The Giants are staring at an important decision with Ryan Walker as the non-tender deadline on the 40-man roster creeps up on November 20. For a pitcher who has spent all four of his major league seasons in San Francisco, this one comes down to whether the front office believes there’s enough left to justify keeping him around after a rough year.
Walker, now 30, gave the Giants little reason for confidence in 2026. He was optioned to the minors three separate times, and that helped limit him to just 32.2 innings, a career low. The numbers behind that workload tell the bigger story: across 33 relief appearances, he finished with a 7.16 ERA and a 1.81 WHIP, both career worsts.
The traffic on the bases piled up quickly. Walker walked 5.2 batters per nine innings, a sharp jump from his 2.6 BB/9 in 2025, and he also gave up 11 hits per nine innings, well above his career 8.1 H/9 mark. That combination wrecked his season and turned what had once been a dependable relief profile into a mess.
The strikeouts only made the slide look worse. Walker came into the majors as a reliever who could miss bats, posting a 29.7% strikeout rate in 2023 and a 32.1% clip in 2024. That dipped to 22.6% in 2025, then cratered to 14.8% this past season.
His underlying numbers don’t offer much comfort, either. Walker’s expected ERA sits at 4.45, which is far better than his actual ERA, but his FIP is an alarming 5.52. The issue is pretty clear: he wasn’t striking out enough hitters, and he was handing out too many walks.
Even with some respectable contact management - a 34.8% hard-hit rate and a 6.3% barrel rate, both above-average marks - he still got burned by the long ball. Walker allowed a career-worst 1.4 home runs per nine innings.
That leaves the Giants with a tricky call, especially with roster crunch coming. FanGraphs projects Walker for $1.6 million in arbitration, and that number alone might not sound like much for a reliever who posted a 3.23 ERA and 1.91 ERA across his first two seasons. But San Francisco already has 51 players on the 40-man roster, and more moves are coming as the club works to protect players from the Rule 5 draft.
That roster pressure makes Walker look more vulnerable than expensive. The Giants need room, and they’re going to have to cut somewhere.
There is at least a path to bringing him back. He still has two options left, which would allow him to open 2027 in the minors and try to sort things out after this collapse. But that scenario feels unlikely.
The most realistic outcome is the simplest one: the Giants non-tender Walker and close the book on a four-year run with the organization.
In Other News...
Giants Catcher Shuffle Left One Offseason Question Impossible To Ignore
Eric Haases stop with the Giants was always built around necessity, but it still became a useful snapshot of how thin the catching depth chart got over the course of the season. Signed to a minor league deal before the 2026 campaign, Haase was pressed into service in April after Daniel Susac got hurt, then stuck around long enough to give San Francisco a veteran presence behind the plate while the roster waited for help.
The production never really followed, and the Giants moved on July 23 to clear a spot for Susacs return after Haase hit .162/.235/.365 in 74 at-bats. Haase has since landed on minor league deals with the White Sox and Braves, but his exit leaves San Francisco back where it started, with inexperienced catchers on hand and a front office that may have to hunt for a more seasoned answer this offseason. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Face A Bullpen Decision That Could Test Their Patience
When the Giants wrapped up the 2026 season, JT Brubaker stood alone as the only player on the roster with an expiring contract, and he has now officially hit free agency. Used mostly out of the bullpen, Brubaker gave San Francisco a useful stretch of innings across 41 appearances, finishing with a 3.58 ERA over 60.1 innings and giving the club another arm it could lean on in a long season.
The question now is whether that production is enough to earn a return trip to San Francisco. Brubaker is expected to draw a one-year offer worth about $3.6 million, but the Giants have plenty of pitching depth and may decide their bullpen needs can be met elsewhere, leaving a familiar but not indispensable reliever in a holding pattern as the market takes shape. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Catcher Depth Chart Is Starting To Take Shape
The Giants offseason catching picture got a little clearer after Andrew Knizner cleared waivers and was outrighted to Triple-A Sacramento. It is another small but telling move in a roster shuffle that has followed the removal of the injured list and a series of other trims, the kind of housekeeping that can quietly reshape how a team enters the winter.
Knizner still has the right to elect free agency, and he is expected to do so, which adds another layer to a position group that has been under the microscope. For San Francisco, the move helps narrow the field as the club sorts through its catching depth and tries to get a better read on what the next version of the roster will look like. [Read more 🡒]