The SF Giants’ season has already produced one ugly running theme: the way umpires have handled rookie manager Tony Vitello.
That pattern showed up again Saturday against the New York Mets, when Vitello went to the umpires after they ruled Turner Hill was not hit by a pitch and instead said the ball struck his bat. The replay didn’t match the call, but the decision stood. Then, almost immediately after Vitello came out of the dugout to discuss it, he was ejected.
Vitello explained the bind he feels he’s in.
“Last week I was ejected and told I was ejected because I didn’t come out of the dugout and talk. Had someone from the umpiring association tell me I should just walk out. And so, I walked out without any fire in me just to explain what was coming out of our dugout, and to calm the situation and got thrown out for walking out of the dugout.”
That leaves him with no real winning move. Stay in the dugout and he gets tossed. Step out to explain himself and he gets tossed anyway.
Last week’s ejection was followed a day later by another flare-up, when Ron Wotus was tossed while handing in the lineup card because of how poorly the umpire had called the game the night before.
The larger picture around MLB umpiring has not helped the officials’ case. Automated balls and strikes are already part of the game, and it feels increasingly likely that more and more calls will be handed over to technology. The foul ball ruling that led to Vitello’s ejection last week is the kind of play that should be reviewable through tracking data, and it’s not hard to imagine a future with a fully automated strike zone and no home plate umpire.
The recent optics have been rough elsewhere, too. In St. Louis, an umpire recently told a rookie Cardinals pitcher to straighten his cap on the mound.
Umpires have a difficult job, and there’s plenty of reason they might have limited patience for managers or players arguing with them, especially one like Vitello, who had no professional baseball experience before this year. But that doesn’t excuse what happened Saturday. Wrongful, thin-skinned ejections only make the whole group look worse, and Vitello’s latest run-in is another bad mark for the institution.
In Other News...
Giants Future Lineup Suddenly Looks Better Than This Injury Mess
The present-day Giants have spent too much time dealing with injuries to feel settled, which is why any look ahead comes with a little relief baked in. A projected 2027 lineup gives the organization a chance to imagine a more balanced roster, one built around a blend of young pieces and established names that could help San Francisco look less like a survival exercise and more like a club with real shape again.
Drew Gilbert and Jonah Cox are part of that conversation in center, with Bryce Eldridge slotted for first base or designated hitter and a catcher timeshare providing more depth behind the plate. Around them, the idea is that players such as Rafael Devers, Matt Chapman, Willy Adames and Jung Hoo Lee could give the Giants enough proven production to support the younger core if the injury luck finally starts to turn. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Rookie Already Faces One Tough Question About His Role
Matt Wilkinsons first weeks in the Giants rotation have already put a spotlight on how his stuff plays against different types of hitters. The rookie left-hander has shown a clear split in performance, and his recent start against right-handed batters was especially rough, with seven runs and three home runs allowed over three innings. For a club trying to sort out its pitching mix on the fly, those kinds of differences can quickly turn from a short-term hiccup into a bigger conversation about usage.
The Giants are still giving Wilkinson a chance to work as a starter, but the long view could depend on whether those platoon issues stick around. If right-handed hitters continue to give him trouble and lefties remain a better match, the team may have to decide whether his best value is in the rotation or in a more specialized left-on-left role. For now, the rookies place on the staff is secure enough, but the question hanging over him is the kind that can shape a season early. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Prospect Jacob Bresnahan Is Forcing His Way Into A Bigger Debate
Jacob Bresnahans rise has added another layer to a pitching pipeline that is already one of the more interesting debates in the Giants system. The left-hander spent August with the Eugene Emeralds, where he drew Northwest League Pitcher of the Month honors, and then got a late-season look at Double-A with the Richmond Flying Squirrels. For a farm system that also features Jackson Flora, Carson Bolemon, Kaden Waechter and Ramon Marquez, Bresnahans name is starting to belong in the same conversation.
What makes this particularly notable for San Francisco is how quickly Bresnahan has checked important boxes for a young starter. He has now topped 100 innings for the first time in his professional career, a meaningful marker for a pitcher trying to prove he can handle a larger workload while keeping his stuff sharp. Flora may still be viewed as the organizations top pitching prospect, but Bresnahan is making it harder to treat the hierarchy as settled. [Read more 🡒]