The Giants need stability in their rotation, and that’s exactly why Nick Pivetta looks like the wrong kind of gamble this offseason.
San Francisco is looking for a starter who can take the ball every fifth day, but ESPN’s Kiley McDaniel projects Pivetta at three years and $45 million. For a team that needs reliability more than upside, that price tag comes with too much risk.
Buster Posey told NBC Sports Bay Area’s Alex Pavlovic that he expects Adrian Houser to join Logan Webb and Landen Roupp in the Giants’ 2027 rotation. Pavlovic also reported that San Francisco plans to sign at least one starter and could leave the fifth spot to an internal competition. That means the first rotation addition has to be able to shoulder a real workload.
Pivetta’s 2025 season gave him plenty of appeal. He finished sixth in National League Cy Young Award voting after posting a 2.87 ERA across 181.2 innings for the San Diego Padres.
Last season, he put up a 2.86 ERA with 42 strikeouts and eight walks in 34.2 innings. After coming off the injured list in September, he turned in a 1.45 ERA over four starts, though each of those outings lasted five innings or fewer.
He then added 7.2 innings across two postseason appearances.
The concern is the health history. Pivetta missed nearly five months because of a right elbow flexor strain, the same injury that sidelined him in Boston in 2024.
The Padres declined his $14 million team option for 2027, which would have set him up for an $18 million player option in 2028. Even so, San Diego has since expressed interest in bringing him back on a new deal.
San Francisco’s need is obvious. The club traded Robbie Ray and Tyler Mahle at the deadline, and four young Giants starters are recovering from Tommy John surgery.
Houser is also working back from a right flexor strain. If Pivetta were to miss significant time, the Giants could wind up needing two starters from a group that includes Matt Wilkinson and Yunior Marte.
And if the innings don’t come from the rotation, they’ll have to come from a bullpen the team has already identified as an offseason priority.
Nick Martinez looks like the cleaner fit for that opening move. He logged 180 innings over 31 starts for Tampa Bay in 2026, finished with a 3.10 ERA, and issued just 26 walks.
Bleacher Report’s Tim Kelly projected Martinez at two years and $36 million. Compared with Pivetta’s projection, that would mean San Francisco spends $3 million more per season but $9 million less overall, while also taking on one fewer guaranteed year.
If the Giants do decide to circle back to Pivetta, the better path would be after they’ve already added a starter who can handle a full season. Three guaranteed years would push the workload risk through his age-36 season and leave San Francisco with less flexibility if it needs another arm later.
In Other News...
Giants Suddenly Face A Familiar Joey Bart Decision Again
Joey Bart is back on the waiver wire, and for the Giants, that immediately brings up an old question they never fully got to answer. Chicago designated Bart for assignment to clear space for Dustin May, putting the former Giants first-round pick in limbo again just as hes entering his last season of arbitration eligibility with a projected salary of about $2.9 million.
San Francisco has already moved on to a younger catching pipeline, which makes this less about nostalgia than roster math. The organization has options behind the plate and may prefer to explore veteran alternatives instead of making a claim, especially with money and roster flexibility both in play. Still, Barts availability reopens a familiar debate about whether the Giants see enough reason to bring back a player who once looked like part of their future. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Just Closed The Book On A Bullpen Story Fans Knew Well
Ryan Walkers Giants run is over, and it ends with a move that says plenty about where his stock had gone. After debuting in 2023 and working his way into the closer role, he spent the last couple of seasons fighting to recapture that form, including multiple trips to Triple-A as the Giants tried to sort out the back end of their bullpen.
Now he heads to Milwaukee in a trade that brings San Francisco two minor league pitchers, Blake Holub and Gavin Perry, while giving Walker a fresh start with a new club. For the Brewers, it is a low-cost bet on a pitcher who has already shown he can handle late-inning work, and for the Giants it closes the book on a familiar bullpen storyline that had become harder to ignore. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Face A Tough Rule 5 Call On One Young Arm
The Giants are staring at one of those front-office decisions that can quietly shape a farm system for years. With the deadline approaching to protect eligible prospects from the Rule 5 draft, San Francisco has to sort through a group that includes Blake Holub, Marty Gair and Henry LaLane, weighing who needs a spot and who might be exposed to another club. The timing makes the call even trickier, because the Rule 5 draft itself is not guaranteed to happen this offseason while Collective Bargaining Agreement talks continue.
If no new agreement is reached by December 1, a lockout could follow and leave the draft format in limbo, though the minor league phase is still expected to move ahead as scheduled. For the Giants, the uncertainty only adds another layer to an already delicate evaluation of young arms, especially when recent performance and outside interest can make a prospect more or less vulnerable than the raw talent alone suggests. [Read more 🡒]
