The SF Giants have a decision to make before today’s deadline, and the Rule 5 draft could shape part of their offseason picture even if the draft itself never actually happens. The club has several eligible prospects to weigh, with Blake Holub, Marty Gair and Henry LaLane standing out as the names worth watching.
There’s still uncertainty around whether the Rule 5 draft will go forward at all. The deadline to protect players arrives before the current Collective Bargaining Agreement expires, but the draft usually doesn’t happen until the winter meetings.
If the two sides can’t reach a new agreement by December 1, baseball would head into a lockout. Last time around, the Rule 5 draft was tabled during negotiations, and that could happen again.
Even so, teams are expected to plan as if it will be held. The minor league phase, though, should proceed as scheduled.
Holub is the newest of the group, and he’s also the one the Giants have to evaluate immediately after acquiring him and Gavin Perry in the deal that sent Ryan Walker to the Milwaukee Brewers. The thinking behind that trade seems pretty clear: the Brewers likely weren’t planning to protect Holub, so they moved him before another club could grab him.
He’s a more seasoned arm than the typical Rule 5 target. A lot of players in this pool haven’t spent much time above Double-A, but Holub has logged parts of the last three seasons at Triple-A.
The right-hander is coming off a strong 2026 season with Nashville, where he put up a 2.10 ERA with 66 strikeouts and 22 walks in 55.2 innings. His delivery is extremely high, and he works primarily with a cutter-slider combination.
The slider sits in the mid 80’s and gets two-plate movement, while the cutter averages over 95 MPH. That kind of Triple-A relief success tends to draw attention in this format.
Gair brings a different kind of appeal. The Rule 5 draft is usually about balancing upside against risk, and teams tend to protect the more complete players while taking chances on traits.
Gair fits that mold. He was a 13th-round pick in 2023, but he has only 75 innings of pro experience.
In that small sample, the righty has shown swing-and-miss stuff along with a lot of walks. Across two minor league seasons, he has posted a 4.68 ERA, 1.49 WHIP, 14.9 K/9, and a 1.97 SO/W rate.
The control issues point toward a bullpen future, but the raw stuff is good enough to keep clubs interested. Gair can run his fastball into the upper 90’s with late carry up in the zone, and he pairs it with a mid 80’s slider and an upper 80’s changeup. Teams may be willing to bet on the arsenal and trust they can help him find the strike zone.
LaLane is the most experienced of the three in terms of minor league seasons, even if the innings total is still modest. He has appeared in six minor league seasons and has thrown just 242.2 innings overall. Nearly 100 of those came in 2026, when he split time between the New York Yankees and the Giants.
San Francisco got LaLane in the deal that sent Heliot Ramos to New York. The left-hander turned in a 3.16 ERA, 1.07 WHIP, 10.3 K/9, and a 3.35 SO/W rate over 21 outings, including eight appearances in High-A to close out the year.
LaLane’s 6-foot-7 frame gives him plenty of extension, and he can throw his fastball for strikes. His feel for the changeup and slider is not as advanced, though the four-seamer now sits in the mid 90’s after picking up a couple of ticks last offseason.
The Giants want to keep developing him as a starter, which means his path is still a long one. If they protect him, he may not be ready to help the big club for a while.
Another team, though, could try to speed things up by taking him in the Rule 5 draft and turning him into a reliever.
In Other News...
Giants Rotation Picture Just Got Tougher With Trevor McDonald Off Track
The Giants pitching depth took another hit this week as Trevor McDonalds rehab timeline came into focus after Tommy John surgery on Aug. 5. McDonald had worked his way into the mix with 14 starts in 2025, and even if the results were uneven, the organization had reason to keep watching a young arm that was still trying to establish itself in the rotation picture.
Now the outlook is far murkier. McDonald is expected to miss most or all of the 2026 and 2027 seasons, with a possible return not until late 2027 or 2028, a setback that changes the long-term calculus for a staff that already has plenty to sort through. He was reinstated to the 40-man roster on Nov. 2 after spending time on the 60-day injured list, but for now the Giants are left planning without one of their more intriguing pitching options. [Read more 🡒]
Buster Posey May Have Just Narrowed The Giants Pitching Market
Buster Poseys latest comments offered a pretty clear hint about how the Giants want to shop this winter. San Francisco appears reluctant to chase players attached to qualifying offers because of the draft-pick cost, a stance that lines up with the organizations emphasis on protecting its amateur pipeline and continuing to build the farm system. It also suggests the front office is trying to be disciplined about where it spends, especially as it looks to reinforce a bullpen that needs help.
For a market that already figures to be competitive, that kind of restraint matters. It narrows the pool of realistic targets and pushes the Giants toward relievers and pitchers who are not tied to those penalties, which could shape the clubs conversations in the coming weeks. Names such as Trevor Rogers, David Bednar and Adrin Morejn are part of the broader discussion, but Poseys comments make it clear the Giants may be drawing a line before the bidding even really starts. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Face A Casey Schmitt Decision That Could Reshape Second Base
Casey Schmitt enters spring training as the projected answer at second base, a notable shift for a Giants club that moved on from Luis Arraez and is still sorting out the infield picture. Schmitts final two months were wiped out by surgery, but before the injury he showed encouraging progress in both power and strikeout rate, enough to keep him in the mix as the organization weighs how best to use him.
The decision is not as simple as handing him the job and moving on. San Francisco is still exploring veteran alternatives such as Gleyber Torres or Arraez, and there is also the possibility of shifting Schmitt to left field if the roster takes shape that way. Meanwhile, prospect Marcelo Mayer could be in line for regular at-bats in Triple-A, another layer to a situation that could end up reshaping how the Giants line up on a daily basis. [Read more 🡒]
