The SF Giants’ season has been a mess, but the Padres have managed to make the division picture feel a little less humiliating.
San Diego opened the year looking like a club that could actually chase down the Dodgers in the National League West. That idea didn’t last long. The Padres are 44-46 now and have dropped nine of their last 10, a slide that has knocked them into third place in the division behind the Arizona Diamondbacks, who sit at 45-45.
That still leaves the Giants in a strange spot. They are technically alive for second place in the division, though that would look a lot more realistic if they hadn’t been so thoroughly handled by Arizona this season.
What makes San Diego’s collapse stand out is how much talent is sitting in that lineup. On paper, the Padres looked built to be a problem. In reality, their stars have been just as disappointing as the Giants’ high-profile bats, if not worse.
Manny Machado has been the biggest shock. He’s hitting .190/.282/.408 with 18 home runs and 51 runs batted in, a far cry from the All-Star production San Diego has come to expect from him over the years.
Fernando Tatis Jr. has been more productive overall, but the power has vanished. He’s batting .282/.343/.382 with five home runs and 34 runs batted in, and that lack of punch has been one of the strangest parts of the Padres’ season.
Jackson Merrill and Xander Bogaerts have also taken steps backward, and the result has been an offense that has simply fallen apart.
The pitching side hasn’t offered much help, either. San Diego has been dealing with injuries to key rotation arms Yu Darvish and Joe Musgrove, and the loss of Dylan Cease in free agency has only made the staff thinner.
There’s one more wrinkle for the Giants: the Padres’ struggles make Tony Vitello’s rough debut season look a little less isolated. San Diego took a chance on rookie manager Craig Stammen, and he hasn’t had much success so far. That leaves Vitello as the only new manager in the NL West who is enduring a difficult first year.
For a Giants team that has spent years trying to move past San Diego and claim the division’s No. 2 spot, this was supposed to be the season to do it. Instead, their lack of investment in the pitching staff may have cost them that opening.
In Other News...
Giants Draft Plans Just Got Shaken Up By A Pitching Scare
The Giants entered draft season with real flexibility at No. 4 overall and a bonus pool that gives them room to be aggressive, which is why a hard-throwing high school arm like Brody Bumila had been on the radar. San Francisco has been linked to plenty of pitching possibilities, and Bumilas fastball made him the kind of upside play that can fit in a draft where the club could choose to chase ceiling or spread its money around.
Now the calculus looks different after the elbow scare that knocked Bumila off the board for the early rounds. He had been a name worth watching for the Giants, but with his stock suddenly clouded, San Francisco may have to pivot toward other arms or a different kind of prospect altogether as draft day approaches. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Bullpen Has Felt Tyler Rogers Absence More Than Expected
The Giants have felt the Tyler Rogers trade in a way that goes beyond simply losing a dependable arm from the late innings. Before he was dealt, the bullpen had settled into a 3.26 ERA, a mark that reflected how much stability Rogers brought to the group as one of the more trusted relievers on the roster. Since then, the relief corps has been more vulnerable, and the overall run prevention has slipped enough to become a real talking point around a team that has leaned on pitching to stay competitive.
Rogers has also looked right at home in Toronto, where his new deal has given the Blue Jays a long-term piece and his results have backed up the investment. For San Francisco, the harder part is not just watching a former bullpen anchor thrive elsewhere, but seeing the innings he used to cover turn into a wider problem back home. The Giants knew they were moving a valuable reliever, but the size of the gap left behind has been sharper than expected. [Read more 🡒]
Heliot Ramos Just Delivered The Kind Of Night Giants Needed
Heliot Ramos gave the Giants the kind of jolt they have been waiting for in the middle of a long season, turning his return from a right quad strain into a statement night against the Blue Jays. Back in the lineup after a rehab assignment, Ramos has wasted little time getting comfortable again, and his power has shown up immediately, with four home runs in his first eight games since coming off the injured list.
The bigger picture for San Francisco is encouraging, too, because the outfield is almost whole again and the club is starting to see what it can look like when Ramos is healthy and driving the offense. Harrison Bader remains the lone holdout while he works back from plantar fasciitis, leaving the Giants with one last health question in the grass even as Ramos keeps giving them reasons to feel better about the lineup. [Read more 🡒]