The Giants have work to do this offseason, but the splashiest names on the market are probably not where they’ll end up. With qualifying offers attached to a handful of free agents, San Francisco’s path looks even narrower, because signing one of those players means surrendering draft compensation and international bonus pool money.
That’s the kind of cost the Giants can’t really afford to shrug off right now. The organization’s best hope still runs through the farm system, and with the odds of contending in 2027 not looking especially strong, giving up picks for a big-ticket free agent doesn’t make much sense. The team already lived through that kind of transaction when it signed Willy Adames a few years ago after he had received a qualifying offer from the Milwaukee Brewers.
So while the Giants may be hunting for upgrades, they should probably stay away from these six names.
David Bednar is the first obvious temptation. San Francisco needs a closer, and Bednar fits that description as well as anyone.
But he’s also likely beyond the Giants’ range. He’s one of the best closers in baseball, and the Yankees will probably keep him in some form or fashion, whether he accepts the qualifying offer or they work out a longer deal.
Brandon Lowe has also been floated as a possible fit, but the qualifying offer changes the equation. He’s a useful power bat coming off a strong season, yet the price tag attached to signing him now makes him a poor fit for a team that would have to give up draft capital on top of a multi-year commitment.
Adrian Morejon is another name that would make sense on paper. The left-hander would give the Giants a closer option, but he’s expected to command a major contract. The more likely landing spot is a contender, while San Francisco may have to look at cheaper left-handed relief options such as JoJo Romero or Steven Okert.
Randy Arozarena would bring plenty of intrigue if the Giants decide they want an outfield upgrade. His all-around skill set makes him easy to dream on. Still, there are more realistic targets for San Francisco, including Taylor Ward.
Trevor Rogers could help address the rotation, especially with Robbie Ray traded away and the need for a left-handed starter still there. Even so, his 4.03 ERA in 2026 points to a market where the Giants should be able to find more affordable answers.
Seiya Suzuki rounds out the list. Like Arozarena, he’s the kind of hitter who can light up a lineup, and his 26 home runs last season make him easy to picture in orange and black. But that kind of offensive punch will come at too high a cost for the Giants, who could also choose to lean on internal outfield options.
The Giants are going to try to improve. They just probably won’t do it by diving into the deepest, most expensive part of the free-agent pool. That might not thrill everybody, but it’s the most likely way San Francisco will operate.
In Other News...
Giants Just Exposed A Bullpen Weakness They Still Havent Solved
The Giants spent part of their roster cleanup trimming three left-handed arms from the 40-man mix, with Matt Gage and Seth Lonsway outrighted to Sacramento and Reiver Sanmartn designated for assignment. On paper, it was a routine set of moves. In practice, it underscored how thin the clubs supply of left-handed relief help has become as it looks ahead to next season.
Sam Hentges remains the most obvious answer in that lane, but the Giants are still carrying concerns about recent performance, and the rest of the left-handed depth chart is hardly reassuring. Some of the other options are young, while others are working back from surgery, which leaves the bullpen with a familiar problem: not enough dependable left-handed innings and no clear sign yet that the issue has been solved. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Pitching Woes Could Force Them Into A Market Fans Never Expected
The Giants spent the 2026 season searching for stability on the mound and never really found it, finishing 65-97 while ranking 23rd in team ERA. Their first move toward addressing the problem was modest, bringing in Tony Neubeck from the Nationals, but it hardly changes the larger picture for a staff that needs far more than a depth add to get back on track.
That is why Bob Nightengales mention of San Francisco as a possible suitor for Tarik Skubal stands out. A pitcher of that caliber would push the Giants into a market they have not often occupied, especially with Skubal expected to command a contract big enough to limit the field to only the most financially aggressive teams. For a club trying to climb out of a rough season, the question is not just whether it needs an ace, but whether it is willing to chase one at that level. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Have Found A Cheap Catching Fix With One Catch
The Giants are still looking for ways to shore up the catching depth behind Daniel Susac, and Kyle Higashioka has emerged as a possible fit. With Susac working his way back from a knee injury, San Francisco could use a veteran backup who can handle the staff without forcing the club into a bigger financial commitment, especially as it tries to preserve payroll flexibility.
Higashioka is now a free agent after the Rangers declined his 2027 mutual option, which puts him squarely in the range of the kind of short-term, modestly priced deal the Giants prefer in this spot. Any move would still hinge on his medical evaluation and the contract language, so the idea makes sense on paper even if the final details remain the real hurdle. [Read more 🡒]