Rafael Devers has gone from a deadline fantasy to an offseason talking point in New York, and this time the idea is getting pushed beyond Yankees fans and into the ESPN conversation.
A loud segment of the Yankees’ fan base, with CC Sabathia helping fan the flames, wanted the club to chase Devers at the 2026 trade deadline. The thinking then was simple: his contract was big, his production had slipped from his usual standard, and that combination made him look like the kind of player a team could maybe pry loose by taking on money instead of surrendering a pile of prospects.
Now Buster Olney and Paul Hembekides are floating a different version of the same idea. Their case is that the San Francisco Giants could look to move Devers this offseason, and that New York would be the cleanest fit if Buster Posey decides to unload that deal.
Hembekides laid out the argument this way: "[Devers] would be a great fit next to George Lombard Jr., and I'll tell you why, man. Mine is a nonstandard opinion.
I think he can fake it at third base. But when you have a superhero playing shortstop, which I believe Lombard will be, you don't need a Gold Glover playing third base for you.
And I do believe the Yankees could coach Devers up to such an extent," Hembekides said.
The third-base angle matters because it solves a real roster problem for the Yankees. They don’t have much offensive punch at the hot corner right now, especially against left-handers, where Amed Roario has disappointed. Moving Devers there would also ease the traffic jam at first base and designated hitter, where Ben Rice, Luis Garcia Jr., and maybe Giancarlo Stanton are all in the mix.
Lombard Jr. is a big part of why this idea has traction. He’s had some bumps at shortstop, but the upside is obvious.
When he first arrived, he piled up eight defensive runs saved over his first 100 big league innings. He now has nine defensive runs saved in 273 1/3 innings, miscues included.
The other major shift since deadline season is that Devers is hitting like himself again. Earlier in the year, the numbers were solid but not special, as he hit .249/.319/.479 in the first half.
Since then, he’s taken off, batting .275/.376/.611 over the second half, with 18 of his 37 home runs coming in that 52-game stretch. That’s the kind of bat a contender can justify paying for.
The money is still massive. Devers is owed $199.5 million over the next seven years, which comes out to $28.5 million annually.
But there are ways for the Yankees to soften the hit. If they move on from Stanton, they can eat just $15 million, helped by the terms of the trade with the Marlins that leave Miami covering the $10 million buyout on his 2028 option.
There’s also the timing angle, and that may be the biggest reason this idea has momentum now. The expectation is that once the lockout ends and a new CBA is in place, contracts added before the current agreement expires on Dec. 1 could be shielded from any salary cap or similar restrictions that follow.
That’s why an aggressive November deal would make sense for New York. It would let the Yankees add another prime-age slugger to build around Aaron Judge, while getting ahead of what could become a much tighter spending landscape. If they want another big bat to carry and protect the lineup, Devers is being framed as the obvious target.
In Other News...
Giants May Have Quietly Solved A Daniel Susac Roster Problem
Daniel Susacs lost 2023 season still carried an important roster consequence for the Giants, even after the left knee patella fracture ended his year. Because he spent enough time on the active roster as a Rule 5 draft pick, San Francisco cleared the service-time hurdle needed to ease the usual Rule 5 restrictions, a small bookkeeping detail with a long shelf life.
Starting in 2027, the Giants can treat Susac like any other 40-man player instead of worrying about the special Rule 5 clock attached to him. In practical terms, that gives the club far more flexibility and control over his future, with team control stretching through at least 2031, which is exactly the kind of quiet roster win front offices value even when it barely registers at the time. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Prospect Jonah Cox Is Forcing A Real Roster Debate
Jonah Cox has spent this season turning raw athleticism into a real argument for the Giants future. The rookie outfielder has already led the club in stolen bases despite limited games played, and his speed has not been the only thing catching attention. His defensive range and ability to move around the outfield have given San Francisco another layer of flexibility, while his aggressive baserunning has stood out enough that coaches have taken notice.
For a Giants roster still sorting out how best to build for next spring, Cox is no longer just a promising name in the system. He is making a case for a spot on the Opening Day roster, and it is a case built on more than one tool. Speed can be fleeting in prospect talk, but when it comes with real impact on the bases and in the field, it starts to create a tougher decision than the club probably expected. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Still Have One Outfield Problem To Solve This Winter
The Giants outfield remains one of the more unsettled parts of the roster heading into the winter, even after a season that showed some signs of improvement. San Francisco was still near the bottom of several defensive metrics in 2025, a reminder that the group has not fully recovered from last years issues, and the clubs decision to bring in Harrison Bader last offseason did not deliver the kind of stabilizing presence it was hoping for. He appeared in only 30 games, leaving the Giants with less certainty than they expected in a spot that was supposed to be strengthened.
There is at least a brighter note in center field, where contributions from Drew Gilbert and Jonah Cox helped the team move in a better direction. The problem is that the corners remain a different story, and that is where the Giants still have work to do. With possible positional shifts on the table and more attempts to upgrade likely ahead, the front office is still staring at one outfield issue that has not gone away. [Read more 🡒]