Giants May Have Created A Bullpen Problem They Did Not Expect

Erik Miller's departure leaves a crucial gap in the Giants' bullpen that could impact future games more than anticipated.

The Giants made a deadline move that looked sensible on paper and still ended up feeling a little jarring: Erik Miller to the Boston Red Sox for infielder Marcelo Mayer.

Given how the season had gone by that point, nobody around San Francisco should have been shocked by activity at the trade deadline. But Miller’s departure stood out because he had become one of the more useful bullpen pieces the Giants had. Teams are always hunting for relief help in July, and a left-handed arm with Miller’s track record was always going to draw interest.

Before the deal, Miller had posted a 2.76 ERA across 38 appearances for the Giants. He had also already given San Francisco one of its more memorable bullpen moments in April, when he squared off with NL Rookie of the Year Sal Stewart and the entire Cincinnati Reds bench. He had been a steady option since 2024, which helped explain why Boston was willing to part with a promising young player to get him.

The move paid off immediately for the Red Sox. For a while, it looked like they had found something in Miller, because he was sharp right away and allowed just one earned run in his first 14 appearances. The biggest difference was his command, which had been a recurring issue during his time in San Francisco.

The finish, though, was rough. Miller stumbled late in the year, then carried those problems into the playoffs. He posted a 13.50 ERA in two postseason outings, and those struggles became part of Boston’s loss to the New York Yankees in the Wild Card series.

Even with that rough ending, Miller is still the kind of reliever the Giants will miss. He may not project as a truly elite bullpen arm, but a solid late-inning lefty has real value, and those pitchers are not easy to find. Right now, San Francisco has only Sam Hentges as its lone left-handed bullpen option, which makes the need pretty obvious heading into free agency.

It will be worth watching both sides of the trade from here. Miller’s future in Boston and Mayer’s path in San Francisco will tell the real story eventually. For now, though, the Giants are left without a hard-throwing lefty who had become a dependable part of their bullpen.

In Other News...

Giants Suddenly Face A Familiar Joey Bart Decision Again

Joey Bart is back in the conversation around the Giants, only this time the question comes with a different uniform attached. The former top San Francisco catching prospect was designated for assignment by the White Sox to clear room for Dustin May, putting Bart on the market again as he enters his final season of arbitration eligibility with a projected salary of about $2.9 million.

For the Giants, the decision is not as simple as a reunion for a familiar name. They have young catchers in the system and have to weigh both roster space and payroll, which could push them toward other veteran options instead of making a claim on Bart. It is the kind of familiar front-office fork in the road that can get more complicated the closer a team gets to having to choose. [Read more 🡒]

Rafael Devers Just Gave Giants Fans Another Brutal What-If

The Silver Slugger results added another layer to a Giants season that already had plenty of regret attached to it. Matt Olson took home the National League first baseman honor, while Rafael Devers, who was nominated alongside him, came up short after a year that was interrupted by a core muscle injury, surgery and a shutdown.

For Giants fans, the sting is less about the award itself than the reminder of what might have been if Devers had stayed healthy and available all season. San Francisco finished the year without a Silver Slugger winner, and the Devers omission only sharpened the sense that the club never got the full version of a bat it was counting on. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Face A Tough Rule 5 Call On One Young Arm

The Giants are staring at one of those November roster decisions that can quietly shape the next few seasons, with a deadline approaching to protect eligible prospects from the Rule 5 draft. Blake Holub, Marty Gair and Henry LaLane are among the names in the mix, and the front office has to weigh present roster crunch against the risk of losing a young arm for nothing if another club decides to take a chance.

The complication is that the whole Rule 5 picture is a little murky this offseason because of the ongoing Collective Bargaining Agreement talks, with the possibility of a lockout if no deal is reached by Dec. 1. Even so, the minor league phase is expected to go on as scheduled, which keeps the pressure on San Francisco to sort through which prospects are worth shielding and which ones can be exposed without too much worry. [Read more 🡒]