The Giants have a clear bullpen need, but the smarter move may be to look west to Pittsburgh rather than pay up for a pricey free-agent closer.
San Francisco’s offseason pitching shopping list is already crowded: a starter, a closer and a left-handed reliever. That’s why a cheaper ninth-inning option could give president of baseball operations Buster Posey more flexibility to attack the rest of the staff needs.
One proposed path would send outfielder Victor Bericoto and right-hander Dylan Smith to the Pirates in exchange for Luke Weaver and $6 million. That package is the writer’s suggested offer, not a reported deal.
Weaver, 33, put together a strong season split between the New York Mets and Pittsburgh, finishing with a 2.69 ERA, a 0.96 WHIP and 65 strikeouts against 16 walks in 60.1 innings. His ability to keep runners off base makes him a plausible candidate to move from setup work into the closer role.
The financial piece is what makes the idea stand out. Weaver is due an $11 million salary for 2027, his final season before free agency, but New York is covering $6 million of that.
Under this proposal, Pittsburgh would pass that subsidy to San Francisco, dropping the Giants’ net cost to $5 million. That would save $9 million compared with Raisel Iglesias’ projected guarantee, while still giving the Giants one season of control.
Iglesias, meanwhile, was still effective for the Atlanta Braves in 2026, posting a 2.55 ERA, 34 saves and a 1.08 WHIP across 60 innings. His track record in the ninth inning makes him an easy fit on paper, even if he turns 37 in January.
In a Nov. 9 review of the relief market, SI’s Michael McDermott cited a FanGraphs median crowd-sourced projection of one year and $14 million for Iglesias. That was a market projection, not a reported offer or asking price.
Pittsburgh has reasons to listen, though it also has reasons to say no. The Pirates need more right-handed power, and Mason Montgomery is already handling closing duties. That creates room for a deal that sends out a veteran setup arm in exchange for a bat and a bullpen piece with control.
Bericoto would give Pittsburgh a right-handed hitter with some pop. He hit .241/.267/.420 with five home runs in 41 Major League games, and while the bat has some power appeal, the on-base percentage leaves him as more of a developmental gamble than a finished product.
Smith would bring immediate relief depth, and he still has years of club control left. He posted a 3.86 ERA with 45 strikeouts and 22 walks in 39.2 innings, though his command needs work.
For San Francisco, the trade would not come without a cost. Moving Bericoto would thin the right-handed outfield mix, and dealing Smith would mean giving up inexpensive bullpen depth for a pitcher who could be gone after 2027.
There’s also the possibility that Pittsburgh simply prefers to keep Weaver. He’s affordable, and an 82-win club trying to contend may not want to part with him. Iglesias also brings a much deeper closing résumé than Weaver, who had just one save in 2026 and finished with a 4.96 ERA over his final 16⅓ innings with Pittsburgh.
Those are the kinds of hurdles that should keep the Giants from overpaying. If the Pirates want a premium prospect or insist on keeping most of the salary relief, San Francisco should go back to free agency. But at the terms laid out here, Weaver gives the Giants a younger late-inning option and leaves more money available to help fix the rotation.
In Other News...
Giants Just Sent A Clear Message About Which Young Arms Matter
The Giants made their priorities clear this week by protecting three young pitchers from the Rule 5 draft, adding Henry Lalane, Marty Gair and Josh Bostick to the 40-man roster. It was a move that spoke as much about the organizations pitching pipeline as it did about the immediate roster picture, with Lalane standing out as the most advanced of the group and expected to begin next season in Double-A.
Gair and Bostick are further behind but still viewed as arms with future major-league possibilities, even if each comes with some developmental questions. To create the room, San Francisco designated Christian Koss and Rowan Wick for assignment, a reminder that the 40-man crunch often forces tough choices when a club decides which young players are worth protecting now and which ones can be exposed to the market. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Have Created A Bullpen Problem They Did Not Expect
The Giants trade of Erik Miller for infielder Marcelo Mayer was always going to be judged through the lens of the prospect return, but it also quietly changed the shape of the bullpen. Miller had been a useful left-handed option in San Francisco, posting a 2.76 ERA in 38 appearances before the deal, and his departure left the Giants with fewer matchup choices from the left side as the season moved on.
Millers early work with Boston suggested the Red Sox had gotten a steady arm, even if his season later turned uneven down the stretch and into the playoffs. For the Giants, the bigger issue is less about what Mayer might become and more about the roster balance they gave up in the moment, since left-handed relief depth is one of those things a club tends to miss only after it is gone. [Read more 🡒]
Royals Just Got Pulled Into A New Infield Trade Market Twist
The Giants are already being linked to the kind of offseason move that can reshape a roster quickly, with ESPNs Jeff Passan reporting that San Francisco is exploring trade options involving infielder Casey Schmitt as it looks to add pitching help. Nothing has been finalized, but the idea fits the clubs broader winter plan, which is expected to center on finding arms either through trades or free agency.
Kansas Citys recent Maikel Garcia trade has only added another layer to the infield market, raising the possibility that more teams could jump in before the December lockout changes the pace of business. For the Giants, the question is whether Schmitt becomes part of that next wave of talks, and how aggressively the front office is willing to move to address a staff that still needs reinforcements. [Read more 🡒]
