million per year sounds realistic, with a two-year, $35 million agreement framed as a sensible outcome.
That would put him behind Logan Webb in the rotation, and it would reunite him with a pitcher he’s good friends with. The timing would be late, maybe five years late, but with the Giants’ rotation needing help, Gausman and San Francisco still line up almost too neatly.
In Other News...
Casey Schmitt Just Became A Real Giants Offseason Flashpoint
Casey Schmitts 2026 season gave the Giants one of their more interesting young success stories before a knee injury shut him down, but it also left the club with a real offseason decision on its hands. Buster Posey has said the team has not settled on where Schmitt will play next season, and the options on the table are wide-ranging enough to tell you how much the Giants still value his bat and athleticism.
Third base, left field and second base are all under consideration, which is why Schmitt has suddenly become more than just a lineup question. If San Francisco decides the best way to use that versatility is as a trade chip, the conversation shifts from position fit to roster-building, with pitching needing help and the Mariners among the teams that could come up as a possible partner. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Have A Big Camilo Doval Decision To Make
Camilo Doval is back in the Giants orbit after being designated for assignment by the Pittsburgh Pirates, giving San Francisco another look at a reliever who once looked like a foundational piece at the back of the bullpen. Buster Posey has already acknowledged the club will sort through where Doval fits as the team gets ready for the upcoming season, and that matters because the Giants are still trying to settle a relief group that can hold up over a full year.
Doval, for his part, has made it clear he wants to stay in San Francisco and get back to the All-Star level that made him such a difference-maker in the first place. The reunion creates an interesting decision point for the Giants, who now have to weigh past production, current bullpen needs, and how much runway to give a pitcher looking to reestablish himself in familiar colors. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Tried To Sell Progress Fans Saw A Very Different Finish
In a post-mortem press conference, Giants leadership tried to point toward the future, leaning on a younger roster and a few individual developments as signs that the season ended with something to build on. Manager Tony Vitello and Buster Posey both framed the last stretch through the lens of progress, even floating names like Csar Perdomo, Anthony Molina and Yunior Mart as potential rotation depth options for 2027, a reminder that the organization is already looking well ahead.
The problem is that the final month left a harsher impression than the rhetoric around it. San Francisco went 8-16 in September, its worst month, and the upbeat spin on the season's closing stretch landed with plenty of skepticism from fans who watched the finish firsthand. The disconnect between what the team said it saw internally and what supporters experienced outside the ballpark felt hard to ignore, even with the promise of younger talent and long-term upside still on the table. [Read more 🡒]