The Giants have a few winter puzzles to sort through, but one move could clean up a lot of the mess at once: a trade involving Matt Chapman.
Right now, San Francisco’s left field, second base and third base picture is still unsettled. In theory, the club could line things up with Casey Schmitt in left field, Marcelo Mayer at second and Chapman at third. But that arrangement only works on paper for so long, especially if the Giants want Mayer playing every day and left field upgraded in a real way.
That’s the crux of the issue. Mayer needs regular at-bats for his development, and left field clearly needs help after Giants left fielders finished dead-last this past season with a 72 wRC+ and -1.4 fWAR. So the real question becomes how the Giants can clear a path for Mayer at second while also fixing left field and keeping Schmitt in the mix.
One possible answer is a Chapman trade, even if it would be difficult to pull off.
Chapman is 33 and his production has trended down over the last few seasons. He’s also under club control through the 2030 season, which makes moving him even more complicated. Still, a deal is not impossible.
If Chapman were moved, Schmitt could settle in at third base full time, Mayer could take over at second base and get the everyday reps he hasn’t yet received in the majors, and the Giants could finally open up left field for a real upgrade.
Mayer, who is only 23, was the Boston Red Sox’s first-round pick in 2021. The Giants didn’t bring him in to sit on the bench, and the expectation is that he’ll end up as the second baseman one way or another.
That kind of reshuffling would do more than just solve a few position labels. It would also let the Giants lean harder into their younger core and create room for the next wave of prospects.
If left field opens up, the free-agent market offers names like Ian Happ, Randy Arozarena and Seiya Suzuki. On the lower end, Randal Grichuk, Taylor Ward and Ramon Laureano could work as bridge options while Bo Davidson and Dakota Jordan keep developing.
A Chapman trade would be tough to engineer, but it could clear the way for the Giants to settle the infield, upgrade left field and make room for what comes next.
In Other News...
Brian Sabean Suddenly Feels Like A Real Option For The Giants
Brian Sabeans name is suddenly back in the mix around the Giants after word surfaced that the former San Francisco general manager is not being retained by the Yankees in his special assistant role. For a franchise that has not made any public front office announcements since the 2026 season ended, the timing makes the possibility of a reunion feel more than just like nostalgia.
Sabean remains one of the most recognizable figures in modern Giants history, and the idea of him returning in an advisory capacity will naturally get attention from a fan base that knows exactly what he meant to the organization. Nothing has been confirmed publicly on the Giants side, but with the club still quiet about its offseason structure, this is the kind of familiar name that can quickly move from speculation to a real conversation. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Have A Tricky Bullpen Decision Brewing Around Joel Kuhnel
The Giants got a little clarity on their bullpen picture when the Super Two arbitration cutoff landed at 2.133 years of service time, a line that helped Randy Rodrguez and Jos Butto while leaving Joel Kuhnel just on the outside. For a team that is always balancing pitching depth against roster flexibility, that matters, especially with Kuhnel having bounced through three organizations in 2026 before settling in with San Francisco for a late-season look.
Kuhnel did enough in nine games with the Giants to keep the conversation going, posting a 2.79 ERA and giving the club a useful arm down the stretch. Still, his broader track record and persistent control concerns leave his status unsettled heading into next season, which is exactly the kind of borderline decision that can shape a bullpen before spring training even begins. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Roster Crunch Is About To Hit Some Familiar Names
The Giants are heading into one of those late-fall roster squeezes that forces a front office to make some uncomfortable calls. With 50 players currently on the 40-man roster, including those on the 60-day injured list, San Francisco needs to clear roughly 10 spots, and that means a familiar wave of decisions is coming as the club sorts out who fits the winter plan and who does not.
A list of 10 players has already emerged as likely waiver or outright candidates, a reminder that roster churn is rarely limited to the margins when a team is trying to create room. More moves could still follow depending on free-agent additions and Rule 5 Draft protections, so the first round of cuts may not be the last sign of how aggressively the Giants want to reshape the roster. [Read more 🡒]