The Giants’ winter plans are already getting squeezed by the market, and the latest move around the league only sharpens the question: was Casey Schmitt the kind of chip San Francisco should have been willing to move for a starter like Bryce Miller?
The Royals and Mariners just completed the most notable trade of the offseason so far, a six-player deal that sent Gold Glove third baseman Maikel Garcia to Seattle and brought Miller back to Kansas City as the centerpiece of the return. That swap matters in San Francisco because Seattle had been hunting for infield help, with names like Ketel Marte and Schmitt surfacing as possible targets before the deal came together.
That’s where the Giants’ own roster puzzle comes into focus. Schmitt has been floated to other teams as the front office looks for ways to shore up a rotation that badly needs help.
In theory, the fit with Seattle made sense. In practice, though, the Mariners have now signaled there is “zero chance” they’ll move another pitcher for offense after landing Garcia.
If the Mariners had been willing to build a package around Miller and had asked for Schmitt in return, the Giants would have had a real decision to make. Schmitt doesn’t bring Garcia’s glove or his on-base profile, but he does offer more power and comes at a much cheaper price, since he has not yet reached arbitration. Garcia, meanwhile, is locked in through 2031 on a five-year, $57.5 million extension that includes a club option for 2031.
Even so, Garcia was the more appealing player for Seattle. He’s already put together a far more accomplished career than Schmitt, despite being just 26 and only now fully established after parts of five seasons in the majors.
Garcia owns 10.5 career WAR to Schmitt’s 1.8, and the gap is driven in large part by defense. Garcia has piled up 38 OAA, while Schmitt sits at -7.
Schmitt has been roughly average to slightly above average at third base, but his other looks have been less convincing. Left field, in particular, has not been a comfortable spot for him. Matt Chapman’s presence also makes Schmitt’s path on the Giants’ roster more complicated, though he can at least handle second base well enough.
From the Giants’ side, Schmitt alone probably wouldn’t have been enough to land a package on the level Kansas City received for Miller. San Francisco likely would have needed to add another piece or two.
And Miller is no throw-in: the 25-year-old looked like a breakout arm in 2024, posting a 2.94 ERA over 180.1 innings before a pair of uneven seasons followed. Kansas City is betting he can get back to that version of himself, and given how expensive pitching has become, that’s a gamble worth taking on a young starter with years of control left.
Still, Schmitt could probably fetch a controllable starter with a little less shine than Miller. The Giants may have other matches out there, too. Miami has young pitching and could use help on offense, while the Yankees have been looking for an upgrade at third base and have been a frequent trade partner recently.
And if San Francisco doesn’t find the right deal, keeping Schmitt is very much on the table. Power bats with team control are hard to find, and the Giants could always try to fix the rotation in free agency instead.
The catch is timing. With the December 1 lockout looming, the front office may not have the luxury of waiting around to see how the rest of the winter unfolds.
In Other News...
Former Dodgers Infielder Is Suddenly On The Giants Radar In A New Role
Erick Mejias path back into the majors has taken a sharp turn, and it has put him on the Giants radar in a way few would have expected. The former Dodgers and Royals infielder converted to pitching full-time after the 2024 season, then landed a minor league deal with San Francisco without a spring training invitation. Since then, he has made enough of an impression in Triple-A and at other minor league stops to at least make the transition look more than like a novelty.
Mejia is now pitching in the Dominican Winter League, where the Giants can keep evaluating whether this late-career switch has real staying power. For a club that is always looking for useful arms and creative roster value, the appeal is obvious, even if the next step remains unwritten. If the conversion keeps trending the right way, there is at least a path back to MLB, this time on the mound instead of in the infield. [Read more 🡒]
Former Giants Prospects Are A Harsh Reminder Of How Fast Depth Fades
Luis Matos move to Milwaukee was the latest reminder of how quickly a once-promising Giants depth chart can thin out. After being cut loose by San Francisco, Matos was claimed off waivers by the Brewers and later elected free agency, a path that has become familiar for players trying to keep their careers moving while searching for a clearer opportunity.
Ismael Munguia has also landed elsewhere, signing a minor league deal with the Diamondbacks after bouncing through multiple organizations, while Ryan Murphy is now in the Athletics system on a minor league contract and has been assigned to Triple-A. For the Giants, it is the sort of turnover that underscores how fragile organizational depth can be, especially when former prospects keep resurfacing in other uniforms instead of in the mix back in San Francisco. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Spring Surprise Quickly Became A Roster Reality Check
Jared Olivas spring with the Giants looked like the kind of under-the-radar success story every club hopes to uncover in March. He played his way onto the Opening Day roster after an impressive camp, giving San Francisco a speed option and a fresh outfield look, but the regular season quickly turned into a tougher test. In seven games, he never found much traction before landing on the injured list.
What followed was a fast-moving tour around the league that underscored how fragile a roster spot can be for a player in his position. After a rehab assignment in Triple-A, Oliva was designated for assignment by the Giants, claimed by the Mets, then released and signed to a minor league deal by the Rays. He is now a free agent, and his ability to steal bases could still make him appealing to clubs looking for a low-cost speed piece. [Read more 🡒]
