Blade Tidwell’s season is headed toward a brutal ending, and the Giants saw this one coming.
San Francisco has recommended surgery on Tidwell’s moderate to severe right UCL sprain, according to MLB.com. The injury is the kind often tied to Tommy John surgery, though it is not yet clear how extensive the procedure will be. Doctors typically decide the exact surgical route once they get in there, but the recovery window is usually 12 to 18 months.
That timetable effectively wipes out any realistic chance that Tidwell could be part of the Giants’ rotation in 2027. It also forces San Francisco to keep reshaping its pitching plans for next season, with Tidwell’s injury just one piece of a wider problem that includes other injured pitchers too.
For the Giants, it’s a tough loss because they believed Tidwell could become a rotation piece soon.
He came into pro ball with plenty of buzz, then took the college path and pitched for current Giants manager Tony Vitello at Tennessee. Vitello’s staff trusted him enough to put him in the weekend rotation as a freshman, and Tidwell delivered a 10-3 record with a 3.73 ERA in 2021. A shoulder injury knocked him off track for the first half of 2022, but he returned and helped Tennessee in the postseason.
The arm talent was never in question. The Mets took him No. 52 overall and gave him a $1.8 million bonus, then watched him move through their system before he reached the majors in 2025. He logged only 15 innings for New York before the deadline deal sent him to San Francisco.
He was already hurt when he arrived and spent the rest of that year at Triple-A Sacramento. The Giants filled their rotation with veteran free-agent starters, which shut the door on an Opening Day opportunity. Tidwell did get called up in early April and picked up his first save.
Only after San Francisco essentially reset its season and traded Robbie Ray and Tyler Mahle did Tidwell finally get a real shot to start every fifth day.
He ended up 1-2 with a 4.45 ERA in 17 games, nine of them starts, while striking out 46 and walking 21 in 56.2 innings. The numbers trended in the right direction as the season went on.
In August, he went 0-1 with a 5.26 ERA, 21 strikeouts and 10 walks in 25.2 innings. In September, he posted a 1-1 record with a 4.26 ERA, along with 15 strikeouts and eight walks in 19 innings.
It was all lining up for Tidwell to help the Giants and maybe lock down a starting role next season. Instead, he’s staring at another long rehab and another year of waiting to show what he can become.
In Other News...
Giants Are Headed For Painful Offseason Roster Decisions
The Giants have spent most of this season juggling injuries, but the broader problem is coming into focus now: they have 16 players on the 60-day injured list, a historically high total that will follow them into the offseason roster math. Once the 2026 season ends, those players will count against the 40-man limit, turning what has already been a messy year into a far tighter winter.
San Francisco also has 55 players under control for just 40 roster spots, which means the front office is headed for some uncomfortable choices. Some injured players will need to be kept, others may not fit, and the same goes for players already hanging on the edge of the roster. The result is the kind of offseason squeeze that can force a team to part with talent before it is ready to do so. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Rotation Problem Is Bigger Than One Cheap Offseason Fix
The Giants pitching picture has gotten a lot murkier than they probably expected when the season started, and it is no longer just a matter of patching one hole. Four young starters have gone down with Tommy John surgery, leaving the club staring at two open spots in next years rotation and a deeper organizational question about how much of the workload it can reasonably expect from its own arms.
That is why the offseason conversation already feels pointed toward affordable help, even if the names are familiar. Michael Lorenzen, Chris Bassitt, Zac Gallen, David Peterson and Tyler Mahle all fit as potential veteran additions on the right kind of deal, while the Giants could also look inward and give younger pitchers a chance to compete. However it plays out, the sense is that San Francisco will need at least one inexpensive starter, and probably more than that, before the rotation can feel stable again. [Read more 🡒]
Mike Krukow Makes This Giants Dodgers Series Hit Even Harder
The last Dodgers series at Oracle Park already carries enough weight for the Giants, with three regular-season games left against a division rival that is headed to the postseason. But for longtime viewers, it has picked up another layer: this will be Mike Krukows final broadcast at home before he retires at the end of the season, closing out a Giants voice that has been part of the teams daily rhythm for years.
Krukow, a former Giants starter, spent time reflecting on the history of the rivalry and revisiting memories from his own playing days, which only sharpens the sense of occasion around these games. For San Francisco, it is not just one more shot at Los Angeles before the schedule turns over. It is also the end of an era for a broadcaster who has lived the matchup from both the mound and the booth. [Read more 🡒]