The Phillies are sticking with Don Mattingly, and that’s a call the Giants and Dodgers have seen go sideways before.
After the club moved on from Rob Thomson in April, Mattingly stepped in and immediately gave Philadelphia a jolt. The timing was brutal for San Francisco, too: his first series as interim manager came against the Giants in Philadelphia, and the Giants got swept, dropping both games of a doubleheader in heartbreaking fashion. San Francisco was 13-15 heading into that series, then slid after the loss while the Phillies caught fire under Mattingly.
That early surge made the whole thing look pretty foolish in the moment, especially for anyone still carrying old memories of Mattingly’s run with the Dodgers. He’s a respected baseball man, an outstanding former player, and someone who has been around the game for four decades. Still, as the season wore on, the same issues that haunted him in Los Angeles started to show up again.
His bullpen choices were a problem down the stretch, and a rough September nearly knocked Philadelphia out of the playoff picture before the Phillies managed to hang on for a Wild Card berth. The postseason only sharpened the scrutiny.
In Game 1 of the Wild Card series against the Atlanta Braves, Mattingly leaned on closer Jhoan Duran for three innings, and the move blew up when Austin Riley launched a go-ahead three-run homer in the eighth. Then, in Game 3, Mattingly turned to a struggling Aaron Nola, who couldn’t even get through two innings after allowing three earned runs.
Philadelphia was eliminated.
For a while, Alex Cora looked like the obvious answer in Philadelphia, but he’s decided to take 2027 off from managing. That left the Phillies with little choice but to bring Mattingly back.
There’s plenty in his favor, at least on paper. Philadelphia went 79-55 after he took over as interim manager, so this wasn’t some empty stint.
But the Dodgers already know the ceiling with Mattingly, and Giants fans remember it, too: Los Angeles never got him to a World Series, while San Francisco won three in five years during that stretch. That’s a big part of why the Dodgers eventually moved on.
Donnie Baseball has the respect of the room. That matters.
But whether he can push a loaded Phillies team all the way through remains the real question. And for the Giants and Dodgers, this is the kind of hire that looks awfully familiar for all the wrong reasons.
In Other News...
Giants Fans Are Remembering A Beloved Piece Of A Memorable Era
Todd Benzingers passing at 63 has brought back a wave of memories for Giants fans who followed the club through the early-to-mid 1990s, when he was part of a roster that helped shape that era. The former first baseman spent three seasons in San Francisco from 1993 to 1995, giving the team a steady veteran presence during a stretch that still resonates with longtime supporters.
The Giants responded to the news with a statement mourning Benzinger and reflecting on what he meant to the organization. For a generation of fans, his name is tied to a memorable chapter in team history, and his death is another reminder of how quickly those familiar figures from a different era become part of the franchises memory. [Read more 🡒]
Why The Giants Still Bet Big On Willy Adames
Willy Adames arrived in San Francisco as the kind of splash signing that was supposed to anchor the Giants for years, but the early returns have been uneven at best. His offensive and defensive struggles have already become part of the conversation around the club, yet the front offices view of him clearly went well beyond what shows up on a stat sheet.
Adames has built a reputation as a strong clubhouse presence, and that seemed to matter as much as anything when the Giants committed to him on a seven-year deal. His loyalty to former teammates has stood out, too, including his outreach to Tampa Bay manager Kevin Cash about Freddy Peralta, a reminder that the Giants are betting on the person as much as the player while they wait for the rest to come around. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Prospect Dakota Jordan Is Suddenly Facing A Real Test
Dakota Jordan arrived in the Arizona Fall League with plenty of attention, and not just because MLB Pipeline had him ranked as the Giants top outfield prospect. His track record in the minors suggested a player trending up, but the fall schedule has been a tougher proving ground, with his line dipping to .208/.333/.313 and only one home run and eight RBIs to show for it. Even so, the Giants have reason to keep watching closely, because the tools that made him a notable prospect are still there, including the speed that has helped him stand out on the bases.
What makes this stretch worth monitoring is less the raw numbers than what they say about the next step in his development. The article digs into his workload, his strikeout-to-walk ratio, and how much this kind of slump should matter when the organization is trying to gauge his major league timeline. For a player who entered the fall with a stronger resume behind him, this is the kind of test that can clarify both the rough edges and the path ahead. [Read more 🡒]